normative

The shallow pond argument and its discharge problem

Singer's shallow-pond thought experiment shows that declining to save a drowning child to protect expensive shoes makes you a moral monster, yet ignoring a charity appeal that would save a distant child's life for the same cost is consequentially identical though socially unpunished; the limitation is that taken to its conclusion it implies you must give until you reach the level of the poor, producing a masochistic, self-negating, never-good-enough psychology.

normativepending

Speaker

Sam Harris

Evidence Quote

“it it produces a kind of you know masochistic self-judgmental life-negative uh machinery which is very different from a different kind of framing”

Source

245 - Can We Talk About Scary Ideas— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:37:04 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...