common law
A legal system in which law develops through accumulated judicial decisions and precedent rather than solely through written statutes or a codified constitution.
As defined in Michael Munger on Constitutions
Where it comes up · 8
- The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)8 claims
- A Ban On Money Into China Is Imminent, Says Nicholas Glinsman2 claims
- Don Boudreaux on Reading Hayek2 claims
- Nicholas Vincent on the Magna Carta2 claims
- Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/20062 claims
- 14 | Alta Charo on Bioethics and the Law2 claims
- Michael Munger on Constitutions1 claim
- Moshe Koppel on Norms, Tradition, and Resilient Societies1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 20Search all claims for “common law” →
- Law and legislation are fundamentally different though commonly treated as synonyms: law is that which evolves out of practice and is found, not made—analogous to market prices, the result of human action but not human design—whereas legislation is consciously designed by people invested with power to make rules governing an organization; conflating the two lets legislation borrow the sanctity that properly belongs only to law.Don Boudreaux on Reading Hayek
- The common distinction between English customary common law and continental statute/Roman law is misleading for this period, because England operated a mixed system in which Henry II's written assizes (statutes), customary law, Roman law traditions, and canon law all operated side by side, with parties using whatever law served their advantage in court.Nicholas Vincent on the Magna Carta
- Leoni introduced Hayek to the concept of common law as an alternative to legislation, so that Hayek's famous distinction between law and legislation in part owes to Leoni, by Hayek's own acknowledgment.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- Law was a major source of crown revenue because losing litigants paid fines to the King, so from Henry II onward the King drew as much business as possible into his courts, depriving great barons of their jurisdiction and putting the King in economic competition with the barons; when short of money, he inflated court fines and accepted what amounts to bribery, fueling baronial resentment.Nicholas Vincent on the Magna Carta
- Common law is judge-made law in which a judge renders a decision and articulates a principle, and that principle becomes precedent only if other judges over time find it useful for adjudicating analogous cases; legal reasoning proceeds by analogy, with adversarial disputants arguing over which precedent applies.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- Countries without written constitutions, like England and Israel, substitute an expanded interpretive tradition—analogous to Torah and Midrash, or England's common law—where analogical reasoning over a body of precedent settles cases, ideally so well that the courts only hear the genuinely unsettled cases, unlike Louis XIV's tree-side rulings that carried no precedential value.Michael Munger on Constitutions
- 'Judge-made law' is a conceptual mistake; in the common law the judge does not make law but discovers, finds, or articulates the pre-existing expectations of the parties—when a judge actually makes law he is acting as a legislator, which is the kernel of truth in conservative objections to judicial activism.Boudreaux on Law and Legislation 12/11/2006
- Leoni held that Roman/common law was something to be discovered rather than enacted, with jurists acting like scientists discovering underlying principles through reasoning—exactly parallel to Hayek's and Mises's claim that market prices deliver information about scarcity through a discovery process, with judges groping via a tâtonnement toward better, more widely applicable laws.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- Leoni's most radical and important idea is an explicit analogy: markets are to centrally planned economies as common law is to legislation; the core obstacle is not incentives but the knowledge problem—no one could possibly know enough to write a law encompassing all future circumstances, just as no planner could discover total demand and supply.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- In equilibrium there are no disputes because the path is fully paved—settled law is the absence of disputes—and there is a feedback loop whereby accumulated judicial decisions reveal to people what the shared expectations are, further reducing future disputes.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)