cigar butt investing
An investment strategy where an investor seeks out cheap, undervalued companies (with a small amount of 'value' left in them, like a discarded cigar) that can be bought at a discount, regardless of the quality of the underlying business
As defined in Charlie Munger in Conversation with Todd Combs | Singleton Prize for CEO Excellence
Other definitions
Buying deeply discounted, low-quality companies that have one puff of value left, in the style of a discarded cigar butt.
#365 Nick Sleep’s Letters: The Full Collection of the Nomad Investment Partnership Letters to PartnersBuying deeply undervalued, often struggling companies to extract the last few puffs of value, the early Buffett style.
Investing, the Last Liberal Art
Where it comes up · 9
- #364 Nick & Zak’s Excellent Adventure: How Nick Sleep and Qais Zakaria Built Their Investment Partnership4 claims
- #182 Warren Buffett (The Making of an American Capitalist)3 claims
- Investing, the Last Liberal Art2 claims
- #101 Warren Buffett (The Tao of Warren Buffett)2 claims
- Charlie Munger in Conversation with Todd Combs | Singleton Prize for CEO Excellence1 claim
- #365 Nick Sleep’s Letters: The Full Collection of the Nomad Investment Partnership Letters to Partners1 claim
- Cultivating a Disaster Resistant, Compound Interest Machine1 claim
- Constellation Software: Principled, Profitable, Permanent1 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 16Search all claims for “cigar butt investing” →
- Buffett's early career as a stock salesman, where he sold GEICO by putting most of his savings into it, pushed him toward heavy research, and he realized that cheap stocks went unbought because no one else did the work.#182 Warren Buffett (The Making of an American Capitalist)
- Charlie Munger changed Buffett's approach from buying cheap, Graham-style cigar-butt stocks toward paying a fair price for a great business, since it is better to pay a fair price for a good business than a cut-rate for a stinker.#182 Warren Buffett (The Making of an American Capitalist)
- Buffett's Graham-style cigar-butt approach, buying cheap, poor businesses for one last free puff, led him to buy Berkshire Hathaway in 1965, which he later judged a mistake, and he would have been better off never hearing of it.#100 Warren Buffett (The Snowball)
- Buffett discovered that many cheap stocks Graham recommended were not being bought by anyone, and he realized that he himself had to be the buyer, meaning investors must reach conclusions independently because no one will give them a formula.#182 Warren Buffett (The Making of an American Capitalist)
- Charlie Munger gently and consistently persuaded Buffett to move away from Graham's cigar-butt bargains toward buying exceptional businesses at fair prices, and Buffett says this insight is why Berkshire could scale.#101 Warren Buffett (The Tao of Warren Buffett)
- Nomad's early cigar-butt strategy of buying very cheap but mediocre businesses did not scale, because each rebound forced a sale and a new search for bargains, which led them to adopt Charlie Munger's view of buying higher-quality compounders.#364 Nick & Zak’s Excellent Adventure: How Nick Sleep and Qais Zakaria Built Their Investment Partnership
- Buffett's Benjamin Graham-style strategy of buying stocks below book value worked in the 1950s and early 1960s but he kept using it too long; in the late 1970s he shifted to buying exceptional businesses at reasonable prices and holding them, earning millions with the old approach and billions with the new one.#101 Warren Buffett (The Tao of Warren Buffett)
- During the 1997 Asian financial crisis, Marathon bought Southeast Asian stocks at roughly one-quarter of replacement cost, down from about 3x replacement cost before the crisis, and invested about $500 million in the region within a year, earning large returns as it rebounded.#364 Nick & Zak’s Excellent Adventure: How Nick Sleep and Qais Zakaria Built Their Investment Partnership
- In 2002 Nomad bought Stagecoach at $0.14, expecting it to be worth $0.60, sold at about $0.90, then watched the stock rise to nearly $4 as a far better business than they had realized, which made them feel like horse's asses and convinced them to stop buying cigar butts.#364 Nick & Zak’s Excellent Adventure: How Nick Sleep and Qais Zakaria Built Their Investment Partnership
- Tiger Management's approach of attracting talent and empowering specialists, which Blue Ridge carried forward, drove the investment philosophy of the Tiger Cubs more than the founder's original views.Investing, the Last Liberal Art