#365 Nick Sleep’s Letters: The Full Collection of the Nomad Investment Partnership Letters to Partners
What this covers
This episode has a single host working through the Nomad Investment Partnership letters of Nick Sleep, passage by passage, with commentary and no guest. The letters alternate between portfolio theory and case studies of companies Nomad owned, chiefly Costco and Amazon.
The Costco material is the most concrete. The store is fixed at about 4,000 SKUs, shelf slots go to the supplier offering the best value, and vendors must quote their lowest price. Jim Sinegal refused a higher markup on designer jeans bought at $22, because one breach invites repeated breaches. This anchors the idea of Scale Economies Shared. The Amazon section covers Jeff Bezos's argument that price elasticity math cannot justify cutting prices year after year. It also covers Nomad's call at the end of 2004 that Amazon, then valued at $18 billion, would outgrow eBay at $77 billion. Online sales were 3.1 percent of U.S. retail in 2006, and Amazon's 2008 holiday orders rose 16 percent while the industry fell 10.
Portfolio construction is where the episode turns contentious. The letters call diversification a misguided "church," cite Kelly Criterion Sizing to suggest Nomad was not concentrated enough, and propose inverting portfolio construction. That means starting at 100 percent in the best idea and working down, as Walton, Gates, Carnegie, and Rockefeller effectively did. The episode also covers Charlie Munger's cancer surgery approach, illustrated by Coca-Cola's shrimp-farm-and-winery years before its tenfold rise. A Baltimore fund that sold IBM and Walmart too early shows the cost of selling a great company. The letters also claim that the best investors are entrepreneurs who never sold, and that companies behaving well because they want to are preferable to those that must.
The host argues that Nick Sleep's Nomad partnership letters show great investors and founders succeed by concentrating on a few deeply understood businesses, sharing scale gains with customers, and holding long-term positions, while the typical investor's short-term focus and diversification cause costly mistakes.
- Businesses that share scale efficiencies with customers compound value over decades, and few companies do this
- Concentration in a few well-understood businesses is safer than diversification, because few things can be known for sure
- Investors repeatedly sell great compounders too early, so patience and inaction are a source of advantage
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
If knowledge is the source of value added and only a few things can be known for sure, then owning more stocks does not lower risk but raises it, so the 'church of diversification' is misguided.
“owning more stocks does not lower risk but raises it.”
Costco fixes its store at about 4,000 SKUs and auctions each shelf slot to the supplier offering the best value, and requires vendors to quote their lowest price consistently, discontinuing any vendor that does not.
“the number of items in a store, so the SKUs, are fixed at 4,000, and the right to fill one of those spaces is auctioned with the supplier”
Bezos argued that lowering prices year after year cannot be justified by short-term price elasticity math, because short-term volume gains never pay for price cuts, but consistent low prices create a virtuous cycle of larger long-term free cash flow.
“With rare exceptions, the volume increase in the short term is never enough to pay for the price decrease.”
Using the Kelly Criterion, if one is certain of being right one should invest the entire portfolio in that idea, and since almost no investors do this, Nomad's portfolio concentration was likely too low.
“if one is certain of being right, one should invest the entire portfolio in that idea.”
Applied effort has a convex output curve, so an extra hour on the current project yields much more than an hour on something new, which makes the opportunity cost of switching to new areas high unless the new area is incredibly valuable.
“Focusing on one thing yields increasing returns for each unit of effort.”
Economic research commonly takes observations over a short period as if cause and effect sat on top of each other, a blind spot that obscures how long-term strategies such as price cuts create value.
“there's a blind spot as the overwhelming methodology for research and economics has been to take observations over a short period of time as if cause and effect sit on top of each other.”
If share prices are set by investors looking at the next data point, they cannot also be looking out for long-term value, so the traders who have many small ideas leave Nomad with one big idea.
“If the share price is being set by those with an eye on the next data point, then they can't also be looking out for the long-term value.”
Investors repeatedly make the mistake of selling great companies too early, illustrated by a Baltimore fund that sold IBM in the 1950s and Walmart in the 1970s, when holding those shares would have been worth more than the fund management company itself.
“In the 1950s, a large Baltimore-based fund management company sold their client shares in IBM only for the shares to appreciate”
During the 2008 holiday season Amazon's order volumes were up 16 percent year-over-year while the overall retail industry was down 10 percent, showing that scale economics work in bad times as well as good.
“order volumes at Amazon were 16% higher than the previous year compared to the overall retail industry, which were down 10%.”
Amazon's high-street competitors could price at net income breakeven and still not undercut Amazon, so for them the game was over, as customers respond to consistently low prices and convenience by leaking revenue to efficient rivals.
“Amazon's high-street peers could price their products at net income breakeven and still not undercut Amazon's prices or profitability. For these high street competitors, the game is over.”
Because power laws are very high on the internet, businesses like Amazon could become far bigger, quicker, and more profitable than their physical-world equivalents, and self-funding growth plus rising barriers to entry widen their moats as they scale.
“the giant advantage that Amazon has over Costco is that on the Internet, power law is very high.”
In the mid-1980s Coca-Cola had become a poorly defined conglomerate with a shrimp farm, winery, and film studio; after the poorer businesses were cut away to reveal the syrup manufacturing and marketing core, the shares rose over tenfold in the following decade.
“As the poorer businesses were cut away, to reveal the jewel that is syrup manufacturing and marketing operation, the shares of Coca-Cola rose over ten-fold in the succeeding decade.”
Instead of building a diversified portfolio from zero upward, one can invert the approach by starting at 100 percent in the best idea and working down, which is how founders invest.
“The other way to construct a portfolio that's different from how other people do it is to invert and start at 100% weighting and work down.”
Although eBay appeared to be the leading internet retailer in the early 2000s, with a market cap of $77 billion against Amazon's $18 billion at the end of 2004, Nomad judged that Amazon, not eBay, was the company that would become the dominant internet business.
“the market cap of Amazon when Nick Sleep is discovering this earn secret was $18 billion”
Online sales were 3.1 percent of all U.S. retail sales in 2006, so Nomad asked skeptics how large e-commerce would be in ten years and argued that Amazon was still early in its growth.
“the answer to that second question is 3.1% of all retail sales happened online in the year 2006.”
Sam Walton, Bill Gates, Andrew Carnegie, and John D. Rockefeller did not make their money through diversification; their portfolios were more or less 100 percent in one company, and they did not consider it risky.
“Sam Walton did not make his money through diversifying his holdings, nor did Bill Gates, Andrew Carnegie or John D. Rockefeller.”
There are only two reasons companies behave well, because they want to and because they have to, and Nomad preferred to invest in companies that want to, since such companies would eventually make the investor's job unnecessary.
“There are only two reasons companies behave well, because they want to and because they have to. Our preference is to invest in those that want to.”
Munger's cancer surgery approach holds that most companies have a jewel at their heart that management has taken for granted while funding new ventures, and that as less successful projects dilute the jewel, aggregate performance declines, so cutting the poor parts can unlock value.
“This often works because there is normally a jewel at the heart of most companies that has often been used to fund new ventures.”
Costco bought two million pairs of designer jeans at $22, about $10 less than before, and a buyer proposed a higher-than-usual markup since no one would notice, but Jim Sinegal insisted on the standard markup, arguing that breaking the low-price contract once would lead to repeated breaches.
“If I let you do it this one time, you'll do it again. The contract with the customer, which is very low prices, must not be broken.”
Most companies pursue scale efficiencies but few share them, and Costco's model of returning cost savings to customers lowers prices, drives further revenue growth, and lifts the performance of older stores, making competition with it very hard.
“Most companies pursue scale efficiencies, but few share them. It's the sharing that makes the model so powerful. The company grows by giving back.”
The best investors aren't investors at all; they are entrepreneurs who never sold, and the biggest mistake an investor can make is selling a stock that goes on to rise tenfold, not owning something into bankruptcy.
“The best investors aren't investors at all. They're entrepreneurs who never sold.”
When studying great businesses, success often traces to simple human attributes, such as how a consumer feels drinking a Coke or receiving a delivery that goes the extra mile, and these human responses have hardly changed in millennia.
“the reason you have these feelings and the stimuli that produce them, have hardly changed in millennia.”
Amazon's decision to lower prices goes against short-term math, and while elasticity can predict this week's or quarter's effect, no one can estimate the effect of consistently lower prices on the business over five or ten years.
“We can estimate what a price reduction will do this week and this quarter. But we cannot estimate the effect that consistently lowering prices will have on our business over 5 or 10 years.”
The best investors are not investors at all but entrepreneurs who never sold, because their love for the business leads them to focus on building something great rather than maximizing short-term returns, so the best financial decision is sometimes not a financial decision.
“The best investors aren't investors at all. They're entrepreneurs who never sold.”
Being good at investing is a very rare skill that is not distributed widely and never will be, and the difference is largely behavioral rather than analytical.
“Being good at investing is a very rare skill. It is not distributed widely and will never be. And that has to do with behavior.”
Choosing not to act on a holding is itself a decision, one taken every day, and it is arguably harder than acting because people are naturally wired to take action.
“Each day Buffett chose not to do anything was a decision taken to.”
Good capital allocation does not require growth; a firm that writes insurance only when pricing is good and steps back when it is poor, as National Indemnity does, shows capital discipline, and few companies have the strength to sit out.
“Surprisingly, few companies have the strength to just sit it out.”
The business model that built the Ford empire a century ago also built Sam Walton's Walmart, Herb Kelleher's Southwest, and Jeff Bezos's Amazon, and it will build empires in the future too.
“It is interesting to note that the business model that built the Ford empire 100 years ago is the same that built Sam Waltons in the 1970s, Herb Kelleher's in the 1990s, or Jeff Bezos' today, and it will build empires in the future too.”
Founders like Jim Sinegal always do what is better for the customer, because doing so over the long term is what is better for the company, whereas managers who optimize for short-term company gains erode the customer contract.
“What Jim Sinegal and other great founders do is they always do what's better for the customer because if you do that over the long term that is then what is better for the company.”
Sol Price's 1967 memo said margin must never be done at the expense of the company's philosophy and that the focus should be on how cheap things can be brought to people rather than how much the traffic will bear, a principle Costco still follows.
“Let us concentrate on how cheap we can bring things to the people rather than how much the traffic will bear.”
Math-based decisions command wide agreement, while judgment-based decisions are debated, and an institution unwilling to endure controversy will limit itself to math-based decisions, which limits innovation and long-term value creation.
“Any institution unwilling to endure controversy must limit itself to decisions of the first type.”
The central engine of Walmart's success was a thrift orientation, meaning low cost and low waste that funded growth by sharing savings with customers, and understanding that engine is the deep reality of the business.
“the central engine of success at Walmart was a thrift orientation, so low cost, low waste, fueling growth with the savings shared with the customer.”
Nick and Zak had four choices for capital: add to existing holdings, invest in new businesses, invest in growth businesses, or buy cigar butts, and after reading 1,000 annual reports and interviewing 300 companies they overwhelmingly preferred existing businesses.
“We had 4 main choices, one, we can add to our existing holdings. Two, we can invest in new businesses. Three, we can invest in growth businesses. Or four, we can invest in cigar butts.”
Successful investors and founders must be willing to be misunderstood and to do things that do not seem sensible to most people, guided by an internal compass that points to what is right for the customer rather than by competitors' actions.
“you have to be willing to be misunderstood, okay, go on, this's been a main theme in the last month, and do things that do not seem sensible to most people.”
Cultures that care about small details all the time are very hard to create, and according to Jeff Bezos they are almost impossible to create if they are not put in place at the firm's genesis.
“Cultures that care about the little things all the time are very hard to create and in the opinion of Jeff Bezos, almost impossible to create if not put in place at the firm's genesis.”
To avoid selling great companies, an investor must analyze the underlying engine of success rather than the outputs, and view an investment as an evolving compounding machine instead of a static balance sheet.
“One must see an investment not as a static balance sheet, but as an evolving compounding machine.”
Nomad keeps a list of super high-quality thinkers, companies whose intellectually honest, economically rational managers allocate capital with discipline, and this list is the terminal portfolio the fund wants to converge toward.
“We call this the terminal portfolio. This is where we want to go.”
Nomad kept a list of 'super high-quality thinkers', 15 businesses that allocate capital with discipline, and called the portfolio made from them the terminal portfolio, which is where Nomad wanted to go; the gap between that list and Nomad's actual holdings showed its actions lagged its thinking.
“We call this 'the terminal portfolio.' This is where we want to go.”
Nomad called itself an Investment Partnership rather than a fund because it sought a different relationship with investors, and the aggregate patience of its investor base was meant to be a competitive advantage over short-term peers.
“One of Nomad's key advantages will be the aggregate patience of its investor base. We are genuinely investing for the long term, few are.”
Nick and Zak did not copy their peers; they built their business from the outcome of their own thinking, and their willingness to trust their own judgment let them discover a valuable earned secret and reshape their partnership around it.
“they didn't copy their peers. Nick and Zak ran their business based on the outcome of their own thinking”
If an idea is the single best thought you have ever had, it should dominate everything you do, because insights of that quality are rare and dividing attention across many projects dilutes returns.
“If it's the single best thought you've ever had in your life, it needs to dominate everything because you're not going to get many insights like that.”
Nomad bet that over the next decade some super-high-quality thinkers would become cheap enough to buy, so the work of identifying them must be done today to be ready when prices pull back.
“The trick is to do the work today so that we are ready.”
A company's leader must keep the whole organization committed to a common goal, and Costco commits to its every-day-low-pricing strategy every minute, so the strategy is embedded in daily operations rather than being a slogan.
“Costco's common goal is that we are going to commit to this every-day-low-pricing strategy. And they commit to it every single minute of every single hour of every single day”
Nomad's key edge would be the aggregate patience of its investor base, because only by looking further out than the short-term crowd can an investor expect to beat it.
“One of Nomad's key advantages will be the aggregate patience of its investor base. We are genuinely investing for the long term, few are.”
Costco's low margins, criticized by investors, are deliberate: the firm defers profits today to extend the life of its franchise, so low margin is not a sign of weakness.
“The firm is deferring profits today in order to extend the life of the franchise.”
The most valuable company in the world would have a huge marketplace for size, high barriers to entry for longevity, and very low capital employed for free cash flow, and Costco has some of these traits while the internet offers an even lighter model.
“Such a firm would have a huge marketplace that would offer size. They would have high barriers to entry, which would offer longevity, and very low levels of capital employed, which would offer free cash flow.”
Li Lu advised investors to be a learning machine and to study a single company for years, such as spending 15 years understanding an American company to find its Asian counterpart, because deep preparation makes the investor faster later.
“You have to be a learning machine. You have to be doing the work now.”
Munger's talk on the psychology of human misjudgment is the most useful investing talk, because investment mistakes come from human behavior rather than from a lack of analytical technique.
“the best talk on investing wasn't about investing. And it was Charlie Munger's talk, The Psychology Of Human Mis-judgment.”
In late 2008 Amazon was priced in the market as if it would not grow despite some of the best growth prospects imaginable, a very rare combination that Nomad saw as a buying opportunity during the panic.
“In the last few months, Amazon has been priced in the market as if it would not grow in the future despite some of the best growth prospects we can imagine.”
Costco's operating costs are very low, measured in basis points, reflecting a paranoia about costs that keeps prices competitive.
“operating costs are low, indeed very low. It is indicative of the paranoia with which the company has run that costs are measured in basis points.”
Nick Sleep judged Costco to be a cost-disciplined, intellectually honest, high-integrity perpetual motion machine trading at a discount to value, and he expected the partnership to do quite well.
“Costco is a cost-disciplined, intellectually honest, high-product integrity, perpetual motion machine trading at a discount to value. I think we will do quite well.”
Buffett's principle that time is a friend of the wonderful business and an enemy of the mediocre means that owning high-quality compounders early allows investors to do nothing else.
“Time is a friend of the wonderful business and the enemy of the mediocre.”
Jeff Bezos's line that your margin is my opportunity explains why Costco and Amazon were both criticized for thin margins at the time, although the thin margins were the strategic point.
“one of Jeff Bezos' most famous quotes is that 'Your margin is my opportunity.'”
Sam Walton was not maximizing returns on his stock but building something great that served people over a long period, which shows that the best financial decision is sometimes not a financial decision at all.
“sometimes it turns out that the best financial decision is not a financial decision at all.”
The founder's role is to be the guardian of the company's soul, and Bezos's decision to relentlessly return efficiency gains to customers is an example of that role.
“The founder is the guardian of the company's soul.”
In Nomad's view only a few things in life are knowable, which is why Nomad holds just a few investments.
“in our opinion, just a few things in life are knowable. And it is because just a few things are knowable that Nomad has just a few investments.”
During Disneyland's construction, Walt Disney insisted on keeping the leather straps on the stagecoaches despite time pressure, showing the same refusal to compromise quality for short-term gain that Sinegal displayed at Costco.
“You're being a poor communicator. People are okay. Don't you ever forget that.”
At the end of 2004, Amazon's market capitalization was $18 billion while eBay's was $77 billion, a gap that made the case for Amazon look silly in hindsight but was widely accepted that Amazon had no chance against eBay.
“the market cap of Amazon when Nick Sleep is discovering this earn secret was $18 billion”
Steve Jobs advised Nike's Mark Parker to get rid of the less successful products and focus on the good ones, which mirrors the idea that a company's core jewel is diluted by weaker projects.
“Just get rid of the c***** stuff and focus on the good stuff.”
Sometimes what you are looking for is right in front of you, illustrated by oil reportedly found under Exxon's own Irving, Texas headquarters, so if Exxon can make that mistake, anyone can.
“Sometimes what you are looking for is right in front of you. If Exxon can make that mistake, we all can.”
Opportunities in which one is comfortable deploying capital are rare, and the highest conviction idea is the rarest of them all, so the real question is how much to invest in each idea.
“opportunities in which we are comfortable to deploy capital are rare and the highest conviction idea is the rarest of them all.”
Good investing and good business decisions are synonymous, so an investor would run a good fund as Bezos runs Amazon.
“I think Bezos would run a good investment fund, but that is the point, good investing and good business decisions are synonymous.”
Li Lu said he spent no time worrying about what other investors do and instead spent all his time studying great companies and industries, which the host argues is the approach Nomad followed.
“I don't spend any time worrying about what other investors do. I spend all my time studying great companies and studying great industries.”
After Amazon's share price doubled, Nomad asked whether selling it would be the equivalent mistake of selling Walmart in 1980, illustrating how easy it is to take profits on a compounder.
“would selling Amazon today be the equivalent mistake of selling Walmart in 1980?”
Clients asked about Nomad's holding in Northwest Airlines rather than its early sale of Apple, but selling Apple has cost Nomad more.
“We got questions about our holding in Northwest Airlines rather than the sale of Apple earlier this year, but selling Apple has cost us more.”
Spreading five minutes each across twelve new projects is worse than one focused hour on an existing one, so effort should be concentrated before taking on something new.
“an extra hour of focus on the current project has a much higher return than an hour on something new or worse 5 minutes each on 12 new things.”
Few companies with poor economics have the strength to sit out a bad market, and when Nomad asks why they want to grow, management answers as if they would like to grow so they can lose even more money.
“Surprisingly, few companies have the strength to just sit it out.”
Reading the letters chronologically shows Sleep slowly figuring out his core idea, the same way a biography shows a person struggling toward their main purpose, and he did not yet realize he was describing the cancer surgery approach.
“Nick doesn't understand he's describing the cancer surgery approach. He's describing Coca-Cola.”
As far as Nomad knows, only the early Buffett partnership portfolios had anyone near this level of concentration, and mainly in companies where Buffett was a controlling shareholder.
“As far as we are aware, only the early Buffett partnership portfolios had anyone near this level of concentration”
Nomad's manager made an early mistake by not buying enough Costco, since the fund's position was too small given how strong the company was.
“Your manager has already made his first mistake in investing in Costco from not buying enough.”
The partnership's Stagecoach investment succeeded because the founder returned after new management ran the business into the ground and the firm pursued a shrinking strategy rather than growth.
“the Partnership's successful investment in Stagecoach has been due to the firm's shrinking strategy, not its growth.”
Ideas that work today also worked in the past and will build empires in the future, and that durability is why the host believes studying these letters is worthwhile.
“these ideas that work today, they worked in the past, and they will build empires in the future too.”
Nomad's client performance was the capitalization of the success of the companies it invested in, so the real work was done by Buffett and the good people at Berkshire rather than by Nomad's managers.
“As time goes by, the performance that our clients have received is the capitalization of the success of the firms in which we have invested.”
When asked about the early 1990s recession, Sam Walton said he had thought about it and decided not to participate, a stance the host compares to Amazon's 2008 growth despite the crisis.
“I've thought about it and I decided not to participate.”
In 2002 Nick Sleep began articulating scale economies shared as the partnership's single best thought, the idea that would dominate everything they did, and the partnership's understanding of it developed over many years.
“he starts talking about this new idea of scale economy shared, which is going to be their earn secret, the single best thought that they ever had”
The host's wife's family has shopped at Costco for almost 30 years and is extremely committed to the company.
“my wife's family has been shopping there for almost 30 years.”