ceteris paribus
Latin for 'other things being equal'; a hedge attached to special-science generalizations that hold only under unspecified normal conditions.
As defined in 215 | Barry Loewer on Physics, Counterfactuals, and the Macroworld
Other definitions
Latin for all else held constant; used to isolate the effect of one variable.
Matthew Smith — Natural Gas: The Next Bottleneck - [Invest Like the Best, EP.483]
Where it comes up · 6
- Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism4 claims
- Impact and ESG Investing2 claims
- 42 - Racism And Violence In America2 claims
- Daniel Carpenter1 claim
- David Brady on the 2012 US Election1 claim
- 215 | Barry Loewer on Physics, Counterfactuals, and the Macroworld1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “ceteris paribus” →
- Aggregate racial statistics are inadequate for assessing whether an individual police shooting was racially caused, just as an aggregate gender pay gap cannot tell you whether a specific woman was paid unfairly for the same work; you need individualized, encounter-level data comparing like with like, not comparisons of aggregate rates across large collectivities.42 - Racism And Violence In America
- Roland Fryer's logistic-regression analysis of Houston police data, controlling for the observable features of each encounter, found that the likelihood of a police officer shooting a suspect was no greater—and slightly less—when the suspect was black, while the use of non-lethal force was about 25% greater against black suspects, other things equal.42 - Racism And Violence In America
- 'Capture' is too seductive a term—thrown around whenever a pundit dislikes a regulatory decision—but it is orthogonal to whether an agency does a good or efficient job, and it is genuinely hard to prove because you need a counterfactual of an uncaptured agency ceteris paribus, while existing empirical studies suffer from omitted-variable bias.Daniel Carpenter
- The other-things-held-constant assumption only works for small periods and stylized examples like a single price change affecting demand; for large questions—such as how average incomes and living standards evolved over the last 40–50 years in the United States—so many things have not been held constant that no coherent, uncontroversial answer is possible.Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism
- If the Mentaculus already specifies the probabilities of everything, including all truths of the special sciences, then the special sciences add no new laws or probabilities to physics; instead they identify which features of the world to conditionalize on so that conditionalizing yields regularities in other features that interest us, characterizing existing Mentaculus probabilities in new and useful ways (often hedged with ceteris paribus clauses).215 | Barry Loewer on Physics, Counterfactuals, and the Macroworld
- The major flaw in economic analysis is not its handling of distributional effects in trade (Roberts is partly arguing against a straw man, since few economists deny caring about distribution) but its failure to incorporate the social determinants of economic outcomes—for example, ten years after the Financial Crisis there is no real consensus on what happened, partly because much of it was social contagion, which economists' other-things-equal framework simply cannot address.Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism
- Although the sociological view that behavior is socially determined is closer to correct than economics' treatment of people as atomistic individuals, economics appears to work better because it makes superior use of the ceteris paribus (other-things-held-constant) assumption, allowing accurate predictions—whereas sociologists either see blooming confusion or apply a single oppressor/oppressed model to everything.Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism
- The widely accepted claim that the average American has made very little progress over the last 40 years is misleading because it fails to account for things that changed dramatically over that period—the marriage rate, how inflation is measured, the composition of the labor force, and demographic and educational changes—making the question far more complicated than the 'settled' consensus suggests.Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism
- Early neoclassical economics set aside broader questions with the 'ceteris paribus' assumption, and its early authors intended to return to them, but the field ran narrowly ahead without doing so.Impact and ESG Investing
- Early neoclassical economics used ceteris paribus to set aside important factors such as human wellbeing, climate, and governance, knowingly, and early authors wanted those factors brought back eventually; ESG tools now let the field return to them.Impact and ESG Investing