David Brady on the 2012 US Election
What this covers
David Brady, a Stanford political scientist, joins Russ Roberts to examine the 2012 presidential race through the lens of structural fundamentals and campaign mechanics. Brady surveys Economic Forecasting Models of Elections—work by Doug Hibbs and Ray Fair—which signal trouble for the incumbent President Obama, yet he argues that current electoral college positioning and demographic realities give Obama a narrow advantage. The crux of the election, Brady contends, rests not on the controversies dominating cable news but on inattentive independent voters and which campaign better controls the election's frame.
Brady details why media-driven "issues of the week" rarely move votes: weekly polling shows roughly 45 percent of voters have not even heard the latest controversy, and those who have report it will not affect their choice. More consequentially, Partisan Sorting has created a paradox—fewer Americans identify as Democrats or Republicans, yet those remaining are more ideologically pure and polarized, making the large, inattentive independent middle decisive. Mitt Romney must keep the election a Referendum vs. Choice Election Framing on Obama's record to win; any shift toward scrutinizing Romney's background, his time at Bain, or his wealth allows Obama to paint him unacceptable. Brady also examines how Issue Ownership has fractured—Obama now holds substantial leads on foreign policy among independents—and explains why the vice-presidential selection and late-summer polling matter far less than campaigns assume when economic conditions force a close race.
Brady argues that although economic fundamentals favor the challenger Romney, current polling and electoral-college math give Obama a slight edge, and the outcome hinges on the inattentive independent vote and the quality of each campaign rather than the hot-button issues that dominate media coverage.
- Economic models (Hibbs, Fair) show a close race with the incumbent in trouble, but Democrats hold a partisan-identification edge that forces Republicans to win ~60% of independents.
- Most voters, especially independents, pay little attention to the media's 'issue of the week,' so those controversies rarely move votes.
- Romney must keep the election a referendum on Obama ('I'm not Obama') to win, while Obama must make Romney unacceptable.
Romney's refusal to release tax returns allows Obama campaign to build unchallenged negative portrait.
- Romney's unwillingness to release his tax returns is damaging—analogous to not testifying at one's own trial—because it lets the Obama campaign keep building a negative portrait (Bain, outsourcing, tax returns) that keeps the focus on Romney rather than the President.
“If the election gets to be a referendum on the President's four years, the President loses. If the election gets turned around to be on whether Romney could replace him, then that puts Romney in trouble.”
The electoral college makes winning the popular vote irrelevant to presidential election outcomes.
- Because of the electoral college, the election is decided not by the popular vote but by key swing states—analogous to baseball where run differential doesn't determine wins—so a president can win re-election without taking the popular vote.
“just as a baseball team can have a winning record even though it's outscored, a President can win re-election if he doesn't take the popular vote. So, what matters is the key swing states.”
Voters lack the counterfactual reasoning skills to credit Obama's economic policies without direct experience.
- Obama's claim that the economy would have been worse without his policies is a hard sell because the average voter is not good at counterfactual reasoning—unlike economists—so statistical evidence that things would have been worse will not persuade on the campaign trail.
“The average person is not as good at counterfactuals as the average economist, so to say it would have been worse and we have statistical evidence that it would have been worse, I think is a very tough sell on a campaign trail.”
Academic position at University of Chicago restricts personal freedom in ways like hunting.
- Once you've been an academic they don't really allow you to hunt, especially not at the University of Chicago.
“Once you've been an academic they don't really allow you to hunt.”