factual
Special Sciences Find Probabilities, Don't Add Them
If the Mentaculus already specifies the probabilities of everything, including all truths of the special sciences, then the special sciences add no new laws or probabilities to physics; instead they identify which features of the world to conditionalize on so that conditionalizing yields regularities in other features that interest us, characterizing existing Mentaculus probabilities in new and useful ways (often hedged with ceteris paribus clauses).
factualpending
Speaker
Barry LoewerEvidence Quote
“Special scientists... don't add any laws to the laws of physics in a certain sense, and they don't add any probabilities, to the probabilities of physics from statistical mechanics, what they do is they find them and characterize them in new and interesting ways.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:02:57 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...