category mistake
An error of attributing a property to something that cannot logically possess it, such as ascribing values to an entity that has none
As defined in AMA | October 2023
Where it comes up · 6
- Steven Pinker1 claim
- 36 | David Albert on Quantum Measurement and the Problems with Many-Worlds1 claim
- AMA | October 20231 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 12 Aristotle's God1 claim
- Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Pascal, Pensses1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 78 Ordinary Language Philosophy1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “category mistake” →
- Gilbert Ryle argues that philosophical problems like realism vs idealism and freedom vs determinism are false dilemmas arising from category mistakes where words are used in two different categories, creating apparent disputes over territory that language covers.A History of Philosophy | 78 Ordinary Language Philosophy
- Talking about aligning AI values with human values may involve a category mistake because it is not clear that current AI systems have values in any meaningful sense; furthermore, since humans hold pluralistic and conflicting values, the very goal of 'aligning to human values' is underspecified and requires deciding whose values and how to reconcile them.AMA | October 2023
- Hume's claim that reason is a slave to the passions was primarily a conceptual point—that deduction from A to B cannot tell you what B (your goals) should be, since goals are logically distinct from beliefs—rather than a psychological claim that people are permanently irrational; people can be made more rational through inquiry, science, and exposing fallacies.Steven Pinker
- Aristotle's ten categories (substance, quality, qualification, relationship, where, when, being in a position, having, doing, being affected) represent the basic ways in which terms can signify in thought, and in logical reasoning one must not switch categories mid-argument, as such category mistakes would equivocate and undermine the logical chain.A History of Philosophy | 12 Aristotle's God
- An electron in a superposition of positions is not in some definite location we are merely ignorant of; rather there is no fact of the matter about its position at all, analogous to asking about the marital status of the number 5 — a category mistake rather than missing information.36 | David Albert on Quantum Measurement and the Problems with Many-Worlds
- Pascal distinguishes between two kinds of knowledge: knowledge in which antiquity or tradition is absolute (law, theology, history) where reason should not be applied, and knowledge in which reason is absolute (mathematics, natural science) where tradition should not be invoked; any argument from authority is contrary to the nature of mathematical or scientific thinking.Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Pascal, Pensses