benevolence
In ethics, a virtue or sentiment characterized by wishing well for others and desiring to promote their welfare and happiness
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics
Where it comes up · 2
- A History of Philosophy | 49 Reactions to David Hume6 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics5 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “benevolence” →
- Benevolence develops from sympathy, which involves feeling pleasure with another or pain with another, grounded in the association principle of resemblance—when you recognize similarities between your experience and another's, you form complex ideas involving both, and thereby feel not just for yourself but for the other.A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics
- There are two distinct types of ethical intuition: (1) intuitionism about overall principles (principles like 'benevolence' are known intuitively) and (2) intuitionism about particular cases (specific actions are known to be right/wrong intuitively).A History of Philosophy | 49 Reactions to David Hume
- Ethical subjectivism means that when we judge something wrong, we are expressing our own subjective feeling or sentiment about it, not reporting an objective fact—when I say 'it's terrible that you suffered,' I am really saying 'I suffer when I think of your suffering,' not that some objective wrongness inheres in your suffering.A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics
- If we recognize that we get satisfaction from seeing others prosper and pain from seeing them suffer, we must acknowledge that self-interest and benevolence are not opposing forces; therefore, the egoist response that benevolence reduces to self-interest (because benevolence satisfies us) is diffused and loses its force.A History of Philosophy | 49 Reactions to David Hume
- Hume argues against Hobbes's claim that humans are naturally egoistic and selfish 'ravenous beasts,' contending instead that there is a natural benevolence and altruism present in all human beings, though it varies in degree, and this natural benevolence is the foundation for moral sentiment and ethical obligation.A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics
- Joseph Butler identifies conscience as one of four god-given mental propensities of the human mind: particular passions (desires for specific objects like food or sex), self-love (self-interest), benevolence (care for others), and conscience (which balances self-love and benevolence).A History of Philosophy | 49 Reactions to David Hume
- Hume grounds moral obligation in sentiment, particularly in the sentiment of benevolence—a universal, natural feeling in which people naturally want what is good for others—which contrasts with pure egoism like that of Thomas Hobbes.A History of Philosophy | 49 Reactions to David Hume
- A biblical ethic can be universalist without being absolutist; it can emphasize universal principles (like benevolence, justice, mercy) while allowing that particular applications may vary contextually and may even have tragic exceptions (like capital punishment in the Old Testament).A History of Philosophy | 49 Reactions to David Hume
- The common ground between reason and sentiment in ethics is utility: reason describes consequences and appeals to utility, while sentiment is based on benevolence (wishing what is good for others) which naturally motivates concern for utility and the common good.A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics
- For Hume, reason's role in ethics is limited to two functions: providing definitions of moral terms and relations of ideas (like defining justice, comparing benevolence and self-interest), and describing factual circumstances and consequences of actions, but reason cannot approve or disapprove actions, cannot justify appeals to utility or consequences, and cannot motivate action.A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics