atelic
Describing an activity without a goal or endpoint; in Setiya's usage, an activity valued for itself, though Callard notes a 'bad' sense meaning genuinely pointless or having no value at all.
As defined in Agnes Callard on Meaning, the Human Quest, and the Aims of Education
Where it comes up · 4
- Kieran Setiya on Midlife5 claims
- 295 - Philosophy And The Good Life3 claims
- Agnes Callard on Meaning, the Human Quest, and the Aims of Education2 claims
- Les Snead on Risk, Decisions, and Football1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “atelic” →
- Aristotle distinguishes energeia (an activity like seeing or enjoying that is completed at every moment, achieving its end continuously) from kinesis (a movement that arrives at an end only later); energeiai are not goalless—their goal is internal to them rather than external—so they differ from truly atelic, pointless activities that have no end or value at all.Agnes Callard on Meaning, the Human Quest, and the Aims of Education
- Career sustainability and fulfillment in a high-pressure job come from being in love with the atelic process--the systems, day-to-day doing--rather than being addicted to the results; the longer one's tenure, the more this orientation matters for lasting in the role.Les Snead on Risk, Decisions, and Football
- Telic activities (from telos, end) incorporate a terminal point and are completed—pursuing them defers satisfaction to the future or archives it in the past and engaging with them extinguishes them—whereas atelic activities (parenting, being in a relationship, reflecting) have no built-in endpoint and are fully realized in the present; an excessive investment in telic projects obscures the present value of atelic activities.295 - Philosophy And The Good Life
- One can change one's relationship to projects retrospectively because atelic activities can piggyback on telic ones—the activity of reflecting on and mulling over a completed project has no endpoint and can continue indefinitely—so gratitude practices and therapy exploit this shift, refusing to let projects be mere projects and putting the temporal structure of one's life partly under one's own control.295 - Philosophy And The Good Life
- As one's life becomes a harmony between getting things done (telic) and enjoying the process (atelic), the distinction between work and play breaks down because one is doing what one is happy to be doing; the goal is to make more of life resemble play—activity pursued for its intrinsic enjoyment—while still recognizing the additional satisfaction available retrospectively in having completed things.295 - Philosophy And The Good Life
- Faced with the pyramid scheme problem, there are two responses: either meaning is inherently present now and internally complete (the Setiya/Stoppard/Nietzsche internalist view, like the sunset example), or, if we grant genuine dependence on future generations, then the shared activity must be telic—genuinely going somewhere with a real destination—because there is a project we have partly done that we want them to continue.Agnes Callard on Meaning, the Human Quest, and the Aims of Education
- Philosophy can function as a kind of cognitive therapy—descended from Stoic thinking about the emotions—but instead of targeting mistaken beliefs about whether others like you, it targets mistaken beliefs about how you relate to time and where the value of your activities lies; the cognitive correction can sometimes help, though the affective follow-through often lags behind the intellectual recognition.Kieran Setiya on Midlife
- Schopenhauer held that desire is futile because wanting something you lack is painful and achieving it leaves you empty, leaving no escape; Setiya argues this is wrong because Schopenhauer failed to conceptualize atelic activities, which are happening right now with nothing more wanted beyond the present act, so they don't defer satisfaction to an always-receding future.Kieran Setiya on Midlife
- Telic activities have a built-in endpoint, so engaging with them means trying to complete and thereby 'destroy' the meaningful thing; if you exclusively value projects—checking them off and moving to the next—you miss the value of process found in atelic activities that have no endpoint, which is a core driver of midlife crisis.Kieran Setiya on Midlife
- Telic and atelic are not mutually exclusive modes of acting; in almost any activity we are doing both simultaneously (rushing kids to school is also parenting), so the issue is not which activity to choose but where one's evaluative focus lies—on the completion or on the ongoing process.Kieran Setiya on Midlife