factual

Two solutions to the meaning problem: internalist or telic

Faced with the pyramid scheme problem, there are two responses: either meaning is inherently present now and internally complete (the Setiya/Stoppard/Nietzsche internalist view, like the sunset example), or, if we grant genuine dependence on future generations, then the shared activity must be telic—genuinely going somewhere with a real destination—because there is a project we have partly done that we want them to continue.

factualpending

Speaker

Agnes Callard

Evidence Quote

“you had better think this process is telic and not atelic. That is atelic in the bad sense, in the sense of having no goal at all. You better think we're going somewhere, and we will--there's such a thing as having gotten there.”

Source

Agnes Callard on Meaning, the Human Quest, and the Aims of Education— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:08:09 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...