alternative possibilities
Genuine choice options between which an agent can choose; in List's framework, alternative agential possibilities at the level of agency rather than at the microphysical level.
As defined in 354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “alternative possibilities” →
- If fundamental physics is deterministic, this does not refute free will because the indeterminism required for free will is at the level of agency, not the microphysical level, and indeterminism at the agential level is fully compatible with determinism at the level of fundamental physics given the level-relativity of the distinction.354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality
- The two conventional compatibilist strategies — denying that free will requires the possibility of doing otherwise, or redefining 'could have done otherwise' as a counterfactual conditional about a slightly different world — both arguably water down or redefine free will relative to the common-sense understanding that genuine choice was open at the moment of decision.354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality
- The three free-will criteria — intentional agency, alternative possibilities, and causal control — are portable rather than custom-made for humans, so they can in principle be applied to chimpanzees (which likely qualify), AI systems, and group agents, leading to the conclusion that corporate entities satisfying all three have functionalist free will without thereby being conscious.354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality
- A system has free will if and only if it satisfies three conditions: (1) intentional agency — it is genuinely an intentional agent; (2) alternative agential possibilities — genuine choice options at the agential level; and (3) causal control over the resulting actions (mental causation) — the action is caused by the agent's mental states and not merely by an underlying physical reflex.354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality