causal

Free Will Requires Indeterminism at Agential Level

If fundamental physics is deterministic, this does not refute free will because the indeterminism required for free will is at the level of agency, not the microphysical level, and indeterminism at the agential level is fully compatible with determinism at the level of fundamental physics given the level-relativity of the distinction.

causalpending

Speaker

Christian List

Evidence Quote

“the reason why this doesn't automatically refute free will, even on the sort of alternative possibilities characterization of free will, is simply that the kind of indeterminism, if any, that is required for free will is not the form of indeterminism at that microphysical level of description, but it would be indeterminism at what I call the level of agency, the agential level, which is a completely different level of description. And given this whole logic of level specificity of the distinction, indeterminism at the level of agency is actually fully compatible with determinism at the level of fundamental physics.”

Source

354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:28:26 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...