Vienna Circle
A group of philosophers and scientists in early-20th-century Vienna who developed logical positivism, seeking to base philosophy on direct observation and the methodology of natural science.
As defined in 319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World
Where it comes up · 3
- A History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism3 claims
- The Frankfurt School3 claims
- 319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “Vienna Circle” →
- The Frankfurt School will have tremendous disputes with logical positivists of the Vienna Circle because positivists try to reduce all thinking and reasoning to logical formalism. The Vienna Circle's goal is to reduce logic, mathematics to logic, and logic to formal relations, but the Frankfurt School argues this treating reason as purely formal is a mistake—reason is substantive.The Frankfurt School
- German philosophy of reason (exemplified by Kant) is fundamentally teleological and normative—it claims that rationality can tell you not just the means to achieve ends but what ends you ought to achieve—whereas Anglo-American philosophy (Hume, Vienna Circle, positivism) treats reason as merely instrumental, unable to derive 'ought' from 'is' and therefore incapable of prescribing ends.The Frankfurt School
- Capitalism's ideology is a truncated form of reason—instrumental reason in the Humean sense—where the world is all that is the case, and reason tells you how it is but doesn't tell you how it ought to be. This separation of 'is' from 'ought' prevents rational discussion of values, right and wrong.The Frankfurt School
- Logical positivism is now taught as a purely semantic and philosophy-of-science theory, but the original Vienna Circle positivists were deeply political, defending positivism as a weapon against the obscurantism of fascism; this political role was forgotten when the movement migrated to the US, where McCarthy-era fears pushed philosophy toward presenting itself as apolitical, formal, and science-like.319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World
- Ayer states that the thoughts expressed in 'Language, Truth and Logic' were not original but were a blend of positivism from the Vienna Circle and Wittgenstein, combined with reductive empiricism from Hume and Russell, plus the analytic (conceptual) approach of G.E. Moore.A History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism
- The Vienna Circle, active from the 1910s-1920s, developed logical positivism by advancing from naive empiricism toward recognition that distinguishing sense data from material objects leads to phenomenalist epistemology, and that empirical verification often must work through logical implications rather than direct observation.A History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism
- Key figures in the Vienna Circle included Moritz Schlick and Rudolf Carnap, and Wittgenstein participated in the circle after leaving Oxford and returning to Austria.A History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism