
The Frankfurt School
What this covers
This is a single lecture by Michael Sugrue on the Frankfurt School, treated as a coalition of thinkers from different disciplines: psychoanalysts such as Eric Fromm, the musicologist Theodor Adorno, the political theorist Herbert Marcuse, and Max Horkheimer. The lecture frames them as responding to the catastrophes of German history: Versailles, Hitler's rise in 1933, and the occupation of 1945. It also notes that the German political center collapsed, leaving a sharper left-right polarization than the United States ever had. From there it follows how the school fused Karl Marx with Sigmund Freud, since Marx offered no social psychology of the individual.
The middle of the lecture is philosophical. It sets the German conception of reason, running from Immanuel Kant and concerned with ends as well as means, against the Anglo-American tradition of David Hume and the Vienna Circle, where reason is instrumental. Horkheimer's critique of that truncated rationality, along with the formula techne without telos, is applied to neoclassical economics, positivism, and liberal politics alike. Marcuse's One-Dimensional Man and Eros and Civilization receive extended treatment. So do Adorno's hostility to mass culture, The Authoritarian Personality, and the school's inheritance from Martin Heidegger, who had been Marcuse's teacher.
The lecturer is openly critical, and the contested points are where the lecture is most pointed. He calls the claim that fascism is capitalism's necessary final stage simply wrong, since it merges liberal democracy with Nazism. He reads Marcuse's essay on tolerance as a forerunner of political correctness. He also argues that the school's contempt for "mass man" makes it deeply elitist despite its language of universal liberation. Shorter asides cover Critical Legal Studies as an offshoot and the role of One-Dimensional Man in the student radicalism of 1968.
The Frankfurt School represents a German philosophical tradition that attempts to diagnose capitalism's ideological distortions and prescribe rational liberation, but their analysis conflates fascism with liberal democracy and reveals itself as resentful mandarinate ideology masquerading as universal reason.
- Frankfurt School treats fascism as the necessary totalitarian development of capitalism, ignoring crucial differences between Nazi Germany and liberal democracies
- Their critique of 'instrumental reason' as truncated and non-teleological applies Anglo-American empiricism to German ideals of substantive, normative rationality
- The school's rejection of mass culture and mass man, combined with their demand for philosophical rule, betrays an elitist project of intellectual authority rather than genuine liberation
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Marcuse's critique in 'One-Dimensional Man' claims that ideology in the form of scientism, neoclassical economics, and liberal politics makes teleological criticism impossible, constituting a 'paralysis of criticism' because all judgments of right and wrong become merely questions of opinion ('you like this, I like that').
“the idea is first of all that in one dimensional man that the kind of ideology that we have scientism neoclassical economics liberal politics makes teleological criticism in the german conception impossible it is a paralysis of criticism why because all of our judgments of ends of right and wrong are turned into questions of opinion you like this i like that great dude it's kind of relaxed and marcus just can't stand this”
According to Marcuse, technological rationality, linguistic philosophy, and liberal politics make 'hair shaft domination' necessary and unquestionable, with the implication being that domination requires distorted views of reality, meaning we are systematically forced into false consciousness that we experience as freedom.
“technological rationality linguistic philosophy liberal politics makes hair shaft domination and the implication of domination is distorted views of reality necessary and unquestionable so his book is an attempt to get out to break through that mold to look around and impose this german teleological rationality on a group of people contemporary americans that most part don't want to hear about it”
The Frankfurt School is a coalition of different intellectuals from different academic disciplines (psychoanalysts like Eric Fromm, historians like Wit Fogle, musicologists like Adorno, political theorists like Marcuse) working together toward a common critique of society in order to account for the terrible catastrophe of 20th century German politics, particularly the rise of Nazism.
“what's important about the frankfurt school is that it's a coalition of different disciplines or of different figures some very powerful intellects coming out of different academic disciplines all working in the same direction towards what would be called a critique of society”
German philosophy of reason (exemplified by Kant) is fundamentally teleological and normative—it claims that rationality can tell you not just the means to achieve ends but what ends you ought to achieve—whereas Anglo-American philosophy (Hume, Vienna Circle, positivism) treats reason as merely instrumental, unable to derive 'ought' from 'is' and therefore incapable of prescribing ends.
“think of kantian ethics right it is possible to derive universal laws of moral behavior from pure rationality that is to be distinguished from the tradition that comes that we find in the in the anglo-american world where reason as hume put it is the slave of the passions and reason cannot tell you what ends to choose reason only tells you in the human sense what means to choose for ends that are decided upon arbitrarily”
The Frankfurt School's conception of freedom is 'the German idea of freedom,' which is freedom from socially imposed bondage and necessary illusions generated by the society one was socialized into—a much bigger idea of freedom than mere contingent ability to do what you want.
“i would say that the frankfurt school is the 20th century adaptation of what the great historian leonard krieger called the german idea of freedom which is a much bigger idea of freedom than mere contingent the contingent ability to do what you want the freedom that the frankfurt school offers us is freedom from this from the socially imposed bondage of the necessary illusions generated by the society that we were socialized into they're trying to bootstrap themselves up and out of that”
Adorno and Horkheimer wrote 'The Dialectic of Enlightenment,' a critique of the Enlightenment insofar as it led to the mass culture industry, with Adorno hating mass culture—rock and roll, jazz, all 20th century music except 12-tone—viewing these as markers of alienation and dismal misery.
“with max horkheimer he wrote a book called the dialectic dialectic of enlightenment which was a critique of the enlightenment insofar as it led to the mass culture industry adorno hated mass culture he hated rock and roll he hated jazz he hated everything all 20th century music except 12 tone pretty much and the earmark of our alienation and our dismal misery is the fact that we don't listen to 12 tone music we listen to elvis presley”
The Frankfurt School will have tremendous disputes with logical positivists of the Vienna Circle because positivists try to reduce all thinking and reasoning to logical formalism. The Vienna Circle's goal is to reduce logic, mathematics to logic, and logic to formal relations, but the Frankfurt School argues this treating reason as purely formal is a mistake—reason is substantive.
“you can see why they're going to have tremendous disputes with the logical positivists of the vienna circle they're trying to reduce all of thinking all of reasoning to some logical formalism i mean they reach the end of the line when they get to girdles and completeness theorem but clearly the goal of the vienna circle is to reduce logic mathematics to logic and logic to a certain set of formal relations well what the frankfurt school is saying is that the whole idea of treating reason as purely formal is a mistake reason is substantive”
20th century German intellectual development must be understood in the context of catastrophic political events: the 1918 Treaty of Versailles, the 1933 rise of Hitler and National Socialism, and the 1945 occupation by Russia, America, England and allied forces. These catastrophes make it impossible to understand German intellectuals except through this political history.
“in the case of 20th century germany it's necessary to locate in historical context developments in intellectual life because of the notorious and catastrophic events of the 20th century in germany 1918 end of the first world war we get the treaty of versailles 1933 the the coming to power of hitler and national socialism and of course this another catastrophe in 1945 with russian and allied and english and american occupation of germany what we had here is a series of catastrophes and it is impossible to see 20th century german intellectuals except in the contest of this catastrophic political history”
Theodor Adorno is in some ways the inverse of Marcuse because he is much more anti-systematic, much more influenced by Nietzsche, and primarily an aesthetician who writes beautiful essays on musicology, but is very unsystematic and has a terrible animus toward the world as it is while giving nebulous explanations for how to change it.
“a second figure after marcusa is theodara dorno and he's in some ways the inverse of marcus because he's much more anti-systematic much more influenced by nietzsche and he's for the most part an esthetician he writes very lovely essays on musicology he once wrote a beautiful thing called bach defended against his admirers which is a very inviting thought i mean he has some very very fine writings on art and aesthetics the difficulty is is that he's very unsystematic and like so many of the members of the frankfurt school he seems to have a terrible animus towards the world as it is but gives very nebulous explanations and accounts for how we should change it and change it into what”
Marcuse's book 'Eros and Civilization' combines Freud and Marx, arguing that while Freud claims civilization necessarily requires frustration of desires, many of the restrictions on emotional and sexual life only serve capitalist domination, and when people are liberated from ideological illusions, many archaic restrictions on sexual life will disappear, leading to a kind of sexual utopia.
“a second book that marcus wrote which is uh was became very popular among student radicals in the 60s was called erosion civilization what it was is a sort of mixture of freud and marx which says that which is like a freud's conception of the relationship between self and society without the pessimism characteristic of freud freud says in the civilization that's discontents you can never resolve the conflict between the individual and society necessary to being in civilized society is the frustration of some of your desires”
'Critique of Instrumental Reason' is the title that best reveals Horkheimer's fundamental project: instrumental reason is the conception of reason as disclosing only means, never ends—beginning with Bacon, continuing through Hume, eventually formulated in logical positivism—and Horkheimer's critique aims to show that this truncated rationality causes tremendous human misery and is the source of 20th century political and economic woes.
“i'm not so interested with these essays themselves rather as the title because the title discloses something very important about this project instrumental reason is that conception of reason as disclosing only means never ends its instrumental reason is human reason it's anglo-american reason it's the it's the same conception of reason that starts out i guess with bacon and starts out with and moves on to hume and is eventually kind of uh formulated in logical positivism right the idea that reason can only tell you how to achieve the means by which you would achieve your ends it can't tell you what ends to achieve”
In German politics in the 20th century the political center collapsed, producing a much greater degree of polarization between left and right than occurred in the United States. There was tremendous movement to both fascism on the right and Marxist/communist resistance on the left, with very little center to occupy.
“in german politics in the 20th century we had a much greater degree of polarization between left and right than we did in the united states which somehow which sometimes makes it difficult to see what's going on in other words what happened during the republic is that the center collapsed and we had a tremendous move to both the right of fascism and the left of communist resistance to it or marxist resistance to it and there was not much of a center there”
Marcuse's 'Critique of Pure Tolerance' (co-written with Wolff and others) argues that what is conventionally understood as freedom of speech is actually a kind of hidden censorship, and that only if professors restrict free speech would people have true freedom—an idea that, when popularized, becomes political correctness.
“herbert marcus one of his last works was called a critique of pure tolerance which he wrote with uh wolff and i think one other guy and the gist of it was something like this that what we think is simply freedom of speech is in fact right like all the other techne without telos characteristic of our conception of reason is in fact restriction of freedom in fact the only way to have real free speech is to restrict free speech in other words what we think is free of as being free speech now is in fact a subterranean and devious kind of censorship on the other hand if professors get the sense of what people can say well that would be freedom and it's clear that when this gets popularized and democratized what it could turn into is political correctness”
Freud argues in 'Beyond the Pleasure Principle' that you need some restrictions—not just because society requires them, but because you need contrast to have pleasure; without restrictions, you lead straight to despair since unlimited gratification eliminates the possibility of pleasure.
“as freud points out very nicely in beyond the pleasure principle you need some restrictions even some few not just because they're necessary to the conduct of society and civilization but just because you need some contrast if you can do everything that will lead you straight away to despair you need something uh some restrictions in order to have the possibility of pleasure in life and that's a deep observation one of freud's best thoughts”
The Frankfurt School's interpretation of fascism as the final stage of capitalism either ignores liberal democracy or conflates it with fascism—a claim that is simply 'plain wrong' requiring no further argument; Nazi Germany and the United States have more differences than similarities.
“the downside though is very very down in the first case the interpretation of fascism as the final stage of capitalism either ignores liberal democracy or it conflates fascism in liberal democracy and that's just plain wrong i mean i don't want to argue about it anymore than that it's wrong look at nazi germany look at the united states there are more differences than similarities i just don't want to hear this from german professors right”
Capitalism's ideology is a truncated form of reason—instrumental reason in the Humean sense—where the world is all that is the case, and reason tells you how it is but doesn't tell you how it ought to be. This separation of 'is' from 'ought' prevents rational discussion of values, right and wrong.
“the ideological ideology of capitalism is a truncated form of reason it's what we might call instrumental reason reason in the sense that david hume used the word reason for hume and all the anglo-american tradition that leads up to the vienna circle and positivism the world is all that is the case and reason tells you about the way the world is it tells you how it is but it doesn't tell you how it ought to be in other words according to the anglo-american tradition there's a skepticism about ought statements we cannot derive them from any set of observations we cannot derive it from science or math”
The Frankfurt School recognizes that Marx by himself is insufficient for their project because Marxism is missing a kind of social psychology—Marx rarely discusses the individual psyche, individual soul, and how individuals relate to society except to say they are pushed around by means of production and ideology.
“one of the important twists that the frankfurt school adds is that they see that there are gaps in marks and marks by himself is not sufficient in particular marxism is missing a kind of social psychology marx very rarely talks about the individual psyche and the individual soul and how and how the individual relates to society except to say that he's pushed around by the means of production and by the ideology that accompanies that”
Adorno and Horkheimer's book 'The Authoritarian Personality' fuses Marx and Freud to examine how mass society in 1930s Germany socialized people such that their psyches were systematically distorted in the same way, with the authoritarian personality displaying traits of rigid conformism, disapproval of outsiders, sadomasochism, and anti-Semitism.
“a second book that he that adorno orthodox authored with horkheimer was probably the most famous book that the frankfurt school produced was called the authoritarian personality and here we have this fusion of marx and freud that i was talking about they look at the mass society of germany during the 30s and they say what could cause people to behave in such a way how is it that they're willing to follow a terrible evil man like this and do terrible things and they say well since we've been reading a lot of freud it must have to do somehow with the the model of their psyche there must be some process by which advanced capitalist societies socialize people in such a way so their psyches are systematically distorted and all distorted in the same way”
Marcuse's 'One-Dimensional Man' became a foundational text for 1960s student radicals, most of whom couldn't understand it but liked the idea of disputing that society is good. The book gave them a highbrow vehicle to articulate their unhappiness, making it foundational to student radicalism in America and France in 1968.
“so this became popular as a kind of foundational text for the 1960s radicals most of whom couldn't understand it but they liked the idea of disputing the fact that this is a good society and they were very unhappy and this gave them a vehicle to talk about that and it's kind of highbrow german stuff so for that reason this becomes one of the foundational texts of student radicalism both here and in france in 68”
Neoclassical economics, logical positivism, and liberalism in politics share a common structure: they are all 'techne without telos'—they tell you about the ways to achieve things but do not and cannot tell you what ends you should be directed toward, creating a dangerous vacuum of normative guidance.
“think about something like liberalism in politics liberalism and politics well you think this i think that does it tell you how you ought to think does it tell you what what opinions really are good in other words what liberalism and neoclassical economics and logical positivism have in common is that they are techne without telos they tell you about the ways in which you can get things done but it doesn't tell you the ends towards which your action should be directed”
From Heidegger, the Frankfurt School adopts two important things: first, 'technophobia'—a neurosis about technology, with Heidegger viewing technology as alienating people from their real being and real self; and second, a hatred of 'mass man' despite posturing about universality and liberation, making the Frankfurt School one of the most elitist movements of the 20th century.
“what carries over into the hunger schools two very important things one what i would call technophobia heidegger has a neurosis about technology any of you have read that essay on the question concerning technology he's a real technology basher he's part of that humanistic that set of humanistic intellectuals that does not like science and particularly does not like technology you'll be part of that crowd that says it alienates you and you don't get in touch with your real being or your real self because of all these machines and this is i think one of the most lamentable tendencies in 20th century philosophy”
Herbert Marcuse was a student of Heidegger and became deeply disillusioned when his former teacher embraced Nazism, leading Marcuse to ask how a brilliant philosopher could be seduced by fascism, and driving him to examine how philosophy itself could reach such a crisis.
“herbert marcusa one of the leading lights of the frankfurt school was one of heidegger's phd students he got his degree under heidegger and while marcus is still a young man heidegger becomes a nazi and marcus thinks to himself my god this is terrible what terrible thing has happened to the minds of our philosophers that they are actually willing to buy into this i mean clearly he's terribly disappointed by his teacher and is clearly enough a break and what he is trying to add what marcus is trying to ask is how is it that philosophy could have gotten into this terrible situation how is it that a brilliant and great thinker like heidegger could get dressed up in nazi regalia and give the the nazi salute before his lectures how is this possible how we reach this kind of crisis”
The Frankfurt School treats fascism and Nazism as the necessary totalitarian development of capitalist society, arguing that Nazism and the accompanying genocide are a necessary result of the destruction of reason through the ideological necessities of the capitalist system—and therefore place responsibility for fascism on the bourgeoisie.
“the frankfurt school treats fascism and nazism as the necessary totalitarian development of capitalist society in other words uh social structure and economic and ideological superstructure and the economic base are all meshed together in the marxist view and since the ideology of nazism developed in late capitalist society in germany and we get fascism in the west at the same time among societies that have the same sort of economic development what the argument they are going to make is that nazism and totalitarianism and the genocide that accompanies it is a necessary result of the destruction of reason through the ideological necessities of the capitalist system”
Critical Legal Studies represents an intellectual offspring of Frankfurt School thought, attempting to show the intrinsic biases and conceptual distortions built into law as an instrument of capitalist repression, though the speaker is not terribly impressed with its results.
“the second result of the frankfurt school is called the critical legal studies those of you who have been following main trends in legal thought critical legal studies is an attempt to get around the bourgeois ideology the the instrumental view of reason characteristic of black letter law critical legal studies tries to show the intrinsic biases the intrinsic conceptual distortions built in to law and built into the of the repressive structure of society um i'm not terribly impressed with the results of critical legal studies”
Theodor Adorno's essays on jazz are worse than wrong—he claims jazz represents a hidden castration complex and that people enjoy jazz because it helps them psychically castrate themselves, an example of pretentious pompous German academic philosophy that misinterprets what it knows nothing about.
“his treatment of jazz is worse than wrong his view of jazz is that it's of course an ideological construct that it's bad for people he's in bringing together freud and marx in his interpretation of jazz a form of music that he knows nothing about um he tells us that in fact it's a really carefully hidden castration complex so the reason why we like jazz is because it helps us psychically castrate ourselves how did he find this out i mean no i'm just not taking this he doesn't know who charlie parker is he doesn't know who john coltrane is he doesn't know who miles davis is and he tells us that the true psychic message is that we're all to become castrati hogwash”
In the 20th century, social science became the new battleground for philosophical arguments that used to be fought on the terrain of pure philosophy, with disputes between functionalist anthropology (Anglo-American empirical tradition) and structuralist anthropology (Continental tradition) recapitulating the Hume-Kant dispute.
“another important way of thinking about the frankfurt school another one of its fallouts one of its one of the things it's important for is that it helps us see that in the 20th century social science is the new battleground upon which philosophical arguments are held in other words we used to fight our battles on the terrain of philosophy now the train of philosophy is pretty much sterile there aren't too many battles there we have transferred these battles into the realm of social science”
The mandarins do not seek power out of 'heteronomous will to power' but rather claim moral obligation to rule because 'autonomous reason requires rule by an intellectual elite' saturated in 'gnostic resentment'—they position themselves as Platonic guardians obligated to rule for the people's good.
“i think that is the big attraction of the frankfurt school not only are they running scared but they want to tell us all that we don't understand the world we need them and they're not doing this out of a pure lust for power that would be heteronomous in the kantian says no they wouldn't do that instead the reason why they're doing it is the reason why plato's guardians used to run the republic because it's their moral obligation because they understand teleological reasoning it's true for critical legal studies because in the united states as well that's another example of mandarins left out of the connection between labor capital and technology and critical legal studies or the frankfurt school in each case are the way in which the mandarins have their revenge what i would say then is that the the frankfurt school tells us that philosophers must become kings not because the mandarins have a tremendous nachane will to power but rather because autonomous reason requires rule by an intellectual elite that is saturated in gnostic resentment”
When Adorno and Horkheimer tested Americans with the same authoritarian personality tests, they found America 'loaded with authoritarian personalities' but could find no obvious authoritarianism. So they reinterpreted: America's authoritarianism is an 'iron hand with a velvet glove'—hidden beneath rock and roll, movies, and surfboards. Liberal America is the most dangerous authoritarianism because it's most hidden.
“now they come to america and start giving out these tests the same test and they find that america is loaded with authoritarian personalities but alas there's no obvious authoritarianism so they fudge it and they say aha you don't think it's authoritarian but in fact this is just the iron hand with a velvet glove over it your whole process of socialization all your rock and roll and your movies and your surfboards all these things are the veil of maya in fact you are authoritarian this is authoritarianism with a happy face drawn on it in fact this is the least overt in that respect the most dangerous kind of authoritarianism”
The American reality is probably the freest place in the world, but one of the ironies of human nature is that when given maximum freedom, people mostly imitate each other—people seek the herd, want to be like others, buy the same fashions—but this is the human condition, not a disease caused by capitalist domination.
“my guess would be that the opposite is true that in fact america is in practice probably the freest place in the world but one of the ironies of human life is that when you give people the maximum amount of freedom what they mostly do is imitate each other i mean go to the store everybody buys the same fad every year a new fat a new fashion comes in and fashion goes out no one holds a gun to your head that makes you buy it it's just that human nature is this is such that people want to seek the school the herd they like to be like other people it makes them feel better this isn't a disease this is the human condition”
Marcuse's 'One-Dimensional Man' was largely finished while he was in California, and there is something incongruous about stodgy German professors being in Southern California (lotus land where it's nice all the time and everything is cheery) with his pessimistic world outlook—like Oedipus in Disneyland.
“the most important book that marcus wrote the most influential one was called one dimensional man and i believe that this was largely finished while marcus was in california and there's something terribly incongruous about stodgy german professors being in southern california because they look at i mean lotus land i mean i was in southern california this summer and it's nice all the time and everything is cheery there you can't have this outlook on the world and feel comfortable in california i mean it's like oedipus in disneyland”
Adorno is 'very dogmatic' and aesthetics as a domain 'is such a nebulous activity that it gives free reign to dogmatism,' allowing Adorno to make pronouncements about what constitutes true music and authentic experience without empirical constraint.
“professor adorno can be very very dogmatic and that's one of the problems with aesthetics right it's such a nebulous activity that it gives free reign to dogmatism”
The Frankfurt School has not become a mass movement, but when it did gain popular influence in the 1960s student revolts, it was a watered-down version because most people lack the mental and intellectual wherewithal to adopt the full Frankfurt philosophical posture.
“it appears to be accessible only to german philosophers and a few people who are professional thinkers in the post-capitalist world it has not gotten a tremendous number of adherents it had when it became a mass movement as in the student revolts of the 60s it was a watered-down version of the frankfurt school most people will not have the mental or intellectual wherewithal to actually adopt this posture”
Frankfurt School's attempt to account for American society through their framework 'does a fair fairly good job with the rise of nazism and fascism in europe' but 'doesn't translate very well to america' because of fundamental differences between European and American political history.
“i think that this is a failure in its attempt to account for american society does a fair fairly good job with the rise of nazism and fascism in europe it doesn't translate very well to america”
Political correctness represents 'the worst fallout of the frankfurt school' in the speaker's estimation, demonstrating the danger of Frankfurt thought when applied in practice.
“and it's clear that when this gets popularized and democratized what it could turn into is political correctness and it's really really unpleasant it's the worst fallout of the frankfurt school in my estimation”
The worst of Adorno's arbitrary dogmatism—exemplified by his writings on jazz—demonstrates why multiculturalism, despite its flaws, represents progress: it prevents the imposition of a single elite's aesthetic standards on all others, combating what would otherwise be 'adorno-centric' cultural imperialism.
“think of the sex life of jazz musicians nothing could be further from the truth so in fact this is pretentious pompous german academic philosophy and i'm just not taking it if it were a meal i would send it back so no i'm not taking those observations on jazz it is the worst kind of arbitrary dogmatism it makes you realize the advantages to the current movement called multiculturalism this is the worst kind of europe it's not even eurocentric it's adorno centric and i'm just not taking it”
The Frankfurt School's ideology is the ideology of 'superfluous irrelevant German mandarins'—intellectuals who no longer have practical role or relevance in a society organized around the coalition of labor, capital, and technology, and who have constructed a theoretical vehicle to tell ordinary people how benighted they are for not conforming to intellectual elite standards.
“to finish off i'd like to interpret this using some ideas that darren stalloff may have made clear to you in his lecture on gouldner this is the ideology of german mandarins and not just all german mandarins this it's the ideology of superfluous irrelevant german mandarins people still talk to physicists and mathematicians because they do something practical and useful but nobody wants to talk to the mandarins either in the united states or in germany throughout the 20th century and the mandarins don't like it so they've constructed a crypto theological construct which will tell us all how wicked and benighted we are because we like to listen to rock and roll and we don't want to listen to 12-tone music and we want to watch tv we don't want to see the plays of brett”
The Frankfurt School's problem is that if you went to post-war Russia, Sweden, Turkey, Angola, or the South Pole, you would find all those places 'loaded with authoritarian personalities.' The concept of 'authoritarian personality' really just means 'people who are not members of the Frankfurt School.' Everyone else is in 'the bonds and shackles of illusion.'
“now a problem emerges here my guess is that if you were to go to or no post-war russia you would find that post-war russia was also loaded with authoritarian personalities my guess is if you went to sweden and turkey and angola and the south pole you find that all those places were loaded with authoritarian personalities too my guess is that what they mean by the authoritarian personality is people who are not members of the frankfurt school you know that's what it amounts to we're liberated and everybody else is in the bonds the shackles of illusion right”
Looking back at tapes from Columbia in 1968, one cannot rationally call the student occupation 'rational' in the technical sense, though one could charitably interpret it as 'teleological reason' in Frankfurt terms.
“the difficulty is of course is that viewing this as the apogee of rationality i think is highly implausible and exceedingly self-indulgent i mean looking back at the tapes from colombia at 68 is this rational does it look rational to you well maybe it's teleological reason let's be charitable about that”
Jürgen Habermas is a second-generation Frankfurt School member who is the greatest living social scientist, far less dogmatic than his predecessors, willing to play fair with the Anglo-American tradition rather than ignoring it and disdaining it, and he attempts to truly assimilate Hegelian thought rather than just reject Anglo-American approaches.
“the first is uh that it's had an important political fallout in uh the work of of jurgen habermas i think that i mean for all the problems of the frankfurt school jurgen habermas in my estimation is the greatest living social scientist and he is a sort of second generation member of the frankfurt school he's about as difficult to read but far less dogmatic and far more willing to play fair with the anglo-american tradition in other words he's trying to be truly hegelian and assimilated rather than just ignore it and distain it and kick sand in his face”
Marcuse rejected Soviet Marxism as not 'true Marxism,' seeking instead a humanistic Marxism, but this is a self-indulgent posture because in a polarized society it is hard to see how there would be a practical alternative to technically organized, hierarchically structured, extremely repressive state-run government, which Marcuse does not adequately address.
“marcus wrote a book in the 50s on soviet marxism and he rejected soviet marxism why because it isn't true marxism which is a very self-indulgent kind of posture to take because he's looking for a humanistic sort of marxism but on the other hand it seems to be the only alternative in this polarized society it's hard to see how we're going to have a practical alternative to this technologically organized hierarchically structured extremely repressive state-run government he doesn't quite explain how we're going to have this marxist utopia”
There is real danger in operating on the assumption that right and wrong are completely outside the bounds of cognition; while positivism's logical tidiness is tempting, the Frankfurt School correctly identifies a genuine problem, earning 'two cheers' despite serious flaws.
“i say this with some trepidation because actually in some ways i really like it you know i think there is real danger in operating on the assumption that right and wrong are completely outside the bounds of cognition i think that while that's tempting because of the logical tidiness of positivism i think that there is real danger there so i in some ways i'd like to say two cheers for the frankfurt school because they are trying to offer us a way out of the labyrinth of modernity a way of thinking about the world that isn't a desert of objects”
Herbert Marcuse's book 'Reason and Revolution' is a revival of left-wing Hegelianism that traces speculative psychology from Hegel's Phenomenology to the present day, asking how we got into this mess and how positivism and scientism came to reign in the late 19th century with consequences visible in the 20th century.
“the first of his important books was called reason and revolution and what that is is a revival of left-wing hegelianism they're going to take that history of philosophy that hegel had been doing in or the history kind of speculative psychology that hegel had been doing in the phenomenology and extended right up to the present a worthy and sensible project how is it we got into this mess how is it the positivism and scientism came to reign in the late 19th century and look at the 20th century consequences of that very intriguing argument”
From Marx, the Frankfurt School takes a left-wing Hegelian reading, extracting the ideas of praxis and political voluntarism—the belief that theory should not be separated from practice, and that understanding the world philosophically must commit one to changing it through political action.
“in addition they borrow a great deal from marx they take a sort of left-wing hegelian reading a left-wing reading of hegel and that marx picks up on that and for marx they get the idea of praxis and the idea of political voluntarism in other words commit yourself to political progress change the world theory should not be separated from practice if you have a theory about how the world works and it's a true theory then it'll change the world in order to get people to do things passively understanding the world is less than half of the job of philosophy”
The Frankfurt School is running scared and afraid of the consequences of late capitalism development. They are trying to create ideological means to bootstrap ourselves out of ideological illusions toward true rationality—a Hegelian resonance where we come to know ourselves and the world around us, and when we do, we will know not only what the world is but what we're supposed to do with it.
“they're running scared they're afraid of the consequences of the development of late capitalism and they are trying to create some ideological means by which we can bootstrap ourself up out of these ideological illusions towards true rationality or hegelian resonances here so that we can come to know ourselves and the worlds around world around us and when we would do that we will know not only what the world is but what we're supposed to do with it and how we're supposed to act it will be teleological it will be normative as well as descriptive”
Herbert Marcuse had a long and varied career, leaving Germany for the United States. Like any member of a late capitalist society, Americans live under a veil of illusion and are forced to have necessarily false consciousness because the global proletarian revolution hasn't occurred. Marcuse was unhappy with what he found in America and tried to offer criticism both of Germany and the United States.
“he had a long and varied career he left germany came to the united states and uh was not happy with what he found in other words like any other late capitalist society we live under this veil of mile we are forced to have the necessarily false consciousness that accompanies the ideology of a society divided into classes because we haven't had the global proletarian revolution we are necessarily under the realm of ideological illusion so marcus comes here and tries to offer criticism both of germany and the tendency of 20th century politics but in addition criticism of the united states”
Max Horkheimer's 'The Eclipse of Reason' is a fine collection of introductory essays and an excellent introduction to Frankfurt School thought.
“the eclipse of reason is a collection of his essays and it's an excellent introduction to the frankfurt school so those of you that want to start in on this stuff would like to read this um the eclipse of reason is a fine set of inter of introductory essays”