Tenure
An academic appointment, typically permanent, granted after review; its procedures shape researcher incentives.
As defined in Mark Zuckerberg Interviews Patrick Collison And Tyler Cowen
Other definitions
Employment status providing professors with protection from being fired for their speech or research; originally designed to protect intellectual freedom but shown to be ineffective when institutional cultures override legal protections
The World In 2024 With Niall Ferguson: Crisis, Conflict And The New Axis of Evil
Where it comes up · 22
- The World In 2024 With Niall Ferguson: Crisis, Conflict And The New Axis of Evil2 claims
- Mark Zuckerberg Interviews Patrick Collison And Tyler Cowen2 claims
- Peter Singer2 claims
- Rob Reich on Foundations and Philanthropy2 claims
- 199 - A Conversation With Caitlin Flanagan2 claims
- Eric Hanushek on Teachers 08/29/20112 claims
- Marc Andreessen2 claims
- Harvard Business Publishing: A Case Study1 claim
and 14 more
Most important claims · 10 of 29Search all claims for “Tenure” →
- Academic tenure—lifetime job unaccountability—is justifiable only if it produces risky, long-time-horizon research, much of which fails but a fraction of which yields important contributions; the same logic justifies a perpetual endowment, so a foundation is only defensible if it pursues long-horizon experimentation, otherwise a donor should just write checks rather than create the institutional form.Rob Reich on Foundations and Philanthropy
- Universities typically guarantee professors only nine months of salary; successful researchers can apply to have one or two months of summer salary paid through their grants, which functions as an incentive system that motivates tenured faculty to remain active in research and thereby increases total research output.Bonus | Cuts to Science Funding and Why They Matter
- Building a world-class university (or institution) in a country with money but low credibility hinges less on early funding than on the harder later phase of credibility-building: being willing to fire people before tenure and credibly guarantee it after, and—crucially—guaranteeing that policies set by one ruler will be honored by the next, which many countries cannot do.John Nye
- Washington, D.C. demonstrates that serious teacher accountability is possible: under a contract instituted four years prior, its evaluation system tied to student performance and outside ratings gave bonuses to about 1000 teachers and fired about 300 over three years—dramatically different from history—though it was enabled by the school system's unusual governance under the U.S. Congress.Eric Hanushek on Education and Prosperity
- The empirical evidence does not support tenure generating long-horizon projects; to get tenure scholars must publish many articles and become influential quickly, so pre-tenure work tends to be unambitious, and the bigger problem is that academic life self-selects for people who are not risk-takers, so few find post-tenure freedom exhilarating enough to do bold work.Rob Reich on Foundations and Philanthropy
- The list of top US universities in 1920 is essentially identical to today (only California was added), and tenure procedures at the top 50 research universities are almost exactly the same as a century ago, indicating that experimentation at the institutional level has died; more schools should experiment with different tenure rules or reward people more on the basis of practical impact, in contrast to corporate market-cap leaders that turn over almost completely each decade.Mark Zuckerberg Interviews Patrick Collison And Tyler Cowen
- The pernicious aspect of tenure is not lifetime protection or academic freedom but the gatekeeping structure in which senior faculty hire and assess their junior peers, producing a natural gravitation toward the like-minded that ratchets the faculty toward one end of the political spectrum; the problem is not that this asymmetry leans Left but that it is asymmetrical, since lacking heterodox challenge prevents knowers from seeing their own biases and blind spots in three dimensions.Pano Kanelos on Education and UATX
- Much professional philosophy is boring because intense competition for tenured jobs and peer review push young scholars toward narrow work that critiques and builds on existing highly-rated-journal debates—aiming at 'the capillaries' rather than 'the lifeblood' of the subject—and improving this would require changing the appointment and tenure system, perhaps by giving students more of a role.Peter Singer
- Tenure was created not as a guarantee of permanent employment for anyone with a PhD, but specifically to give professors the absolute security needed to speak the truth and exercise academic freedom without being fired by conservative administrators or donors; since faculty are failing that purpose by staying silent on the layoffs, the protection is no longer deserved.199 - A Conversation With Caitlin Flanagan
- The aspiring historian should not try to replicate Ferguson's academic career or that of his contemporaries because the academic job market is increasingly difficult with few tenure-track positions, low pay relative to the US, and conditions that are 'really really really tough' outside the elite universities (Oxford, Cambridge, Imperial, LSE, Kings).The World In 2024 With Niall Ferguson: Crisis, Conflict And The New Axis of Evil