What this covers

Eric Hanushek of the Hoover Institution discusses teacher quality with Russ Roberts in this hour-long conversation about what actually drives student achievement in American schools. Hanushek's central claim is that teacher quality matters far more than school-level variables, but that the standard credentials used to identify good teachers—master's degrees, years of experience—bear no consistent relationship to how much students learn. He presents evidence that some teachers reliably cover vastly more material than others in the same school, and that this variation translates into large lifetime earnings differences for their students. The conversation ranges across the data underlying these claims, the mechanisms that perpetuate ineffective teaching, and the policy tradeoffs between reform approaches.

The discussion covers several distinct tensions. Hanushek argues that measured teacher differences are large enough to dwarf family background effects over time, yet acknowledges that a single good teacher cannot overcome a school culture of disorder. He shows that within-school variation in teacher quality exceeds between-school variation—suggesting the problem is not that poor districts get worse teachers but that all schools contain both highly effective and ineffective teachers—yet notes that tracking teacher impact through test scores alone risks confusing a teacher's genuine effect with the composition of her assigned class. The conversation also addresses structural problems: how tenure rules and administrative complexity make removing poor teachers nearly impossible, how teacher pay schedules reward credentials that don't improve outcomes, and how political pressures around testing (including the Atlanta cheating scandal) create perverse incentives. Hanushek proposes that the gap between good and bad teachers is large enough that removing the lowest 5–8 percent and allowing modest class-size increases could move US achievement from below the developed-world average to near the top. Roberts and Hanushek also discuss whether better evaluation systems, broader school choice, or stronger accountability within the current system offers the most promising path forward.

Sharpest takeaway

Hanushek argues that teacher quality—not credentials like master's degrees or experience—is the most important school-based determinant of student achievement, with the gap between good and bad teachers large enough to translate into hundreds of thousands of dollars in lifetime earnings, implying that removing the worst teachers (even at the cost of larger classes) would dramatically raise national achievement.

  • Measured credentials (master's degrees, experience beyond the first years) have no average impact on student achievement
  • Teacher effectiveness varies more within schools than between schools, and a string of good teachers can overcome family background disadvantages
  • Converting achievement gains into lifetime earnings yields a ~$400,000 per-year difference between a 75th and 25th percentile teacher

The claims · ranked32 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.79

Because teacher value is so large, the logic implies you should give your best teachers the largest classes (and small classes to poor teachers to limit their damage), but the current system does this exactly backward since pay is disconnected from value created.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“it immediately suggests that you ought to give your good teachers big classes... and your small classes should go to the poor teachers because they do less harm”

0.79

The variation in teacher effectiveness is larger within any given school than between schools, meaning it is not the case that suburban schools get all the good teachers and city schools the poor ones.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“the difference in teacher effectiveness is largest within any school as opposed to between schools... the variation within any school is much larger than the variation between schools”

0.75

Reading and math are the focus of value-added teacher research not because they are uniquely important but because student gains can be tracked year-to-year; the same distribution of teacher quality likely exists in history and science but is harder to identify analytically.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“I think that there's the same distribution of quality when we look at history teachers and at science teachers and so forth we just have a harder time analytically identifying the teacher impacts”

0.75

A great teacher placed in a school with poor overall culture (e.g., students roaming halls) would struggle to make a large difference unless the broader school culture improved and the teacher was complemented by other good teachers.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“if you took a school like that and you put a great teacher in that school that teacher would struggle to make the kind of differences we're talking about if the overall culture of the school wasn't improved”

0.75

Value-added scores can be confounded because a great teacher may be assigned challenging students and show only modest improvement, analogous to hospitals with low survival rates because they take the hardest surgical cases—so good evaluation must separate the teacher's effect from the composition of the class.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“a great teacher might get assigned a challenging group of students have modest or mediocre improvement over the course of the year and would say that's not representative”

0.75

Political pressures following the imposition of testing—exemplified by the Atlanta scandal where teachers changed pencil marks after exams—are an incentive problem, and the same forces push teachers to advocate for easier tests nationally and resist testing improvements.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“we just had a scandal in Atlanta where students were improving their test scores dramatically... they were going into the exams after the tests were finished and changing where the pencil marks were... that of course is an incentive problem”

0.75

Good information about teacher quality can come from normal in-class evaluations by trained observers (as in Washington DC, where part to half of evaluation comes from observations rather than test scores), not just from testing—just as businesses combine measures rather than relying solely on counting output.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“it's actually being used for the teachers where it's possible in Washington DC now... at least half... of their evaluation comes from in-class observations of trained observers”

0.74

A teacher at the 75th percentile adds about $400,000 per year to the present value of her students' lifetime earnings relative to an average teacher, and symmetrically a 25th percentile teacher subtracts about $400,000 per year—derived by combining teacher achievement-gain estimates, the earnings return to achievement, and class size.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 4/4durability 2/4· Eric Hanushek

“that 75th percentile teacher is adding four hundred thousand dollars to the economy to the terms of lifetime present value of lifetime earnings of her students in that year”

0.74

If the worst 5-8% of teachers were eliminated and class sizes allowed to be slightly larger, international estimates suggest the US would jump from below the developed-country average in math and science to near the top—so a fiscal crisis could be turned into a large gain for schools.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 4/4durability 2/4· Eric Hanushek

“if we could reduce the bottom five to eight percent of our teachers the International estimates suggest that we would jump from below the developed country average in terms of math and science to near the top”

0.73

The skeptic's view—that gifted students will eventually learn what they need regardless of a bad teacher and that family/genetic effects dominate—is contradicted by the policy consensus that schools do make a difference; in practice a student who falls behind in algebra is often shuffled onto a different path and never catches up.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“the kid who doesn't do very well in eighth or ninth grade algebra one ends up never getting to algebra two he just shuffled off... and never actually catches up because they're putting you know on a different path”

0.73

A good teacher three or four years in a row can overcome the achievement gap associated with coming from a poor family versus a better-off family, refuting the view that disadvantaged students' outcomes are hopeless due to family background.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“the data suggests that a good teacher three or four years in a row can overcome this family background difference”

0.73

Earning a master's degree gives teachers about a 20% salary bump but has no average impact on their teaching performance, and additional experience beyond the first couple of years also has no average impact on student outcomes—yet these are exactly the attributes school pay schedules reward.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“you get about a 20% bump in your salary if you get a master's degree... it has no impact”

0.73

Nations whose students score higher on the same math tests grow economically faster, other things being equal, suggesting that learning multiplies and has real macroeconomic impact.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“nations where kids know more math as measured by these same kinds of math tests... grow faster other things being equal and it makes a huge difference”

0.70

Poor children show little year-to-year movement in achievement because the system does not systematically give them several good teachers in a row—a good year is typically followed by being cycled through a poor teacher.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“what we don't do is systematically ensure that a poor kid gets three or four good teachers in a row we give them a good teacher and then to be fair we cycle that student through a poor teacher”

0.69

Over the past ~20 years, US schools saw roughly a 20% increase in students, a 34% increase in teachers (driving smaller class sizes), and a 41% increase in total staff—showing that the non-teaching workforce grew even faster than teachers, both far outpacing student growth.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Eric Hanushek

“there's been a 20% increase in the number of students... a 34 percent increase in the number of teachers... a 41% increase in total staff”

0.69

In a poor inner-city school in Gary, Indiana, some teachers produced a year and a half of learning in an academic year while others produced only half a year, meaning a child's knowledge could differ by a full year depending on which teacher they were assigned.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Eric Hanushek

“in a inner-city school in Gary Indiana where there were all poor kids we found that some teachers got a year and a half of learning in an academic year other teachers got half of a year of learning”

0.69

Tenure rules (e.g., after two years in California, three in many states) protect ineffective teachers indefinitely, and the system uses devices like the 'dance of the lemons' (shuffling bad teachers between schools) and 'rubber rooms' (paying incompetent teachers to sit idle) because due-process clauses make removal nearly impossible.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Eric Hanushek

“in California after two years teachers have tenure... she's got tenure and she's around for as long as she wants to stay it's not a decision of the school”

0.69

Roughly 70% of what a child gains in fourth grade carries through to graduation (after allowing for depreciation each year), so a student who gets 75th-percentile teachers every year from kindergarten through 12th grade could accumulate around $250,000 in extra lifetime present-value earnings relative to one with average teachers.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Eric Hanushek

“70% of what kid gets in the fourth grade carries through on into graduation”

0.68

The most important school-based determinant of student achievement is the teacher, but not the commonly measured attributes like having a master's degree or more experience—rather some people are simply better at teaching than others.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“the most important aspect of schools is the teacher... it's not the commonly measured attributes that we call quality like having a master's degree or having more experience but in fact some people are better at it than others”

0.68

Because hiring teachers involves irreducible uncertainty even with interviews, demo lessons, and lesson plans, the better policy lever is to make better decisions about who stays in the classroom rather than relying on screening at hiring.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“there's still a lot of uncertainty and so in my opinion we just have to live with the uncertainty of hiring but make better decisions about who stays in the class”

0.68

Hanushek favors a middle path on reform: broader choice and charter schools (e.g., a quarter of schools being non-unionized charters) put beneficial pressure on the system, but because politics will keep ~80% of students in public schools, strong accountability and performance measurement are also needed, and marginal changes within the current system can yield substantial improvement.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Hanushek

“I come out somewhere in between... even if we opened up broader vouchers eighty percent would still want to go to their existing public schools... more choices beneficial and it puts a lot of pressure on the schools”

0.65

The Los Angeles Times in roughly 2010 hired a researcher to compute value-added scores for about 3,000 LA public school teachers and published them by name, which Hanushek did not consider a sound personnel approach but which prompted the district and unions to develop a better evaluation system.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Eric Hanushek

“the Los Angeles Times hired a researcher to produce value-added scores for all the teachers... talked about 3,000 teachers... and they published the results”

0.63

Teacher unions dislike the finding that a small percentage of teachers are doing real harm because it bears directly on whether tenure protects all teachers or whether the system moves toward better evaluation, and some critics misinterpret any claim of teacher differences as being 'anti-teacher.'

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Eric Hanushek

“people in the teachers unions really dislike this argument that there are small percentage of our teachers that are really doing harm to our kids because this gets to the heart of whether they protect all teachers through tenure”

0.57

The current US education system is an emergent 'invisible hand' arrangement (not designed by anyone), and it is at least imaginable that, absent legal and governmental constraints, the value of great K-12 instruction would be higher relative to university instruction, since young students benefit more from a great teacher while adults can largely teach themselves.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“is it imaginable that that should be reversed if... the invisible hand wasn't being stopped by legal and governmental involvement... the demand for great instruction in K through 12 should be much more important... than it is for at the university level when we really are capable of teaching ourselves”

0.56

Despite the move toward accountability under No Child Left Behind since 2001, the tests themselves have not improved as much as hoped, and there has been little solid effort to develop tests that capture the deeper understanding educators care about.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Eric Hanushek

“one of the disappointments to me of the movement toward better accountability No Child Left Behind... is that the tests haven't improved as much as I would have hoped”

0.56

Last-in-first-out layoff rules force districts to fire the youngest teachers regardless of effectiveness while protecting ineffective veterans, so reductions hurt schools more than necessary—an effect a recent LA court order tried to limit for disadvantaged schools.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Eric Hanushek

“if you're going to reduce the number of teachers you have to get rid of the youngest teachers regardless of whether they're effective or ineffective and regardless whether you have some dinosaurs who've been around for thirty forty years”

0.38

Saying a child will learn 'half a standard deviation more' is meaningless to most parents, so achievement gains must be translated into clearer measures like dollars of lifetime earnings to be policy-relevant.

normativeestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Hanushek

“if I tell you that in this classroom your kid is going to learn half a standard deviation more most people have no idea what that means”

0.34

Experience can reduce teacher effectiveness after a point because teachers burn out and stop improving, with the metaphor that 'those old pages get pretty yellow' for some teachers.

causalcontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Eric Hanushek

“after you've taught a certain length of time you get little burned out and it's harder to maintain your excellence... those old pages get pretty yellow for some teachers and that has an impact”

0.32

Most schools hand out pink slips to a vast majority of teachers every spring because they don't yet know next year's budget and contracts require notice, but historically almost none of those slips were executed—though more layoffs have actually begun to occur recently.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Eric Hanushek

“every spring a vast majority of the schools in the nation hand out pink slips... saying you might be laid off because they don't even know what their budget is going to be next year... until this last year virtually none of those pink slips have actually been executed”

0.30

Looking only at salaries understates high school teacher compensation because the job includes non-monetary benefits like summers off and generous pensions.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“there's lots of non-monetary aspects of being a high school teacher summers off often generous pensions so looking just at salaries is often misleading”

0.29

Stimulus spending was marketed by transferring money to states to prevent teachers, firefighters, and police from being laid off, which is an effective political marketing strategy because the public fears schools without teachers or unsafe neighborhoods.

factualcontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Russ Roberts

“defenders of stimulus say well that kept a lot of teachers from being fired or laid off... that's a great way to market stimulus they always talk about the teachers firefighters and police”

0.12

Good teachers are better than bad ones.

factual· Russ Roberts

“obviously good teachers are better than bad ones”