Justice Holmes's formulation in Pennsylvania Coal v. Mahon that regulation is a taking 'when it goes too far' is vapid, and combined with the Supreme Court's takings jurisprudence this produces a dreadful intellectual mess in which nobody knows when land regulations go too far, generating enormous value destruction through landmark preservation and Endangered Species Act habitat rules.
causalpending
Speaker
Richard EpsteinEvidence Quote
“the Supreme Court law on takings is a dreadful intellectual mess”
Created: 10/30/2026, 3:13:18 PM
Your notes
Loading notes...