Sherman Act
The foundational US antitrust statute prohibiting restraints of trade and monopolization, referenced as what private collusive contracts would violate.
As defined in Capitalism, Government, and the Good Society
Where it comes up · 5
- Michael Munger on Antitrust4 claims
- Capitalism, Government, and the Good Society2 claims
- Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner1 claim
- Peter Thiel: The Stagnation of Science and the AI Revolution1 claim
- Michael Munger on Franchising, Vertical Integration, and the Auto Industry 06/22/20091 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “Sherman Act” →
- On cartels, there are three distinct approaches: the libertarian sees no problem because free entry self-corrects; the classical liberal favors making such restraint-of-trade contracts legally unenforceable (without criminal sanction) to hasten their decay; and the modern antitrust position uses the Sherman Act to punish cartels civilly and criminally because cartels can endure even when agreements are unenforceable.Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner
- Government protection makes cartels more dangerous, not less, as in Parker v. Brown (1943) where the Supreme Court upheld a state-organized raisin cartel against the Sherman Act precisely because the state ratified it—but a good economist recognizes a state-run cartel is durable because it won't break down from cheating, unlike a private cartel.Capitalism, Government, and the Good Society
- The biggest danger to capitalism is that government is too cooperative with capitalists through rent-seeking: a corporate manager faces a choice between creating value with better cheaper products (benefiting consumers) or lobbying legislators for protective contracts that would violate antitrust law if done privately; since shareholders are indifferent and the rent-seeking route has higher value, a manager who refuses it will be fired or face takeover—so government must armor itself against interest groups.Capitalism, Government, and the Good Society
- The Reagan-era voluntary import restraints on Japanese cars created a corrupt bargain that benefited both sides: American makers were shielded because there weren't enough imports to compete away their advantage, and Honda's profits increased dramatically because the restraints (backed by Japanese government allocation among its three makers, effectively a non-compete that would have violated the Sherman Act) meant Japanese sellers weren't forced to drive prices down.Michael Munger on Franchising, Vertical Integration, and the Auto Industry 06/22/2009
- The Left has effectively adopted originalism—usually a conservative doctrine—by returning to the legislative debates around the Sherman Act's passage, which contained a 'dog's breakfast' of goals (protecting labor, reducing inequality, protecting competitors), and arguing this original intent should be restored, thereby correctly identifying the power problem but egregiously misidentifying the solution.Michael Munger on Antitrust
- The 1945 Alcoa case was poorly decided because Judge Learned Hand defined the relevant market as only virgin aluminum (giving Alcoa a 90% monopoly) and ignored recycled aluminum competition, under which Alcoa had only about half the market, and he condemned as a Sherman Act violation Alcoa's plan to expand and cut prices—which is simply competition.Michael Munger on Antitrust
- The Sherman Act exposes a fundamental split: economic libertarians, holding a natural-rights view of contract, believe the state has no right to forbid contracts in restraint of trade, whereas economic conservatives like George Stigler and Richard Epstein support the Sherman Act as exactly the right level of enforcement.Michael Munger on Antitrust
- When oil companies adopt ESG policies and reduce production by 30%, the result can look like collusion with OPEC to raise prices and profits, though it's disguised as environmental virtue rather than antitrust violation.Peter Thiel: The Stagnation of Science and the AI Revolution
- The Sherman Act of 1890 has two clauses: one concerning industry structure (whether there are so few firms that a firm has excessive market power) and one concerning behavior (whether an activity would tend to monopolize via restrictions on price or output), marking the move from non-enforceability of restraint-of-trade contracts to criminalizing such conduct as per se illegal.Michael Munger on Antitrust