factual
Alcoa case was wrongly decided by market definition
The 1945 Alcoa case was poorly decided because Judge Learned Hand defined the relevant market as only virgin aluminum (giving Alcoa a 90% monopoly) and ignored recycled aluminum competition, under which Alcoa had only about half the market, and he condemned as a Sherman Act violation Alcoa's plan to expand and cut prices—which is simply competition.
factualpending
Speaker
Michael MungerEvidence Quote
“that may be the single worst antitrust case ever written by Judge 'Un-Learned' Hand.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:42 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...