Pigovian tax
A tax (or subsidy) advocated by A. C. Pigou to correct externalities by changing the price faced by the party generating them—taxing negative externalities and subsidizing positive ones.
As defined in Ronald Coase on Externalities, the Firm, and the State of Economics
Other definitions
A tax set equal to the marginal external cost of an activity (e.g., carbon emissions) intended to make producers internalize the externality.
Arnold Kling on Specialization and Trade
Where it comes up · 3
- Don Boudreaux on Coase2 claims
- Ronald Coase on Externalities, the Firm, and the State of Economics1 claim
- Arnold Kling on Specialization and Trade1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Pigovian tax” →
- Coase's recurring theme, akin to Hayek's, is that even the most elegant 'blackboard' model imposed on reality will always be too simple; if bottom-up forces are allowed to operate they devise more nuanced solutions that outperform engineering models, so a Pigovian tax that looks good on paper will not work as well as emergent methods of dealing with externalities.Don Boudreaux on Coase
- Despite Coase's paper challenging it for over 50 years, the Pigovian approach—taxing negative externalities and subsidizing positive ones by changing the prices people face—remains the standard way economists think, even though Coase showed sometimes it is better to do nothing and let the harmed party adapt.Ronald Coase on Externalities, the Firm, and the State of Economics
- Recommending a Pigovian carbon tax assumes a knowable optimal level that nobody can actually identify, and the prescription is always one-directional—'I hate carbon, tax it more'—with no way to recognize when a tax has become too high, so it ignores all the adjustments the market is already making and overstates economists' ability to set the right number.Arnold Kling on Specialization and Trade
- Because Coase regarded the world as more complicated than simple Pigovian theory, a Pigovian carbon tax—though one way to address global warming—may not be the best way; it might be cheaper to let warming occur (if it is happening) and let humans adapt, rather than forgo current output that the tax would sacrifice.Don Boudreaux on Coase