Ronald Coase on Externalities, the Firm, and the State of Economics
What this covers
Ronald Coase, Nobel laureate, speaks with Russ Roberts about his career, the state of economics, and China's economic transformation. The conversation spans Coase's two landmark papers—"The Nature of the Firm" and "The Problem of Social Cost"—and his recent book on China written with Ning Wang. Throughout, Coase argues that economics has abandoned empirical reality for abstract theorizing, and that understanding firms, externalities, and government requires studying how things actually operate rather than constructing imaginary systems.
The heart of Coase's complaint is blackboard economics: the field's drift toward models disconnected from the world. He contends that firms exist precisely because the price system is expensive to use; within organizations, command-and-control replaces constant price-based negotiation. He is equally critical of what has become known as the "Coase Theorem," dismissing it as a misrepresentation—it assumes zero transaction costs, a system that cannot exist. This leads to a normative point: since transaction costs are real and often high, property rights assignment matters greatly, and the Pigovian approach of taxing negative externalities does not always improve outcomes.
On China, Coase describes growth driven by village enterprises and unemployed workers starting businesses—a "Marginal Revolution" operating largely outside and despite government direction, illustrating both the limits of central control and what capitalism with Chinese characteristics actually means. He argues China remains far behind the West in productivity per capita and innovation, leaving substantial room for continued growth, though much current government infrastructure spending is likely unproductive. Throughout, he emphasizes that progress in economics depends on abandoning elegant abstraction and doing the harder work of understanding reality.
Coase argues that economics has gone astray by becoming 'blackboard economics'—abstract theorizing about imaginary systems—and that real understanding of firms, externalities, and government requires empirical study of how things actually operate in the real world.
- Firms exist because using the price system is costly, so command-and-control is cheaper
- The Coase Theorem misrepresents his point because it assumes zero transaction costs, a system that cannot exist
- China's growth has happened largely outside and despite government control, illustrating the limits of central direction
Modern economics is too abstract and detached from empirical reality of how actual systems function.
- Modern economics is too abstract—'blackboard economics'—because it studies imaginary systems that are not empirically based and don't concern themselves with what really happens; the remedy is more empirical study of how things actually operate.
“Blackboard economics is economics which you can put on the blackboard, in which you study an imaginary system. It's not empirically based at all. It's not concerned with what really happens.”
- The statistical study economists do is not genuine empirical work because it draws conclusions from bunches of statistics rather than finding out what really happens; real empirical work means getting down and studying what actually occurs.
“Blackboard economics is economics which you can put on the blackboard, in which you study an imaginary system. It's not empirically based at all. It's not concerned with what really happens.”
- Coase dislikes 'the Coase Theorem' because it is a proposition about a system with no transaction costs—a system that could not exist and is therefore unimaginable; he only posited the zero-transaction-cost case to explain his views, not as a description of reality.
“I don't like it because it's a proposition about a system in which there were no transaction costs. It's a system which couldn't exist. And therefore it's quite unimaginable.”
- The influence of Game Theory on the study of the firm was wholly bad because it led people to develop high theoretical approaches instead of approaches based on what actually happens; only recently have people begun to study what really happens rather than engaging in blackboard economics.
“I think the influence was wholly bad, because people developed high theoretical approaches instead of approaches based on what actually happens.”
Understanding firm organization requires studying why command-and-control replaces price mechanisms when transaction costs are high.
- The economic treatment of the firm has by and large gotten worse over 70 years rather than progressing; we should study what actually happens at firms and how they operate, and Coase is optimistic this empirical turn will eventually happen.
“I think the treatment by economists has by and large got worse, if that's possible. I think the time has come when we should study what actually happens, study firms and how they operate and learn from that.”
- Firms exist and operate by command-and-control rather than internal prices because using the price system is expensive—making bargains requires knowing many things—so a system that avoids constant negotiation saves a lot of costs; within firms, people do what they are told rather than respond to prices.
“It's cheaper because the price system is a very expensive system. If you think of all the things you have to know in order to make a bargain it's obvious it's not a cheap system. And a system that avoids negotiations is one that saves a lot of costs.”
- When transaction costs are high, firms are more likely to use command-and-control rather than the price system, but the state of economics is such that people don't try to measure transaction costs, allowing discussions and explanations to proceed without real knowledge of the real world.
“It's very relevant. But the state of economics is such that people don't try to measure these things, to study them, and so people can engage in discussions and explanations without any real knowledge of what happens in the real world.”
Government and human institutions persistently err in ways empirical study can identify and potentially correct.
- Government should give up a great deal, and how much it should give up can only be determined by studying how government actually operates; the assumption that governments always do the right thing is false—they make many errors—and where they are most likely to err can be found through empirical study of government.
“the assumption that governments always do the right thing is not true. They make lots of errors, and where they are most likely to make errors can be found by studying how governments operate.”
- Studying how things actually operate reveals the importance of the stupidity of human behavior; major catastrophes like both World Wars were tragedies that need not have happened and could have been stopped, illustrating how persistent error pervades human affairs and government.
“it's not possible to study how things are dealt with without realizing the importance of the stupidity of human behavior.”
- Warren Nutter's estimates of Russian production produced figures far lower than the official British government figure and were dismissed as bias, but it was later proven that the official figures were too high and Nutter was closer to correct.
“Warren Nutter, who was making estimates of the Russian production ended up with a figure no where near the official figure of the British government. This was thought to be due to his bias. We now know the one that whose own figures were too high.”
China's economic transformation occurred through decentralized capitalist enterprise despite state control, and growth will continue given low current productivity.
- China is currently the workshop of the world, producing large parts of its output on the basis of orders from abroad with what is produced determined in Europe and the Americas rather than in China; it is not very innovative now, but as it becomes more innovative its production will become more valuable and significant.
“They produce large parts of their stuff on the basis of orders from abroad. What is produced is not determined in China but is determined in Europe and the Americas.”
- China is very capitalist but not capitalism as we know it—it is capitalism with Chinese characteristics—and the country has been transformed not by the Chinese government's operations but by a 'Marginal Revolution' of village enterprises and unemployed people starting businesses, change happening despite and outside the control of the government.
“it's not being transformed as people in Europe commonly think as a result of the Chinese government's operations, but as the result of what we call the Marginal Revolution--change is taking place despite the Chinese government.”
- China's growth is likely to continue precisely because its output per capita and productivity remain very low and its institutions and legal system are very undeveloped, leaving a long way to go to catch up with the West; high total output reflects a large population, not high productivity.
“China has a long way to go to catch up with the West in terms of productivity, in terms of the institutions required to make a really good economic system. And that's why I think we are going to see further growth in China. It's got a long way to go.”
Despite witnessing major failures, human capacity to learn and exploit opportunities justifies long-term optimism about economic progress.
- China is a very big country that is difficult to control and difficult to know what's going on in, captured by the Chinese saying 'the mountain is high and the emperor is far away'—a Hayekian point about local knowledge that only nearby people possess.
“China is a very big country, and it's very difficult to control. It's very difficult to know what's going on. And so things can happen. There's a Chinese saying... The mountain is high and the emperor is far away.”
- Despite witnessing world wars, genocide, and bad economics since 1910, Coase is an optimist about the human enterprise because the opportunities are so great and we will take advantage of them, albeit slowly and with further mistakes.
“Well, I'm an optimist. The opportunities are so great. And I think we will take advantage of them, very slowly of course, and [?] will come further mistakes, but I'm optimistic about the future.”
- The Chinese government is doing a lot of things, most of them being failures, while the economy operates under the Chinese Communist Party which commonly doesn't know what's going on; much building and infrastructure is unlikely to be productive.
“The government is doing a lot of things, most of them being failures. It's an economy which is under the Chinese Communist Party, but the Chinese Communist Party commonly doesn't know what's going on.”
- We should not give up an approach (like empirically studying firm-specific cases) merely because it is hard; life is hard, and we should look for ways to solve the problem rather than easy ways to do things.
“Well, we shouldn't give up an approach because it's hard. Life is hard. We shouldn't be looking for easy ways to do things but for ways to solve the problem.”
- China's economic success is a good thing for the world and for the Chinese people, and not bad for the United States, because US productivity per head is far greater than China's and likely to continue being so.
“Our productivity per head is far greater than that in China. And likely to continue.”