normative

Pigovian Taxes Have No Knowable Optimum

Recommending a Pigovian carbon tax assumes a knowable optimal level that nobody can actually identify, and the prescription is always one-directional—'I hate carbon, tax it more'—with no way to recognize when a tax has become too high, so it ignores all the adjustments the market is already making and overstates economists' ability to set the right number.

normativepending

Speaker

Arnold Kling

Evidence Quote

“How would you know if your tax on carbon had ever gotten to be too high? And you just say, 'I hate carbon; let's tax it more.' There's no way of knowing what the amount is.”

Source

Arnold Kling on Specialization and Trade— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:09:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...