Peltzman effect
The phenomenon, named for economist Sam Peltzman, whereby reducing the cost or danger of a risky behavior leads people to engage in more of that behavior; a form of moral hazard.
As defined in Jim Manzi on the Oregon Medicaid Study, Experimental Evidence, and Causality
Other definitions
The tendency for safety regulations to be partly offset by riskier behavior, as people who feel safer compensate by taking more risk—named after Sam Peltzman's car-safety study.
David Henderson on the Essential UCLA School of Economics
Where it comes up · 8
- Greg Ip on Foolproof2 claims
- Gary Belsky on the Origins of Sports2 claims
- Richard Robb on Willful2 claims
- Roger Noll on the Economics of Sports1 claim
- Jim Manzi on the Oregon Medicaid Study, Experimental Evidence, and Causality1 claim
- David Henderson on the Essential UCLA School of Economics1 claim
- Roy Baumeister on Gender Differences and Culture 11/14/20111 claim
- The Economics of Moneyball with Skip Sauer 10/23/20061 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “Peltzman effect” →
- Peltzman-style risk compensation: when government makes cars safer through airbags, anti-lock brakes, or seatbelt mandates, drivers respond by driving more recklessly, so accidents may rise and pedestrians can be harmed, although the net effect on mortality is unclear empirically.The Economics of Moneyball with Skip Sauer 10/23/2006
- Football helmets function as a missile and paradoxically make the game more dangerous—an illustration of the Peltzman effect, where protective equipment changes behavior toward more risk—whereas rugby players, with similar physical attributes but no helmets, do not suffer the same brain-injury problems.Roger Noll on the Economics of Sports
- Football helmets, introduced to protect players, became so good at protection that players grew reckless and used them as armor rather than safety devices—a classic case of unintended consequences (the Peltzman effect / moral hazard); eliminating helmets from practice would force players to develop better tackling technique using shoulders and arms.Gary Belsky on the Origins of Sports
- Peltzman found that 1960s car-safety laws (padded dashboards, seat belts) did not lower driver fatality rates but raised fatality rates for motorcyclists and pedestrians, because feeling safer led people to drive more intensely—faster and following closer—a behavioral offsetting effect later corroborated by NASCAR studies showing intensity rose as driving got safer.David Henderson on the Essential UCLA School of Economics
- Football helmets make the sport more dangerous rather than safer, because the protective equipment changes how players act, an effect that economists call the Peltzman effect, and boxing gloves similarly allow harder head blows.Roy Baumeister on Gender Differences and Culture 11/14/2011
- Even if the government profited fiscally on the bailouts, that is the wrong calculus: the disastrous effect is on the incentives for prudent investing, because a world in which the worst-case scenario gets bailed out can shape risk-taking behavior—just as the Peltzman effect shapes a football player or driver—even if the actors never explicitly said they were counting on a bailout.Richard Robb on Willful
- When something is made safer—antilock brakes, seatbelts, airbags, better football helmets—people compensate by behaving more recklessly (the Peltzman effect), so although any single outcome may be safer, there can be more risky episodes; banning helmets on some ski mountains reflected this, yet even with the offsetting recklessness the net effect can still be beneficial for everyone.Richard Robb on Willful
- Reducing the cost (in the broad, non-monetary sense) of the negative outcomes of a risky behavior like smoking can, via the Peltzman/moral-hazard effect, increase the incidence of that behavior; in this context insurance coverage might most plausibly cause people to delay quitting smoking rather than to start, or alternatively reduced financial stress from coverage frees money to spend on cigarettes.Jim Manzi on the Oregon Medicaid Study, Experimental Evidence, and Causality
- Risk compensation means that making something feel more dangerous makes people more careful: a metal spike in steering wheels would make people drive slower, and drivers of small cars they perceive as less safe drive more carefully than SUV drivers—so you want a large car if you're going to crash but a small one if you want to avoid crashing.Gary Belsky on the Origins of Sports
- Peltzman hypothesized that if drivers feel safer they drive faster because the risk of an accident is part of the price of fast driving, and his early research found that seatbelts and safety devices encouraged faster driving so that while drivers were less likely to die, pedestrian accidents increased; later research showed cars are not actually less safe with seatbelts (deaths fall) but the benefit is smaller than designers expected because of the offsetting behavior.Greg Ip on Foolproof