Paris Club
An informal group of 22 bilateral official creditor governments (mostly wealthy nations) that coordinates the restructuring of sovereign debt for developing countries, originating from Argentina's 1956 debt crisis.
As defined in Griffin Lecture 2022: Deborah Brautigam on "China, the U.S., and Global Debt: Why Cooperate?"
Where it comes up · 2
- Griffin Lecture 2022: Deborah Brautigam on "China, the U.S., and Global Debt: Why Cooperate?"7 claims
- China, India and the Global Order (or Disorder)1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “Paris Club” →
- The G20 represents 80% of global income, 60% of global population, and three-quarters of global exports, giving it far more legitimacy than the Paris Club or OECD because it includes both China and the United States alongside emerging markets, though private sector bondholders (63% of global debt) are still not directly represented.Griffin Lecture 2022: Deborah Brautigam on "China, the U.S., and Global Debt: Why Cooperate?"
- When asked if China wants to be in the driver's seat of the IMF, the real answer is that China wants neither to be marginalized nor to be constrained by the baggage of existing Western-dominated systems; China is operating a parallel system through debt relief (postponing rather than writing off) tied to RMB currency use.China, India and the Global Order (or Disorder)
- Global debt governance has historically occurred through a mix of formal rules (IMF, World Bank under Bretton Woods) and informal institutions or club governance (Paris Club, G20), with the Bretton Woods system of 1944 establishing the foundation for post-crisis financial architecture.Griffin Lecture 2022: Deborah Brautigam on "China, the U.S., and Global Debt: Why Cooperate?"
- China launched its own debt cancellation program in 2000 for poor countries, which differed from the HIPC Initiative because it did not require structural adjustment reforms or economic liberalization that the World Bank and IMF demanded, but was limited to only interest-free loans and totaled about $3.4 billion over 20 years.Griffin Lecture 2022: Deborah Brautigam on "China, the U.S., and Global Debt: Why Cooperate?"
- From 1956 to 1988, the Paris Club provided only modest extensions of payment periods and no essential debt relief, but in 1988 accepted that some countries had insolvency problems (not just liquidity problems), and began implementing modest haircuts (debt value reductions), which were expanded to the World Bank and IMF in 1996.Griffin Lecture 2022: Deborah Brautigam on "China, the U.S., and Global Debt: Why Cooperate?"
- The Common Framework, formed by the G20 to restructure debt, is an experiment that includes only three countries (Chad, Zambia, and Ethiopia) and only the poorest 73 countries, but excludes middle-income countries that have also defaulted and owe significant debt to China and others.Griffin Lecture 2022: Deborah Brautigam on "China, the U.S., and Global Debt: Why Cooperate?"
- During the DSSI, there was confusion about definitions of 'official bilateral creditor' versus 'commercial creditor' because while Paris Club members and G20 governments had common understandings, the IMF did not use these definitions, leading Germany to classify its state-owned bank as commercial and China to do the same with China Development Bank.Griffin Lecture 2022: Deborah Brautigam on "China, the U.S., and Global Debt: Why Cooperate?"
- By early 2020, the Paris Club held only 8% of African debt while China held about 17%, and the Paris Club used a one-size-fits-all approach to debt restructuring whereas China used a project-by-project, loan-by-loan tailored approach.Griffin Lecture 2022: Deborah Brautigam on "China, the U.S., and Global Debt: Why Cooperate?"