One China policy
The diplomatic position that there is one China and Taiwan is part of it, historically accepted across Western parties with the expectation of peaceful unification.
As defined in Dominic Cummings - COVID, Brexit, & Fixing Western Governance
The US diplomatic position, held for 50 years, that recognizes Beijing while maintaining strategic ambiguity about Taiwan's status rather than recognizing Taiwanese independence.
Dave SmithThe US diplomatic position, established under Nixon and Kissinger, acknowledging Beijing's stance that there is one China, while maintaining unofficial relations with Taiwan.
387 - Politics PowerUS diplomatic stance established in the 1970s acknowledging the People's Republic of China as the sole legitimate government of China while maintaining economic and unofficial relations with Taiwan, without explicitly committing to military defense
Ukraine, Israel, Taiwan: crisis and conflict in the context of a new cold war
- Dominic Cummings - COVID, Brexit, & Fixing Western Governance2 claims
- Dave Smith2 claims
- How China Might View a Second Trump Administration: A Conversation with Mr. Rick Waters1 claim
- Ukraine, Israel, Taiwan: crisis and conflict in the context of a new cold war1 claim
- What's Really Driving China's Strategic Objectives? (w/ M. Taylor Fravel & Mike Green)1 claim
- 387 - Politics Power1 claim
- Vivek Ramaswamy1 claim
- Trump's acceptance of a phone call from Taiwan President Tsai Ing-wen during the transition period before his February 2017 reconfirmation of the One China policy created a diplomatic crisis that 'unsettled everything' in US-China relations, requiring Xi Jinping's direct intervention to restore the strategic relationship.How China Might View a Second Trump Administration: A Conversation with Mr. Rick Waters
- Avoiding major conflict with China starts with clear red lines on both sides: the US must hold a hard red line that China will not annex Taiwan by force for the foreseeable future, while prudently maintaining its decades-old quiet deference to the one China policy (since formally recognizing Taiwan as independent would be China's red line); the Thucydides trap is a theory, not a law of physics, and conflict is not inevitable.Vivek Ramaswamy
- The one China policy has been the official policy of the United States for 50 years, so conflict arises when American politicians assert China has no right to enter Taiwan, contradicting the recognized policy—and declaring Taiwan independent could itself provoke a Chinese invasion.Dave Smith
- The optimal Western strategy toward China is détente: restate the One China policy (post-1972), avoid trade/investment restrictions, and reduce sanctions on semiconductors and tariffs, offering China things of interest to its leadership (not vague statements from Gina Raimondo or Janet Yellen) in exchange for reduced geopolitical riskUkraine, Israel, Taiwan: crisis and conflict in the context of a new cold war
- Recent US support for Taiwan has increased substantially with high-profile cabinet and senior official visits, raising questions about whether the US still maintains a one-China policy, which concerns Fravel because China's assessment of US commitments shapes how China thinks about Taiwan.What's Really Driving China's Strategic Objectives? (w/ M. Taylor Fravel & Mike Green)
- If chip dependence on Taiwan's TSMC is the real concern, the response should be a Manhattan Project-style effort to manufacture chips domestically rather than risk war, because Taiwan is not magical and these things can be produced in other places.Dave Smith
- Extending a nuclear umbrella or strategic ambiguity over Taiwan is non-credible and dangerous because, unlike NATO's mutual defense which was credible for America, Taiwan is not existential for the US, so threatening nuclear war over a Chinese-populated island China sees as existential is either bluffing or insane—and 1914 shows how strategic ambiguity ends, now with weapons that kill a thousand times more, a thousand times faster.Dominic Cummings - COVID, Brexit, & Fixing Western Governance
- The West has simultaneously pushed Ukraine into a war of attrition with Russia, ratcheted up diplomacy against China over Taiwan by abandoning One China policy, thereby driving the world's biggest manufacturer into alliance with Russia, all while leaving a rotten defense procurement system unreformed—a scenario so incoherent it would seem too ludicrous to invent.Dominic Cummings - COVID, Brexit, & Fixing Western Governance
- US policy toward Taiwan is 'strategic ambiguity'—a deliberate ambiguity established when Kissinger and Nixon formulated the one-China policy—and Taiwan is not a treaty ally, in contrast to the Philippines.387 - Politics Power