Lucas critique
Robert Lucas's argument that people understand how the economy works well enough to alter their private behavior in response to government policy, thereby undoing the policy's intended effect; named after the Chicago economist.
As defined in Benjamin Friedman
Other definitions
Robert Lucas's argument that policy interventions are unreliable to predict because the people being acted upon hold expectations that adjust to the policy itself.
Jennifer Burns on Milton Friedman
Where it comes up · 7
- Economist Who Predicted Brexit & Trump Brilliantly Explains Capitalism's Collapse2 claims
- Valerie Ramey on Stimulus and Multipliers 10/24/20111 claim
- Benjamin Friedman1 claim
- Nicholas Wapshott on Keynes and Hayek1 claim
- Erik Hoel on Consciousness, Free Will, and the Limits of Science1 claim
- Jennifer Burns on Milton Friedman1 claim
- John Quiggin on Zombie Economics 11/01/20101 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “Lucas critique” →
- Robert Lucas argued that policy effects cannot be estimated by regressing historical data without accounting for whether a policy is expected to be permanent or temporary, and Tom Sargent developed methods to estimate deep structural parameters that allow policy analysis outside historical experience.Valerie Ramey on Stimulus and Multipliers 10/24/2011
- The Lucas Critique holds that policymakers cannot reach desired outcomes because populations react to imposed policies in unanticipated ways; relatedly, Austrian economists (Hayek, Mises) argue that knowledge of how we would respond to price changes exists only in our brains, cannot be written down, and is produced through the market process itself, so prices cannot be predicted by equations in advance—paralleling the clone problem in free-will debates.Erik Hoel on Consciousness, Free Will, and the Limits of Science
- The Rational Expectations movement (Lucas, Sargent) reached Friedman's conclusions — including a modern, mathematically formal version of his old-fashioned argument that the economy is too complicated to intervene in given that actors hold expectations — but used precisely the kind of formal models Friedman opposed, making it 'his bastard child'; Friedman was ambivalent about it privately while more supportive publicly.Jennifer Burns on Milton Friedman
- Roberts argues that despite decades of increasingly mathematical economics and the rise of econometric modeling, the ability to use econometrics to steer the economy and assess public policy was devastatingly critiqued by Robert Lucas in 1976, and today we still have the same unresolved debate—some say the stimulus worked, some say it failed—demonstrating that the inability of econometric techniques to settle such debates is one of the great lessons of the last 50 years.Nicholas Wapshott on Keynes and Hayek
- Lucas critique states that if you persistently target a particular economic variable for policy, economic actors will learn to game it, making policy ineffective; Blyth argues this critique was ignored when governments shifted from targeting full employment to targeting inflationEconomist Who Predicted Brexit & Trump Brilliantly Explains Capitalism's Collapse
- The Lucas critique drove macroeconomics toward fully-specified micro-foundations whose first versions implied business cycles are impossible unless governments cause them; Keynesians responded with more sophisticated models that worked during the Great Moderation but explicitly bracketed and could not explain the Great Depression.John Quiggin on Zombie Economics 11/01/2010
- After 30 years of targeting full employment (1945-1975) under Lucas critique, governments then spent 30 years (1975-2005) targeting inflation instead, and now $13 trillion in quantitative easing and other central bank programs have been dumped into the global money supply without producing inflation anywhereEconomist Who Predicted Brexit & Trump Brilliantly Explains Capitalism's Collapse
- The Lucas critique is overrated because it places far too much burden on the knowledge and understanding of ordinary citizens, assuming people understand policy implications well enough to take private actions that undo the intended effect of any government policy intervention.Benjamin Friedman