Hubble tension
The unresolved disagreement between the locally measured expansion rate of the universe (~73) and the value predicted from early-universe CMB data (~67).
As defined in 118 | Adam Riess on the Expansion of the Universe and a Crisis in Cosmology
Where it comes up · 10
- The “Crisis in Cosmology” EXPLAINED4 claims
- 310 | Marc Kamionkowski on Dark Energy and Cosmic Anomalies4 claims
- 118 | Adam Riess on the Expansion of the Universe and a Crisis in Cosmology2 claims
- New Theory Inspection: Is the Universe a Bubble? I had a look1 claim
- 170 | Priya Natarajan on Galaxies, Black Holes, and Cosmic Anomalies1 claim
- 243 | Joseph Silk on Science on the Moon1 claim
- 358 | Solo: Vacuum Energy and the Cosmological Constant1 claim
- AMA | September 20231 claim
and 2 more
Most important claims · 10 of 17Search all claims for “Hubble tension” →
- The early-universe model predicts a Hubble constant of about 67 ± 0.5 km/s/Mpc while direct local measurements average about 73 ± 1.5 (ranging 70-75), producing a 4-6 sigma discrepancy that no single identifiable error can explain because so many independent methods are used at both ends.118 | Adam Riess on the Expansion of the Universe and a Crisis in Cosmology
- How and by whom a new scientific idea is proposed materially affects its acceptance; on an uneven playing field, the GGSL tension is unlikely to garner the attention Adam Riess won for the Hubble tension, partly because Riess's Nobel Prize confers intellectual authority that makes the community take his anomalies seriously, and partly because some subfields (like gravitational lensing) carry less prestige than others.170 | Priya Natarajan on Galaxies, Black Holes, and Cosmic Anomalies
- If the local universe distance ladder measurement of the Hubble constant is wrong, it implies that the distance ladder has a systematic calibration error, whereas if the CMB measurement is wrong, it implies that the cosmological model of the universe itself is flawed, representing the two main interpretations of the Hubble tension.The “Crisis in Cosmology” EXPLAINED
- There is currently no single silver-bullet explanation for the Hubble tension: theoretical ideas that get close are fine-tuned, and proposed systematic errors only knock out one observation rather than all of them, so a resolution would require multiple effects or a 'conspiracy' of systematic errors going in the same direction.118 | Adam Riess on the Expansion of the Universe and a Crisis in Cosmology
- The Hubble tension is the discrepancy between the value of the Hubble constant measured via early-universe background radiation (as it was ~300,000 years after the Big Bang) versus values measured using nearby objects at later times.Ask Me Anything | July 2024
- The Hubble tension is a genuine inconsistency rather than evidence that the Hubble constant simply changes over time, because the early-universe and late-universe measurements, when interpreted within the same cosmological model, predict the same present-day expansion rate, so their disagreement signals a problem with the model or measurements, not mere temporal variation.AMA | September 2023
- The Hubble tension may stem from the indirect 'distance ladder' method built on stellar and supernova indicators, whose first rung could be unstable; Silk withholds judgment until direct geometrical distance indicators—not reliant on climbing a ladder—are securely in place within the next decade.243 | Joseph Silk on Science on the Moon
- In an alternate reality where the TRGB method had been invented and deployed before the Cepheid method, there would be no Hubble tension because CMB and TRGB measurements would show almost perfect agreement, and the Cepheid method would likely be dismissed as a troubled method due to dust contamination.The “Crisis in Cosmology” EXPLAINED
- Until about three years ago it was reasonable to worry that the Hubble Space Telescope's imperfect resolution let light from nearby stars contaminate Cepheid variable measurements; but the James Webb Space Telescope's superior angular resolution eliminated this crowding issue, and for the 16 Cepheid hosts remeasured, the results were spot-on with the HST values—making the Hubble tension more serious now than three years ago.310 | Marc Kamionkowski on Dark Energy and Cosmic Anomalies
- The Hubble tension—a statistically noticeable discrepancy between the Hubble constant measured from nearby data and from the early-universe CMB—is fairly solid as evidence, but lacks a good theoretical explanation, which makes Carroll reluctant to take it too seriously, in contrast to the birefringence claim which is theoretically explicable but observationally weaker.Holiday Message 2020 | The Screwy Universe