What this covers

Adam Riess and Sean Carroll discuss the Hubble tension—a persistent disagreement between two independent measurements of how fast the universe expands. The cosmic microwave background predicts an expansion rate around 67 kilometers per second per megaparsec, while direct local measurements yield roughly 73. Riess, a Nobel laureate who helped discover the universe's acceleration in 1998, argues this 4–6 sigma discrepancy is too robust to dismiss as mere measurement error and instead points toward genuinely missing physics. The conversation traces how this tension emerged as precision improved rather than shrinking, and why it matters: unlike historical disputes that compared two views of the same era, this one could mean both measurements are correct but the intervening model itself is incomplete.

Riess walks through the observational machinery behind the dispute—the Cosmic Distance Ladder, Type Ia supernova standard candles, and Cepheid variable calibrations—showing how independent geometric methods converge on the local value. He then explains why solving the tension requires choosing where new physics lives: the dark energy equation of state is now pinned near −1, leaving little room for late-universe modifications, so attention has shifted to the early universe. The conversation also touches on a second tension in matter clumpiness (Sigma 8) and addresses why cosmologists lack motivation to defend the current model—discovering it fails would be "fantastic news" for finding deeper physics. Throughout, Riess emphasizes that the goal is not to split the difference but to understand why two complete views of the cosmos diverge, drawing on historical parallels like Anomaly Resolution: New Object vs New Physics to show that intuition alone cannot predict whether tensions signal overlooked systematics or genuine theoretical gaps.

Sharpest takeaway

Riess argues that the Hubble tension—a persistent 4-6 sigma disagreement between the locally measured expansion rate (~73) and the value predicted from the cosmic microwave background (~67)—is too robust across independent methods to be a mere systematic error and likely signals missing physics, most plausibly in the early universe.

  • Three independent geometric calibrations of Cepheids all yield local Hubble values in tension with the CMB prediction
  • The late-universe dark energy equation of state is now pinned near -1, so model changes are easier to motivate in the early universe
  • The discrepancy has grown rather than shrunk as measurement precision improved

The argument · threads1 threads · 39 claims
0.85

Modifying gravity to reconcile different regimes conflicts with effective field theory's expectations in weak-field limits.

1 pointcentrality 5/5
  • Changing gravity so it fits the solar system, binary pulsars and gravitational waves yet differs for cosmology is not only empirically difficult (attempts have failed) but also contrary to what effective field theory expects, since in the weak-field regime of the whole universe we should be on firm ground—though large conceptual mistakes are by nature invisible while being made, warranting an open mind.

    “changing gravity in such a way that it fits the solar system and the binary pulsar and gravitational waves and all that, but is different for cosmology, is just not only hard because we've tried it and it's been difficult, but also not at all what you'd expect from the philosophy of effective field theory”