
The “Crisis in Cosmology” EXPLAINED
What this covers
This is a solo explainer written and presented by David Kipping, built as a walk through the problem before any verdict. It begins with the expansion of the universe, which Edwin Hubble and George Lemaître each inferred in the late 1920s, and with the Hubble constant that sets its rate. It then lays out the two measurements that disagree. The cosmic microwave background (CMB)) route, fitted with a six-parameter model, gives Planck's 67.4 ± 0.5 km/s/Mpc. The local-universe route gives about 73.0. Kipping frames what each failure would mean: a miscalibrated ladder on one side, a flawed cosmological model on the other.
Most of the middle is a close look at the local method. He covers Henrietta Leavitt's period–luminosity relation for Cepheids, then the rungs that lead on to Type 1A supernovae, and explains why an error low on the ladder carries upward. The contentious part is the Cepheids themselves. They are young stars in dusty, crowded disk regions, and only a few dozen are available in the Milky Way. Astronomers also disagree on the metallicity coefficient, which can shift the result by a percent or more.
The turn comes with the tip of the red giant branch (TRGB)), the method Wendy Freedman's team used to recalibrate the ladder. It sits 1.3 sigma from the CMB value and 2.9 sigma from the Cepheid value. Kipping also offers a counterfactual in which TRGB had come first and no tension would exist. He then looks ahead to JWST cross-checks and closes with a critique of the "crisis" headline, arguing for sober analysis over sensationalism.
The Hubble tension—a discrepancy between cosmic microwave background and local universe measurements of the universe's expansion rate—may be resolved not by revolutionary new physics, but by systematic errors in the distance ladder calibration, particularly dust obscuration of Cepheid variables and uncertainties in metallicity corrections.
- The tip of the red giant branch method lands between the two conflicting measurements, suggesting both prior methods may contain systematic errors rather than one being fundamentally wrong
- Dust contamination of young Cepheids and poorly calibrated metallicity dependencies introduce percent-level uncertainties in the distance ladder
- Future data from Gaia and JWST should resolve whether the crisis reflects new physics or measurement methodology rather than fundamental cosmological breakdown
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
If the local universe distance ladder measurement of the Hubble constant is wrong, it implies that the distance ladder has a systematic calibration error, whereas if the CMB measurement is wrong, it implies that the cosmological model of the universe itself is flawed, representing the two main interpretations of the Hubble tension.
“So something is very weird here. One of these measurements must be wrong. If it is the local universe one, then that implies that our distance ladder is most likely in error. There must be some systematic calibration issue with what we did there. But if it were the CMB one that was wrong, then that would imply that our cosmological model of the universe is itself flawed. That's perhaps the most exciting of these two options. 'Cause it would mean that there was new physics beyond the current model.”
Only a few dozen Cepheids exist in the Milky Way, making it difficult to precisely measure the dependencies of the Leavitt Law on color and metallicity from this small sample, and additionally challenging to measure these properties for Cepheids in other galaxies.
“There's actually only a few dozen cepheids in the Milky Way, so it's gonna be difficult to precisely measure these new dependencies from such a small sample to begin with, as well as of course, challenging to measure those same properties for other galaxies down the road.”
The patterns and inhomogeneities revealed when subtracting the average temperature from CMB data encode information about the shape, composition, and structure of the universe, and can be described by a physical model using just six free parameters describing the mixture of matter, dark matter, and dark energy as well as the shape of the universe and its expansion rate.
“subtracting off that average, the patterns and inhomogeneity that are revealed encode information about the shape, composition, and structure of the universe. Remarkably, just about everything within the CMB can be described by a physical model using just six free parameters describing the mixture of matter, dark matter, and dark energy as well as the shape of the universe and its expansion rate.”
The Hubble constant, the rate of universe expansion, has been measured using two independent methods that produce measurements differing by enough to be difficult to reconcile: the cosmic microwave background method yielding ~67.4 km/s/Mpc, and the local universe distance ladder method yielding ~73.0 km/s/Mpc.
“this number has been measured with two independent methods, which seem to give answers which are sufficiently different that they're difficult to reconcile.”
The TRGB method avoids the metallicity problem of Cepheids because there is hardly any metallicity dependency in the TRGB luminosity, unlike the Leavitt Law.
“Since unlike the Leavitt Law, there's hardly any dependency in mentality here, which remember it's very difficult to measure at cosmic distances.”
Cepheid variable stars are massive, regularly pulsing stars that are very bright and detectable across intergalactic distances, with pulsation periods intimately related to their brightness in a relationship discovered by Henrietta Leavitt.
“One called a cepheid variable. All we really need to know is that cepheids are massive stars that regularly pulse, causing their brightness to periodically increase and decrease. These are very bright objects detectable from across intergalactic space and it was Henrietta Leavitt who discovered that their pulsation periods were intimately related to their brightness.”
The distance ladder is a multi-rung hierarchical measurement technique where each rung depends upon the correct calibration of the previous rung(s), so that if any lower rung is miscalibrated, all higher rungs will also produce incorrect distances.
“In this way you can think of it as being like the second rung in a ladder, which depends upon that first rung, which remember is correctly calibrating that law. In fact, we could even go to a third rung, which depends upon the second rung...”
The luminosity of Type 1A supernovae as standard candles must be calibrated using observations of those supernovae in galaxies where Cepheids are also visible, allowing astronomers to use Cepheid distances to determine the supernovae's true luminosity.
“In some galaxies we see type 1A's go off and in those same galaxies we also see cepheids. That means that we can use the cepheids to measure the distance to that galaxy, which of course means that that must also be the distance to our supernovae. And then we can figure out how luminous the supernovae was.”
Giant stars, which have evolved beyond the main sequence and are burning hydrogen in a shell around their inert helium core, eventually reach a peak luminosity called the tip of the red giant branch (TRGB) before helium fusion begins, and this peak is independent of metallicity.
“Stars like the sun, fuse hydrogen inter helium in their core, but eventually they'll swell by hundreds of times as they exhaust a supply of hydrogen fuel in their cores and instead start fusing the hydrogen around the shell of the core...Eventually the pressure in the stellar core becomes sufficiently high that the thus far inert helium ash starts to fuse...That reversal point, the peak luminosity is called the tip of the red giant branch, and it's largely independent of the star's metallicity unlike for cepheids.”
The universe is expanding, a conclusion reached independently by Edwin Hubble and George Lemaître in the late 1920s based on observations showing that distant galaxies move away faster the further they are from us.
“observations of distant galaxies reveal that the further away a galaxy is the faster it appears to be moving away from us. Both Edwin Hubble and George Lemaître independently realize that the universe must be expanding in order to explain this.”
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) may provide a firm answer on the correct metallicity correction coefficient through its improved spectroscopic capabilities, but currently astronomers may have to wait for this clarification.
“there is some hope that JWST will provide a firm answer here thanks to its improved spectroscopic capabilities, but for now we may have to wait.”
The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) is already observing nearby galaxies to measure their distances using both the Cepheid technique and the TRGB method, as well as other techniques, in an effort to determine whether these different methods agree with each other.
“Yet more, JWST is already observing nearby galaxies in an effort to measure their distances using both the cepheid technique and with giant stars as well as other methods too, to hopefully finally figure out whether they agree with each other or not.”
The metallicity dependency coefficient in the Leavitt Law, analogous to an exchange rate, determines how to convert metallicity measurements into luminosity corrections, but astronomers do not agree on this coefficient, with recently published values showing a significant range that can introduce percent-level discrepancies in the Hubble constant.
“The dependency of luminosity upon metallicity is characterized by this coefficient in the Leavitt Law equation. It's almost like the exchange rate going from dollars to Yen. If you want to know the value of your Yen, then you of course need to know the exchange rate to make an accurate conversion. The problem is that astronomers don't really agree on this coefficient as shown by the range of recently published values shown here. And these differences can introduce discrepancies in the Hubble constant at the percent level.”
Type 1A supernovae are thought to be standard candles with standard luminosities, functioning as the third rung of the distance ladder, and because they are so bright they can be detected out to distances of up to a billion light-years, much further than the ~100 million light-year limit of Cepheids.
“Like cepheids these are thought to be standard candles, objects with standard luminosities. But unlike cepheids, we've never seen one up close and personal to really know what that standard luminosity actually is...”
Nature operates according to objective principles that don't depend on our predispositions or hopes; we can only observe what nature actually shows us, not what we want to see.
“To quote freedman, nature is there and she's gonna come out in the way she is. Our predispositions don't count.”
Cepheids are young, massive stars that are typically born in dense stellar nurseries within galactic disks, meaning they are surrounded by dust and gas in busy, overcrowded regions, which complicates distance measurements.
“Cepheids are massive stars, which means they are young stars because massive stars simply don't live very long. So why is this a problem? It's because stars are typically born in dense stellar nurseries that are nestled within their galactic disk. This is the New York City of the Galaxy, a busy, bustling, dense, overcrowded region filled with dust and dirt all over the place.”
The Planck mission determined the Hubble constant from CMB data to be 67.4 plus or minus 0.5 km/s/Mpc, with the cosmological model achieving almost perfect agreement to the observational data across the board.
“now more precisely pinned down to 67.4 plus or minus 0.5 using the Planck mission. I'll ignore the units here because it's really not that important for the current discussion and largely just distracts from the main points.”
In an alternate reality where the TRGB method had been invented and deployed before the Cepheid method, there would be no Hubble tension because CMB and TRGB measurements would show almost perfect agreement, and the Cepheid method would likely be dismissed as a troubled method due to dust contamination.
“An interesting way of thinking about the Hubble crisis is to imagine an alternate reality, an alternate reality where we invented and deployed the tip of the red giant branch method before the cepheid method ever came along. So in this alternate reality we'd have two measurements for the Hubble constant, one from the CMB and one from the local universe. And both of them would seem to be an almost perfect agreement with one another. There would be no tension. And instead we'd just be celebrating the remarkable fact that these two radically different methods gave remarkable agreement about the expansion rate of the universe. So if then cepheids came along later we would likely just dismiss it as a troubled method, especially given the fact that they are usually embedded within bustling galactic disks.”
The TRGB measurement is 1.3 sigma away from the CMB measurement, which is completely within acceptable statistical agreement, and 2.9 sigma away from the Cepheid measurement, which is slightly high but could potentially be explained by adding additional systematic error to the Cepheid measurements.
“It's 1.3 sigma away from the CMB method, which is completely fine. And 2.9 sigma away from the cepheid measurement. That's a little high, but we could perhaps just explain that by adding in a little bit more systematic error into the cepheid measurements.”
The speaker makes a commitment to provide 'sober analysis' rather than the sensationalized claims they could make to attract views, stating 'I can't give you the answers that you might want to hear. That's not how science works.'
“I can't give you the answers that you might want to hear. That's not how science works. To quote freedman, nature is there and she's gonna come out in the way she is. Our predispositions don't count. All I can ever promise you on this channel is a sober analysis...”
Wendy Freedman, a famed astronomer who first used the Hubble Space Telescope to measure the Hubble constant two decades ago using Cepheids, has been advancing the TRGB method for years and recently led a team using this independent standard candle to recalibrate the entire distance ladder.
“Famed astronomer Wendy Freedman has been advancing this method for years, which is not surprising given that it was she who first used the Hubble Space telescope to measure the Hubble constant two decades ago using cepheids. Suffice to say Freedman has been thinking about this problem very deeply for as long as anyone.”
Previous astrophysical crises, like BICEP2 and BICEP* claims about detecting primordial gravitational waves, attributed their mistakes to dust, suggesting that dust calibration issues are not a novel problem but a recurring challenge in astrophysics.
“it's not the first time astrophysicists have experienced that sensation either. Remember BICEP2 or Biogen STAR, dust and dust.”
Observing extragalactic giant stars is observationally superior to observing Cepheids because the stars are in clean, uncrowded regions of the galactic halo without dust contamination, whereas observing Cepheids is like trying to do astronomy in New York City surrounded by haze and city lights.
“If observing extra galactic cepheids is like trying to do astronomy in New York City, swamped by the haze and city lights, observing extra-galactic giant stars is like being out in the Atacama Desert, clear inky black skies peppered with crisp oasis of light.”
The phrase 'crisis in cosmology' is a sensationalized headline that proliferated across science news outlets, misleading the public because the true situation is more nuanced and complicated, and the answer may simply be dust contamination rather than broken physics.
“A crisis in cosmology makes for a great headline. So much so that's proliferated across many science news outlets over the last couple of years. It's probably why you clicked this video. And indeed this video would surely get a lot more views if I told you that physics is broken, or that the Big Bang model is wrong, or some other extreme conclusion. ...the truth is often more nuanced, complicated, and often less exciting than that tagline portrays. After all the answer here may simply be dust, but a headline like dust may be a source of systematic error in cepheid distance measurements just isn't as catchy as a crisis in cosmology.”
Wendy Freedman's immediate reaction when her TRGB measurement landed between the CMB and Cepheid values was shock and surprise rather than satisfaction, as she had hoped the measurement would definitively point to one or the other method being wrong.
“I guess we would hope we were hoping that you would, your number would land on one side or the other and we'd be like okay, so now we know where the problem is. When you realized your answer was right in the middle, were you frustrated by that? How did you feel? - Well, someone, the immediate reaction was sort of like shock. Really? Did it really land in the middle? It was sort of odd.”
Cosmology is the study of the nature of the universe itself, addressing fundamental questions about the universe's size, origin, and physical laws.
“Cosmology is the study of the nature of the universe itself. Arguably the most fundamental question astronomy can probe, how big is the universe? How did it begin? What is the universe law?”
Before prematurely concluding there is no Hubble tension crisis, it is still scientifically prudent to improve measurement precision further to ensure the disagreement is not real.
“So does this mean that there's no crisis in cosmology then? Well, before we totally give up on that idea, I think we still want to improve our precisions just a little bit more.”
Despite the Hubble tension not yet being resolved, future data from Gaia and JWST will provide answers, and the speaker commits to continuing to report on this question as new data arrives.
“we will resolve the Hubble tension. So until then, stay thoughtful and stay curious.”
The cosmic microwave background (CMB) is the earliest detectable light in the universe, emitted when the cosmos was less than 400,000 years old (approximately 13.8 billion years ago), and appears remarkably uniform at an average temperature of about 3 Kelvin.
“This is the earliest light we can detect in the universe emitted at a time when the cosmos was less than 400,000 years old. So that's 13.8 billion years ago. At first glance, the CMB appears remarkably uniform with a universe appearing to have an average temperature of about three kelvin in all directions.”
The TRGB method works not by observing individual red giant stars at their peak luminosity (an unlikely occurrence), but by observing large numbers of red giants and identifying the maximum brightness value that corresponds to the TRGB, which serves as the standard candle.
“It's a weird one though because it doesn't really work for any single objects since it's unlikely you'd happen to catch a star at exactly this moment in its life cycle. But if you look at the brightness values of a large number of giants, then you'd see a clear maximum possible value that corresponds to the tip of the red giants and that heat is our standard candle.”
Distance measurement to distant objects requires understanding parallax, the apparent shift in position of an object relative to a distant background when viewed from two different locations, with closer objects showing larger parallax shifts.
“If I want to measure the distance to a nearby object, the way our brains do it is with parallax. Hold your finger out of arm's length in front of some distant background like say a city skyline. And if you close one eye and then the other, your finger will seem to move from side to side relative to that background. That's because your eyes are in physically different locations and so the angle subtended from each eye to your finger is different. The closer your finger is held to your eyes, the bigger the shift.”
The cepheid distance measurement method stops working effectively for galaxies beyond about 100 million light years because cepheids become too faint to detect, whereas the observable universe is about 90 billion light years across, creating a need for more distant measurement techniques.
“Because having calibrated this law, we can now go out beyond the Milky Way... eventually it stops working for galaxies beyond about a hundred million light years. After that, the selfies are just two faint for us to detect in the first place. Now that might sound like a huge number, but remember the universe is about 90 billion light years across. So we'd really like to go much further.”