Higher goods
In the Aristotelian/Thomistic framework, the non-material goods (virtue, justice, relationships, contemplation) that constitute genuine human flourishing and are not constrained by income, as opposed to 'lower' material goods.
As defined in Mary Hirschfeld on Economics, Culture, and Aquinas and the Market
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Higher goods” →
- When you take a lesser good and elevate it too high by pursuing it as an ultimate good, you actually lose all the value that was there in the first place—self-esteem is a perfect example: feeling good about yourself is fine, but pursued without content as an ultimate end it leaves you not feeling good about yourself at all.Mary Hirschfeld on Economics, Culture, and Aquinas and the Market
- Treating happiness as maximizing utility subject to an income constraint is an actively bad idea normatively, because the goods that make up a meaningful human life (justice, close relationships, virtue) are higher goods not constrained by income or time, so the framework inevitably substitutes toward lower material goods that appear scarce and distorts our entire idea of what happiness is about.Mary Hirschfeld on Economics, Culture, and Aquinas and the Market
- Economic growth is clearly good for impoverished countries emerging from poverty, but it should not be a goal of public policy for already-developed economies like the US, Europe, and Japan, because pursuing growth as an end feeds the disorder that more is better and keeps people chasing the next thing; in a healthy society ordered toward higher goods, growth would still appear as a welcome byproduct, since flourishing organisms tend to grow.Mary Hirschfeld on Economics, Culture, and Aquinas and the Market
- If you pause and ask what you want your life to look like and which goods you want in it, you will see that the amount of material goods needed to live a good life is finite; once you know roughly how much you need and order material desires to higher goods, scarcity effectively disappears and you stop treating lower material goods as the point of life.Mary Hirschfeld on Economics, Culture, and Aquinas and the Market
- Working on the Aquinas-based way of seeing the world for fifteen years amounted to a genuine conversion that changed Hirschfeld's consumer behavior and orientation—she no longer needs a raise, is genuinely content with what she has, and finds she can appreciate what is already in her house—but the change required actually practicing it, not just reading about it.Mary Hirschfeld on Economics, Culture, and Aquinas and the Market