normative
Utility-Maximization Is Bad Normative Advice
Treating happiness as maximizing utility subject to an income constraint is an actively bad idea normatively, because the goods that make up a meaningful human life (justice, close relationships, virtue) are higher goods not constrained by income or time, so the framework inevitably substitutes toward lower material goods that appear scarce and distorts our entire idea of what happiness is about.
normativepending
Speaker
Mary HirschfeldEvidence Quote
“when we think in terms of pursuing happiness as maximizing subject to constraint, what we inevitably end up doing is substituting into the, or thinking of the utility function as being primarily premised on these lower goods that do seem to be scarce or subject to constraint. So, material goods. And that seems to shape our whole idea of what happiness is about.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:22 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...