Group polarization
The robustly replicated finding that groups of like-minded people who deliberate together become more extreme, more confident, and more unified, shifting further in their pre-deliberation direction.
As defined in 327 | Cass Sunstein on Liberalism
Other definitions
The tendency for members of a deliberating group to end up holding a more extreme version of their pre-deliberation views after discussing with like-minded others.
Sunstein on Infotopia, Information and Decision-Making
Where it comes up · 7
- Sunstein on Infotopia, Information and Decision-Making3 claims
- Cass Sunstein on #Republic2 claims
- Greg Lukianoff2 claims
- 327 | Cass Sunstein on Liberalism2 claims
- 285 - American Division1 claim
- 359 - Getting Used To It1 claim
- 158 - Understanding Humans In The Wild1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “Group polarization” →
- On average, groups of like-minded people who deliberate together become more extreme, more confident, and more unified, shifting further in the direction of their pre-deliberation tendencies—a robustly replicated finding (originating with the MIT student named Stoner) that, when supercharged by social media algorithms and voluntary self-sorting, creates 'information cocoons' that threaten the stability of liberal democracies.327 | Cass Sunstein on Liberalism
- Federal judicial voting demonstrates group polarization with real (non-experimental) data: Democratic appointees vote much more liberally on all-Democratic three-judge panels than when a Republican is present, and Republicans likewise vote far more conservatively on all-Republican panels, with each becoming more moderate when an opposing appointee is present.Sunstein on Infotopia, Information and Decision-Making
- In a study of juries (with Daniel Kahneman and David Schkade), groups of people ended up much more outraged after engaging with one another than the average individual member was beforehand, with this amplification appearing on every scale used to measure the magnitude of outrage.327 | Cass Sunstein on Liberalism
- The 'big sort'—Americans increasingly living among the like-minded—combines with the law of group polarization (from a Cass Sunstein paper) whereby people of like mind become more extreme when gathered, so that geographic sorting turns whole cities and states into ideological monocultures that radicalize, just as academic institutions do.285 - American Division
- The best-functioning companies, boards, and investment clubs deliberately cultivate dissent and disagreement and take institutional steps to counteract group polarization, demonstrating that deliberation can be structured to work better rather than being abandoned.Sunstein on Infotopia, Information and Decision-Making
- When people sort into communities of like-minded types, they become more unified, more confident, and more extreme; Sunstein's Colorado experiment showed that after just 20-25 minutes of internal discussion, left-of-center Boulder participants shifted further left and right-of-center Colorado Springs participants shifted further right, and afterward viewed each other as aliens rather than fellow citizens—a dynamic social media replicates constantly and destructively for democracy.359 - Getting Used To It
- After deliberation, people typically end up holding a more extreme version of what they thought before the discussion began (group polarization), and this is close to an iron law of social interactions, demonstrated in controlled experiments such as the Colorado study where Boulder liberals became more pro-affirmative-action and Colorado Springs conservatives more anti.Sunstein on Infotopia, Information and Decision-Making
- It is incoherent to be highly skeptical of the best scientists in the world while being gullible enough to believe unfounded claims; genuine skepticism requires a uniformly high bar for all facts, which is why phenomena like flat-earth belief are so distressing in a more literate, informed age that nonetheless enables group polarization.158 - Understanding Humans In The Wild
- When like-minded people deliberate together they predictably move to a more extreme point in line with their pre-deliberation tendency, because they hear mostly arguments supporting their existing view and few opposing ones, which builds confidence, unity, and extremism; this is a documented finding from social science rather than a product of being a bad person.Cass Sunstein on #Republic
- Data on federal three-judge panels show that a Democratic appointee sitting with two other Democratic appointees votes much more liberally than a Democratic appointee sitting with one Democratic and one Republican appointee, which is startling because the two Democrats already have the votes; the difference is driven not by character but by the informational inputs received in the judicial echo chamber.Cass Sunstein on #Republic