Grand strategy
A state's overarching, deliberate long-term plan for achieving its security and foreign policy aims; Commins is skeptical it works in practice.
As defined in David Commins
Other definitions
The overall strategic framework a nation uses to achieve its long-term objectives, integrating military, economic, diplomatic, and institutional instruments of national power
The Geopolitics and History of Continental and Maritime Power - S.C.M. PaineStrategic planning that integrates multiple instruments of national power (military, economic, diplomatic, informational) over long time horizons to achieve overarching national objectives; coined by Britain in response to Napoleonic Wars
NWC 2025 INS Lecture - Dr. Sarah Paine: Geopolitics, Cold War Lessons and the Way Forward
Where it comes up · 16
- Richard Hanania - Foreign Policy, Fertility, and Wokeness4 claims
- The West Still Doesn T See Russia S Real Plan. Ukraine Is Just The Beginning Andrew Monaghan3 claims
- The Geopolitics and History of Continental and Maritime Power - S.C.M. Paine3 claims
- Sarah Paine — Why Japan lost WWII (lecture & interview)2 claims
- Sarah C.M. Paine: What Is China's Grand Strategy?2 claims
- Venezuela after Trump’s strike: John Bolton vs John Mearsheimer2 claims
- Living Through Revolutionary Times1 claim
- Is the U.S. Destined For War with China?1 claim
and 8 more
Most important claims · 10 of 26Search all claims for “Grand strategy” →
- Because Bushido emphasizes winning the battle at hand and steeling the will, the Japanese conflated operational success (winning a given battle) with strategic success (achieving the war's larger aim), so they won most battles in China but lost the war because taking a hill never delivered the strategic objective of stabilizing China.Sarah Paine — Why Japan lost WWII (lecture & interview)
- Strategy, distilled from Western theorists, is an executive process of generating plans built on assumptions about the future and seeking to implement and resource them; on this basis Moscow demonstrably has a strategy because it holds assumptions about the future, builds plans, resources them, and tries to implement them.The West Still Doesn T See Russia S Real Plan. Ukraine Is Just The Beginning Andrew Monaghan
- British strategic culture, as an island reliant on trade and a navy rather than a large standing army, has long aimed to prevent any single power from dominating the continent by backing the other side, relying instead on diplomacy, allies, and trade — and the British coined the term 'grand strategy.'Sarah Paine — Why Japan lost WWII (lecture & interview)
- Bad relations between the US and Russia are not accidental or caused by misunderstanding, but derive from a fundamental clash of interests: US grand strategy seeks to prevent any country from dominating its region, while Russian grand strategy seeks to dominate Eurasia.What Everyone Needs to Know about Russia Under Putin - FPRI's 2018 Champagne Brunch for Partners
- Grand strategy is the integration of multiple instruments of national power to achieve national goals, extending beyond warfare into peacetime and the long-term security of a country.How Superpowers Self-destruct Russian Chinese American Grand Strategy Sarah C.m. Paine
- Foreign policy is always a matter of experimentation and seeing what works, and it is hard to find a case where grand strategy really worked out; success in foreign policy involves a lot of luck regardless of the country.David Commins
- Britain's grand strategy for defeating Napoleon (and later applied in WWII) involved six integrated elements: keep home economy growing to fund military and allies; shut down enemy trade and force enemies to rely on dwindling resources; find continental allies directly threatened by the enemy; secure peripheral theaters favoring maritime access; force the enemy to fight on divided attention; and only commit ground forces after the enemy is badly weakened and with allied support.NWC 2025 INS Lecture - Dr. Sarah Paine: Geopolitics, Cold War Lessons and the Way Forward
- Self-interest distorts foreign policy more than domestic policy because foreign policy lacks the tight feedback loops and accountability mechanisms that discipline domestic outcomes, allowing special interests (generals, weapons manufacturers, foreign governments) to shape decisions without correction.Richard Hanania - Foreign Policy, Fertility, and Wokeness
- Although Moscow regards 'grand strategy' as a Western concept it doesn't use, its own concept of mobilization (mobilizatsiya) is remarkably synonymous with the Western idea of grand strategy.The West Still Doesn T See Russia S Real Plan. Ukraine Is Just The Beginning Andrew Monaghan
- The notion that the United States pursues a coherent grand strategy is largely an illusion; observed foreign policy behavior is better explained as the aggregate output of competing self-interested actors than as the execution of a rational national plan.Richard Hanania - Foreign Policy, Fertility, and Wokeness