Dodd-Frank Act
The 2010 U.S. financial reform law passed after the 2008 crisis, imposing extensive regulation on banks.
As defined in John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
Where it comes up · 5
- John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate5 claims
- Lawrence H. White on Monetary Constitutions2 claims
- CBO Director: What Happens When Debt Hits 122% Of GDP | Phillip Swagel1 claim
- Jason Zweig on Finance and the Devil's Financial Dictionary1 claim
- Richard Epstein on Cruises, First-Class Travel, and Inequality1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “Dodd-Frank Act” →
- When a regulator has the discretionary power to shut down your business, regulated firms learn to stay silent — no banker dares speak against Dodd-Frank and no health insurer against the ACA — so the erosion of rule-of-law protections in regulation is not just an economic problem but a threat to political freedom, which is why such regimes self-perpetuate.John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
- The right regulatory debate is not 'more versus less' but rule of law: good regulation is a knowable rule you can read and obey (like the FAA's 18,000-foot ceiling), whereas modern regulation in banking, health, and most business is vague, complex, applied after the fact, requires permission rather than rule-following, and lacks rights of appeal — making the regulator prosecutor, judge, jury, and executioner.John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
- Both Dodd-Frank and the ACA are classic 'old lady who swallowed a fly' regulatory spirals: the 1930s solution to financial panics was to guarantee bank debts so people wouldn't run, but guaranteeing debts creates moral hazard (encouraging reckless 'Las Vegas' betting), which requires regulation to constrain, which firms evade, leading to losses, bigger guarantees, and more regulation — an escalating spiral that produced today's monstrous, sclerotic system.John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
- After 2008 society missed the ritual public humiliation that followed the Crash of 1929, when the Pecora Commission forced senior bankers into public apology and some, like NYSE President Richard Whitney, served prison time; Dodd-Frank delivered thousands of pages of microscopic regulation but not the catharsis that would have benefited both the public and the industry.Jason Zweig on Finance and the Devil's Financial Dictionary
- The Dodd-Frank Act enacted in 2010 provided policymakers with new crisis tools, including a resolution authority for large financial institutions, which has not yet been tested but is available for future use.CBO Director: What Happens When Debt Hits 122% Of GDP | Phillip Swagel
- It is better to assume emergency actions will be taken and pre-define them—specifying that an emergency can only be declared under stated characteristics and that only certain exceptions may be made—but history gives reason for pessimism: the 1991 Financial Institutions Reform Act required structured early intervention and removal of management at undercapitalized banks, yet was completely ignored when the crisis came.Lawrence H. White on Monetary Constitutions
- Radical monetary reform is politically infeasible by current vote counts and will require either a crisis—which we hope to avoid—or sustained intellectual groundwork; notably the 2007 crisis did not produce regime change because the Fed dodged most of the blame, getting only a partial audit and a slap from Dodd-Frank while its discretion was not constrained at all.Lawrence H. White on Monetary Constitutions
- The shift toward higher bank capital is already happening: regulators who once claimed moving from 31-to-1 to 29-to-1 leverage would be a disaster now accept capital ratios of 20, as people understand the Modigliani-Miller theorem that higher capital is no drag — and reform can proceed by offering banks a regulatory safe harbor from Dodd-Frank in exchange for issuing more equity, plus ending the tax deductibility of debt, letting Dodd-Frank quietly float away.John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
- Heavily regulated industries are losing dynamism and converging on a European model of 3-4 entrenched, regulated firms with no entry or exit: only one new bank has been chartered since Dodd-Frank (to serve the Amish), no new health insurers have formed while existing ones disappear, and a revolving door sends regulators to lucrative jobs in the firms they regulated — alongside falling new-business formation and reduced geographic mobility.John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
- In 1900 government at all levels was only 3-4% of GDP and the arrow of growth pointed up; today extensive cartelization of markets plus direct government controls means the incremental burdens of new programs far exceed their benefits, so the arrow now points the wrong way, with Dodd-Frank and the Affordable Care Act turning out to be huge albatrosses on the economy.Richard Epstein on Cruises, First-Class Travel, and Inequality