Devil's Advocate
A technique or appointed role in which someone deliberately argues against a proposed position to surface its weaknesses; originated in the Catholic Church's sainthood vetting process.
As defined in Charlan Nemeth on In Defense of Troublemakers
Other definitions
A person assigned to argue a contrary position in a group to stimulate debate, regardless of their actual beliefs.
Ian Leslie on Conflicted
Where it comes up · 3
- Charlan Nemeth on In Defense of Troublemakers2 claims
- A Revolution in Thought? - Dr Iain McGilchrist1 claim
- Ian Leslie on Conflicted1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Devil's Advocate” →
- Charlan Nemeth's research shows that an appointed devil's advocate works less well than someone in the group who genuinely believes the rest are wrong, because we communicate arguments far more convincingly when we truly believe them and others can sense we have something at stake.Ian Leslie on Conflicted
- Role-played dissent like the Devil's Advocate technique does not stimulate genuine reconsideration because people know it is an intellectual game and pay only lip service; only authentic dissent—a clearly held opposing view persistently expressed at real social cost—produces the divergent thinking that improves decisions.Charlan Nemeth on In Defense of Troublemakers
- The Roman Catholic Church, which originated the Devil's Advocate as an internal role-player to dig up reasons against sainthood, reportedly invited Mother Teresa's genuine critic Christopher Hitchens to argue against her canonization—a notable shift toward consulting a true external dissenter rather than a role-played one, consistent with Nemeth's argument that authentic dissent beats contrived dissent.Charlan Nemeth on In Defense of Troublemakers
- The left hemisphere, unlike the right hemisphere which sees more than one angle and has been called the 'Devil's Advocate,' never doubts that it is right, is never wrong, and never at fault; someone else is always to blame.A Revolution in Thought? - Dr Iain McGilchrist