
A Revolution in Thought? - Dr Iain McGilchrist
What this covers
This is a single-speaker lecture from the Darwin College series, delivered by Ian McGilchrist, a psychiatrist and author of The Master and His Emissary. He starts from the neuroscience: the brain is divided and asymmetrical in nearly everything measurable, and the corpus callosum linking the hemispheres is proportionally shrinking and largely inhibitory. From the hemispheric attention difference he builds a diagnosis of the metacrisis, which he treats as the predictable result of a failure to understand what a human being is and how that being relates to the world.
The cultural argument ranges widely. McGilchrist reads bureaucracy as a "virtual machine" of left-hemisphere traits. He draws on Theodor Adorno and the administered world, and on Hannah Arendt and the banality of evil, to argue that procedure can obscure real people. He lists symptoms of dominance: loss of judgment and nuance, quantity displacing quality, rationalization displacing reasonableness, and rising paranoia and anger. The mechanistic fallacy runs through this. He says physics has abandoned the machine model of the universe, yet we still apply it to minds, societies and living things. He also takes up over-sanitizing and over-protecting children, and the decline of trust in schools, hospitals, police and business, where older practices based on honor have given way to short-term gain.
Several claims are explicitly contested. McGilchrist maintains that science, reason, intuition and imagination each depend chiefly on the right hemisphere. He describes three Western cycles (Greek, Roman, Renaissance) of flowering, stability and sclerotic decline. He forecasts that AI and bureaucracy together could allow near-total control of populations by any regime. He argues that technical fixes for forests, oceans and species would fail without a change of heart, and that the left-hemisphere mind finds the idea of the sacred an affront. He closes on what human flourishing needs: a trustworthy community, closeness to nature, and communion with something divine.
McGilchrist argues that the Western world's accelerating crises (the 'metacrisis') stem from a cognitive capture by the left hemisphere's way of attending to the world—which simplifies, abstracts, and seeks control—at the expense of the right hemisphere's capacity for contextual understanding, nuance, and apprehension of the living whole.
- The left hemisphere's narrow, manipulative attention has colonized institutions and created a machine-like worldview that treats complex living systems as decomposable mechanisms
- Right hemisphere capabilities—contextual understanding, emotional wisdom, aesthetic and moral perception—are systematically devalued in contemporary discourse and decision-making
- The metacrisis (environmental destruction, polarization, mental illness, bureaucratic control, AI expansion) is not a collection of isolated failures but the predictable outcome of left-hemisphere dominance
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The roots of the administered world lie in the past; Adorno quoted the mid-19th century Prussian writer Ferdinand Kerr: 'life no longer lives'—who does not recognize with a chill this diagnosis of the modern human predicament; Adorno points out that administration serves to rationalize the irrational, which explains why its workings and outcomes are often deeply unreasonable and deeply damaging.
“adoro points out that it is not even the Triumph of The Logical since Administration serves to rationalize the irrational which explains why its workings and outcomes are often deeply unreasonable and deeply damaging”
Trust costs nothing but the time to build it; once built, it is a fantastically efficient way for any human enterprise, particularly a society, to operate, but it is easy to lose—a Dutch proverb says trust arrives on foot but departs on horseback.
“trust costs nothing but the time to build it once built it is a fantastically efficient way for any any human Enterprise particularly a society to operate but it's easy to lose there's a Dutch proverb trust arrives on foot but departs on Horseback”
The three things on which human flourishing and well-being most depend are: belonging to a cohesive social group which one can trust and with which one can share one's life; closeness to the natural world; and communion with a divine realm however conceived—this is not just opinion but borne out by a vast and ever-increasing body of research.
“the three things on which human flourishing and well-being most depend are these belonging to a cohesive social group which one can trust and with which one can share one's life closeness to the natural world and communion with a Divine realm however conceived this is not just my opinion but borne out by a vast and ever increasing body of research”
It is hardly a surprise that material affluence does not make us happy if accompanied by spiritual poverty.
“it's hardly a surprise then when we see that material affluence does not make us happy if accompanied by spiritual poverty”
Trust is supremely important and almost completely ignored; truth and trust come from the same root and naturally go together—one cannot have trust in a society where no one speaks the truth, and one cannot be true to a society where there is no trust.
“this has the distinction of being at the same time supremely important and almost completely ignored truth and Trust Words which come from the same root naturally go together one cannot have trust in a society where no one is speaking the truth and one cannot be true to a society where there is no trust”
The metacrisis is the predictable outcome of a complete failure to understand what a human being is, what the world is, and what the one has to do with the other, and the right hemisphere is far better equipped to understand all this than the left.
“the metac crisis is the predictable outcome of a complete failure to understand what a human being is what the world is and what the one has to do with the other and all this is the sort of thing the right hemisphere is far better equipped to understand than the left”
Even if we were enabled by massive effort and massive stroke of fortune to prevent further loss of the world's forests, reverse ocean pollution, reverse species decline, and tackle other aspects of the metacrisis, this would be in vain if we did not change our hearts and minds, for we would still be the same hubristic, entitled, resentful, power-hungry animals that we have become—which has everything to do with left-hemisphere dominance.
“even if we were by a massive effort and a massive stroke of Fortune enabled to prevent any further loss of the world's Forest reverse the pollution of the oceans reverse the decline of species and similarly tackle the other aspects of the metac crisis I have mentioned this would be in vain if it simply meant that we did not change our hearts and Minds for we would still be the same hubristic entitled resentful power hungry animals that we have become and this like the rest has everything to do with the dominance of the left hemisphere's mode of being”
The problem is not that we took the wrong decision here or there, but that we have completely lost direction because of the values we have come to espouse; not only is being receptive to the summons offered by values the key to a fulfilling life and a flourishing society, but it is every bit as important as survival itself.
“for it's not that we took the wrong decision here or there but that we've completely lost Direction because of the value we've come to espouse as I get nearer to the end of life I'm more and more convinced that not only is being receptive to the summons offered by values the key to a fulfilling life the key to a flourishing society and a flourishing Natural World At Large but every bit is important as survival itself”
Physics now teaches us that the mechanical model of the universe is mistaken, yet because of our success in making machines we still imagine that the machine is the best model for understanding everything we encounter, including ourselves, our brains and minds, our society, and the living world.
“even physics now teaches us that the mechanical model of the universe is mistaken but because of our success in making machines we still imagine that the machine is the best model for understanding everything we come across we ourselves our brains and Minds our society and the living world”
Each hemisphere has evolved to pay a different kind of attention to the world: the left hemisphere pays narrow-beam, focused attention on detail that is already known, desired, and intended for manipulation (things to eat or use), while the right hemisphere pays broad, sustained, coherent, vigilant, and uncommitted attention to everything else that is happening, watching for mates, offspring, and predators.
“each hemisphere has evolved for classical darwinian reasons to pay a different kind of attention to the world”
The crucial part in each of the four important onward paths to truth—science, reason, intuition, and imagination—is played by the right hemisphere, not the left, despite both hemispheres contributing.
“in what I take to be the four important onward paths to truth science reason intuition and Imagination though both hemispheres contribute The crucial part in each case including in science and reason is played by the right hemisphere not the left”
Theodor Adorno saw developing after World War II what he called the 'administered world' in which everything was controlled, proceduralized, and devitalized; this could not be separated from Nazi evil at that point, but Adorno saw it was much more than that—narcissism was as much a symptom of a new mentality as its cause, a mentality of total control that had taken root in the form of a self-legitimizing bureaucracy.
“Theodor adoro saw developing around him what he called theal the administered World in which everything was controlled proceduralized and devitalized inevitably at that point in history this could not be separated from the evil that was narcisism but adoro can see that it was much more than that narcism was at least as much a symptom of a new mentality as its cause a mentality of total control that had taken root in the form of a self- legitimizing bureaucracy”
We over-sanitize and cause vulnerability to infection; we overuse antibiotics, leading to superbugs that no antibiotic can kill; we protect children in such a way that they cannot cope with, let alone relish, uncertainty or risk, and are rendered vulnerable.
“we over sanitize and cause vulnerability to infection we overuse antibiotics leading to Super bacteria that no antibiotic can kill we protect children in such a way that they cannot cope with let alone relish uncertainty or risk and are rendered vulnerable”
Bureaucracy is a virtual machine exemplifying left-hemisphere properties; Hannah Arendt referred to the 'banality of evil' in the Nazi regime, where mind-numbing evil was committed not by conventional monsters but by those simply following ordained procedures, with real people and real life obscured by pieces of paper and the recording of numbers.
“one aspect of this is the virtual machine known as bureaucracy famously har arand referred to the banality of evil one of the most disquieting aspects of the Nazi regime was its chilling bureaucracy mind-numbing evil was committed by people who were for the most part not conventional monsters but were simply following the ordained procedures real people and real life had been almost wholly obscured by pieces of paper and the recording of numbers”
Three times in Western history—in the Greek world around the 6th century BC, in the Roman world around the end of the Republic and beginning of the empire, and in the modern world with the Renaissance—there has been a pattern of: first a sudden efflorescence of everything that comes from the proper working together of the two hemispheres in harmony; then a stable period for a few hundred years at most; then a decline after which the civilization eventually crumbles under its own weight.
“in the second part of the master and his Emissary I Trac the main turning points in the history of ideas in the west and concluded that three times we have seen enacted a certain pattern first there is a sudden efflorescence of everything that comes from the proper working together of the two hemispheres in harmony that then follows a stable period for a few hundred years at most and soon a decline after which the civilization eventually crumbles under its own weight I Trac this pattern beginning in the Greek world around the 6th Century BC in the Roman world around the end of the Republic and the beginning of the empire and in the modern world with the Renaissance”
In each of the three historical cycles, the vitality and harmony of a flourishing culture is lost as it overreaches itself, becomes less creative, more sclerotic, unimaginative, over-administered, over-hierarchical, and power-hungry, with a cooning of values where goodness, beauty, and truth had once been the guiding values and the need to control and the value of power come to hold sway.
“in each case it's apparent that the vitality and Harmony of a flourishing culture is lost as in due course it overreaches itself becomes less creative more and more sclerotic unimaginative over administered over hierarchical and power hungry there is a cooning of values where goodness Beauty and Truth had once been The Guiding value the need to control the value of power hold sway”
AI and bureaucracy go hand in hand, enlarging the empire of the left hemisphere and making possible if not inevitable in the near future almost total control of the populace by any regime, however malignant.
“the other if possible still more dangerous expansion is that of AI bureaucracy and ai go hand in hand enlarging the Empire of the left hemisphere and making possible if not inevitable in the near future almost total control of the populace by any regime however malignant”
That anything should be sacred is a affront to the power-hungry, left-hemisphere-dominated mind; belief in a divine cosmos is seen as standing in the way of whatever society the machine propels us toward.
“indeed that anything should be sacred it isn't the front to the power hungry left hemisphere dominated mind belief in a Divine Cosmos is seen as standing in the way of whatever Society the machine hurtles us towards”
In older European business practices based on honor, trust was built through reputation and reliability; these have been grossly undermined by a smarter paradigm imported from America in pursuit of short-term gain by defectors—a very shortsighted move because trust has also been lost in schools, universities, hospitals, police, and the army, all of which now have massive recruitment problems.
“in the world of capital older Europe European business practices based on honor have been grossly undermined by a smarter Paradigm imported from America in the pursuit of short-term gain by defectors this was very shortsighted trust has also been lost in the world of schools and universities hospitals the police and the Army all of which now have massive recruitment problems”
A model that favors the machine over the human being, the inanimate over the living, is corrosive of all that is beautiful, good, and true and has no place in it for the sacred.
“a model that favors the machine over the human being the inanimate over the living is one that is corrosive of all that is beautiful good and true and has no place in it for the sacred”
Signs of left-hemisphere dominance and dysfunction in contemporary Western culture include: inability to see the broader picture in space and time; loss of wisdom and reduction of understanding to mere knowledge; replacement of knowledge with information and token representations; loss of concepts of skill and judgment; divorce of mind and matter; exploitation and exponential growth of bureaucracy; proceduralization of life; reduction of justice to mere equality; loss of uniqueness; supplanting of quality by quantity; abandonment of nuance for simplistic either/or positions; loss of reasonableness replaced by rationalization; disregard for common sense; design of systems for utility rather than humans; growth of paranoia and distrust; rise of anger and aggression.
“our inability to see the broader picture both in space and in time the way in which wisdom has been lost understanding reduced to Mere knowledge a knowledge replaced by information token representations the loss of the concepts of skill and judgment which are the products of experience the divorce of mind and matter resulting in a strong tendency to simultaneous abstraction and the debasement of matter to Mere lump and matter there our exploitation an exponential growth of bureaucracy and administration everywhere the proceduralization of Life the reduction of justce Justice to Mere equality a loss of the sense of the uniqueness of all things the supplanting of quality by quantity the abandonment of nuance in favor of simplistic either or positions the loss of reasonableness which is replaced by rationalization a complete disregard for common sense the design of systems not for humans but to maximize utility a growth of paranoia and per vasive mistrust for if all is not under its control the left hemisphere becomes anxious and protects its anxiety outwards onto others nonetheless we play the passive victim and abjure responsibility for our own lives in addition I might point to the rise of anger and aggression in the public sphere the destruction of social cohesion”
As a mechanical system, human beings must be dispensable and wholly interchangeable; true diversity is not tolerated, imaginative eccentrics lose their jobs, and humans must have no allegiances that might conflict with fitting into their assigned slot in the machine.
“as a mechanic as far as a mechanical system is concerned human beings must be dispensable and wholly interchangeable in fact despite the rhetoric true diversity is not to be tolerated imaginative eccentrics lose their jobs humans must have no allegiances which might conflict with their duty to fit into their slot”
The brain is massively divided down the middle and asymmetrical in almost everything that can be measured at many levels in both its structure and function, yet the corpus callosum connecting the hemispheres is getting proportionately smaller over evolution and is largely inhibitory in function.
“the bra an organ the power of which consists solely in making connections is massively divided down the middle why moreover it is asymmetrical in almost everything that can be measured at many levels in both its structure and function why not only that but the band of fibers that connects the hemisphere at their base the Corpus kosin is getting proportionately smaller not larger over Evolution and is in any case to a large extent inhibitory in function”
Denial of facts and delusional beliefs are far more common in association with damage to the right hemisphere and consequently dependence on the left hemisphere than the reverse; the left hemisphere confabulates and makes up stories to fit with its beliefs, and will insist that a paralyzed limb is unaffected or deny that the offending appendage belongs to the subject.
“denial of the facts and delusional beliefs are far commoner in association with damage to the right Hemisphere and consequently dependence on the left hemisphere than the reverse on its own the left hemisphere confabulates makes up stories so to fit with its beliefs it will frankly insist that a paralyzed limb is unaffected or if challenged deny that the offending appendage belongs to the subject at all belongs to you Doctor”
Machines are fundamentally unlike life and all complex systems: they are linear and sequential, put together part by part from the ground up, can be switched on and off at will, have default stasis not flow, are not resonantly embroiled with their environment, have precise boundaries, their parts do not change structure and function as the whole changes and evolves, and they are utilitarian constructs in service of the power of their maker.
“only the tiniest handful of things in the entire known universe are at all like a machine namely the machines we made in the last few hundred years machines unlike life and all complex systems whether animate or inanimate are linear and sequential are put together part by part from the ground up and can be switched on and off at will their default status is stasis not flow they are not resonantly embroiled with their environment they have precise boundaries their parts do not change structure and function as the whole changes and evolves not least because in the machine the whole does not evolve and they are utilitarian constructs in service of the power of their maker”
Robert Rosen, in his book 'Life Itself,' demonstrates just how unlike machines organisms are, and further argues that the best way to understand all naturally occurring systems—which are never merely complicated but complex and therefore never fully predictable—is as organisms, whether we choose to see them as alive or not.
“The brilliant mathematician and biophysicist Robert Rosen in his book life itself demonstrates just how unlike machines organisms are he further argues that the best way to understand all naturally occurring systems which are never merely complicated but complex and therefore never fully predictable is as organisms whether we choose to see them as alive or not”
The Dunning-Kruger effect tells us that the less people know, the more they think they know; this is worth bearing in mind when considering the left hemisphere's confidence and overconfidence.
“in Psychology there's something called the Dunning Krueger effect which tells us that the less people know the more they think they know it's hardly rocket science I admit but it is worth bearing in mind”
We pursue happiness and become measurably less happy over time; studies of rates of psychopathology in adolescence from 1938 to 2007 showed between 5 and 8 times more students met criteria for psychopathology in the latest cohort compared with the earliest, and this may be an underestimate because many recent subjects were already stabilized on antidepressants—a possibility that didn't exist for the earliest cohorts.
“as a society we pursue happiness and we become measurably less happy over time studies of rates of psychopath theology in adolescence relying on serial contemporaneous assessments using the same objective instrument and meeting stringent standards over the period from 1938 to 2007 showed that there were between five and eight times not five or 8% more but five between five and eight times as many students that met a common cut off for Psychopathology in the latest cohort compared with the earliest and this may be an underestimate because many recent subjects were already stabilized on an anti-depressant a possibility that didn't exist for the earliest cohorts”
Rates of suicide, which have always been about 3 times higher in men than women, are rising most steeply in young women—a paradoxical outcome despite increased freedom and reduced oppression.
“rates of suicide which have always been about three times higher in men are rising most steeply in young women”
In Zeno's paradox of Achilles and the Tortoise, although it purports to prove that Achilles can never catch up with or overtake the tortoise, we know perfectly well that in real life he can overtake it in a couple of strides—the paradox dissolves when we view it from a right-hemisphere perspective that attends to the whole situation rather than abstract analysis.
“in every case I explain why the apparent Paradox can be seen as stemming from the different dispositions towards the world offered by the right and left hemispheres this doesn't mean however that each take is equally valid in Zeno's well-known Paradox of Achilles and the Tortoise although he purports to prove that Achilles can never catch up with never mind overtake the tortoise we know perfectly well that in real life he can overtake the toris in a couple of strides”
The left hemisphere, unlike the right hemisphere which sees more than one angle and has been called the 'Devil's Advocate,' never doubts that it is right, is never wrong, and never at fault; someone else is always to blame.
“the left hemisphere never doubts that it is right it is never wrong and never at fault someone else is always to blame”
The left hemisphere is designed to aid us in grabbing stuff and controls the right hand with which most of us do the grabbing, making it seductive and addictive; it offers a simplified schema and simple answers, prizing consistency above all and offering the same mechanistic model to explain everything.
“the left hemisphere is more is designed to Aid Us in grabbing stuff it controls the right hand with which most of us do the grabbing as such it is seductive not to say addictive second the left hemisphere view sees a very simplified schema of the world and offers simple answers to our questions it's mod of thinking prizes consistency above all and offers the same mechanistic model to explain everything that exists”
We now live in a world where you cannot speak or act until you have put each word before a humorous tribunal ready to say no to everything you want to say or do, destroying spontaneity, joy, movement of the spirit, and even the impulse to visit a gallery or go on a date without elaborate bureaucratic mediation.
“we now live in a world in which you cannot speak or act and until you've put each word before a humorous in a tribunal which is ready to say no to everything you want to say or do I'm of course a boring old stick but I feel so sorry for young people now whatever happened to the spontaneous act the sense of J to the movement of the spirit out of sheer exaltation even an Impulse to visit a gallery soon runs into the need to have booked weeks ahead ahead using an app”
When integrity founded in an intuitive moral sense is lost, a society becomes like a building that has lost its integrity and needs to be shored up with ever more scaffolding—hence the proliferation of rules and laws, yet crime escalates.
“in Psychology there's something called the Dunning Krueger effect which tells us that the less people know the more they think they know it's hardly rocket science I admit but it is worth bearing in mind instead of seeing all things as processes running organically from the past to the Future across time and spreading out across the world through space like water finding its way across a landscape we see ourselves and the world as composed of static slices or points Here and Now compartmentalized in a way that conforms to the modus operandi of of the left hemisphere a world of meaningless bits we owe nothing to and can learn nothing from history or so we believe we owe nothing to and Lead need leave nothing to posterity we turn a blind eye to the inevitable impact of our rapacity on more humble and more stable ways of life that have stood the test of time better than ours we neglect the importance of context we believe we are right and that one size fits all justifying the imposition of vast Global bureaucratic structures not to say Wars so as to impose our thinking on cultures far different from our own equally we arrogantly critique our ancestors for not sharing the idiosyncratic view of the world we've generated in the last 20 years and which we believe must now be forced on all whatever their reasonable misgivings and we treat people people not as unique living beings but as exemplars of a category one aspect of this is the virtual machine known as bureaucracy famously har arand referred to the banality of evil one of the most disquieting aspects of the Nazi regime was its chilling bureaucracy mind-numbing evil was committed by people who were for the most part not conventional monsters but were simply following the ordained procedures real people and real life had been almost wholly obscured by pieces of paper and the recording of numbers after the war Theodor adoro saw developing around him what he called theal the administered World in which everything was controlled proceduralized and devitalized inevitably at that point in history this could not be separated from the evil that was narcisism but adoro can see that it was much more than that narcism was at least as much a symptom of a new mentality as its cause a mentality of total control that had taken root in the form of a self- legitimizing bureaucracy the roots of which lay in the past he quoted the mid 19th century orrian writer Ferdinand ker life no longer lives who does not recognize with a chill this diagnosis of the modern human predicament and adoro points out that it is not even the Triumph of The Logical since Administration serves to rationalize the irrational which explains why its workings and outcomes are often deeply unreasonable and deeply damaging the cancerous growth of more and more elaborate and more and more expensive bureaucracies in the world I particularly know hospitals and universities but the same could be said of government schools and the police is an inevitable and dangerous consequence of the world view we've adopted the other if possible still more dangerous expansion is that of AI bureaucracy and ai go hand in hand enlarging the Empire of the left hemisphere and making possible if not inevitable in the near future almost total control of the populace by any regime however malignant as we broaden our view it becomes apparent how much The Meta crisis can best be seen as a war on nature and a war on life this my friends is the reality we face why on Earth should such a suicidal War come about there are three reasons that spring to mind one is that the left hemisphere which makes that's what Benjamin Franklin called The Tool making animal thinks like a machine and has therefore exported machine like thinking into our environment everywhere nature and life are therefore ultimately an impediment the second is that the left hemisphere really only understands its own representations what it itself has made and given to itself nature and life are therefore ultimately incomprehensible and the third and most important is the resentfulness of a mind that believes it understands and can and what's more should control all its surveys here nature and life are a rebuff to its power a rebuff which cannot be tolerated the German American Artist George gross produced a shockingly vivid expression of this mindset as he contemplated Europe before the second world war entitled I shall extinguish everything around me that restricts me from being the master the Contemporary fantasy that we can be whatever we want and do whatever we want is a cruel travesty of the truth this was never true and never could be it is the product of a culture of narcissistic fragmentation ironically we've invented new impediments to its fulfillment we now live in a world in which you cannot speak or act and until you've put each word before a humorous in a tribunal which is ready to say no to everything you want to say or do I'm of course a boring old stick but I feel so sorry for young people now whatever happened to the spontaneous act the sense of J to the movement of the spirit out of sheer exaltation even an Impulse to visit a gallery soon runs into the need to have booked weeks ahead ahead using an app and that's just getting into a gallery what about negotiating the numberless hazards of a date life no longer lives wisdom skill judgment intuition and even understanding all to be gained only from a life well- lived have been sidelined in favour of machine-like algorithms that stifle true thought the assault on life continues as far as a mechanic as far as a mechanical system is concerned human beings must be dispensable and wholly interchangeable in fact despite the rhetoric true diversity is not to be tolerated imaginative eccentrics lose their jobs humans must have no allegiances which might conflict with their duty to fit into their slot thus it is that we've seen concerted attacks on the idea that there are any differences between men and women attempts to brainwash children attacks on family and K ship with their rightful claims on loyalty on the professions with their expertise which must be replaced by blind rule following and their codes of Ethics which a machine cannot understand and which is therefore replaced by the pretense that teachers doctors and Priests are just providing a service to Consumers rather than embodying what are ultimately sacred duties indeed that anything should be sacred it isn't the front to the power hungry left hemisphere dominated mind belief in a Divine Cosmos is seen as standing in the way of whatever Society the machine hurtles us towards Milton saw it all Lucifer the bright cannot bear the imputation of anything higher than he and the Very word Society reminds us that no properly functioning Society is mechanistic so we see social cohesion dissipate and Living Traditions erased in their place fragmentation the stoking of resentment and a rise of aggression this in turn is deemed to require what the toille pressingly described as a network of small complicated rules that he fora would come to strangle life itself once the Integrity founded in an intuitive moral sense is lost a society becomes like a building that has lost its integrity and needs to be shored up with ever more scaffolding now there has to be a law for everything yet crime escalates”
Physicist David Bohm noted a phenomenon he called 'sustained incoherence' characteristic of left-hemisphere thought: on seeing incoherence, it would be intelligent to stop, look for the cause, and change tack, but there is a reflex defensiveness that leads instead to obstinate continuation—the left hemisphere does not want to hear why it might have got things wrong.
“the physicist David bone reflected on a phenomenon he called sustained incoherence characteristic of what he called thought the thought process we now know to be typical of the left hemisphere what he meant was that on seeing incoherence it would be intelligent to stop look for the cause and change Tac but he noticed there was a reflex defensiveness in thought that leads instead to obstinate continuation in other words the left hemisphere above all else does not want to hear why it might have got things wrong”
We grossly misconceive the nature of studying the humanities as utilitarian, trying to extract value from money, thus rendering it pointless and certainly a waste of resource.
“we grossly misconceive the nature of studying the humanities as utilitarian in some way in order to get value from money and thus render it pointless and in this form certainly a waste of resource”
The idea that the left hemisphere is unemotional is wrong; the most highly lateralized emotion is anger, and it lateralizes to the left hemisphere.
“like almost everything that you to be said about hemisphere differences the idea that the left hemisphere is unemotional is wrong the most highly lateralized emotion is anger and guess what it lateralizes to the left hemisphere”
We are so eager that all scientific research results in positive findings that it has become progressively less adventurous and more predictable and therefore discovers less and less that is truly significant advancement in scientific thinking.
“we're so eager that all scientific research results in positive findings that it has become progressively less adventurous and more predictable and therefore discovers less and less um that is truly significant Advan in scientific thinking”
We privilege autonomy and end up bound by rules to which we never assented and more spied on than any people since the beginning of time.
“we privilege autonomy and end up Bound by rules to which we never ascented and more spied on than any people since the beginning of time”
McGilchrist's recommendations might be quite simple: begin by cultivating a sense of awe and wonder rather than clever knowingness about the extraordinary complex and beautiful cosmos which is a pure gift; think about what we're to do with the gift of life; have compassion for others and all the living world rather than aggressive embattlement against forces we probably misunderstand; and adopt a sense of the little that we can know—true knowing begins when we recognize how little we know.
“my recommendations might be quite simple Begin by cultivating a sense of awe and wonder rather than clever clever knowingness about the extraordinary complex and beautiful Cosmos which it a pure gift that we have been given a life in think about what we're to do with it and in order to do that well to to have compassion to others and to all the living world not a sense of aggressive embattlement against forces that we quite probably misunderstand and to begin to adopt a sense of the little that we can know in other words a kind of not willing ignorance but the beginnings of true knowing which is when we recognize how little that we know that is the first step towards true knowledge”
Confucius told his disciple Su Kong that for a stable society a ruler needs three things: weapons, food, and trust; if he cannot hold all three he should forgo weapons first and food next, for without trust we cannot stand.
“Confucius told his disciple Su Kong for a stable Society a ruler needs three things weapons food and Trust if he cannot hold all three he should forgo weapons first and food next for quote without trust we cannot stand”
We have been seduced into thinking we understand everything and can master and mold the world like a machine to provide a future that will benefit mankind, but this is a malign fantasy that becomes clearer with every passing day; those with grand schemes to improve humanity have caused misery on an almost unimaginable scale by their narcissism, cruelty, and willful blindness.
“we seem to have been seduced into thinking we understand everything and what's more can Master it and mold it like a machine so as to provide a future that will benefit mankind that this is a malign fantasy becomes pler with every passing day those with grand schemes to improve Humanity have caused misery on an almost unimaginable scale by their narcissism cruelty and willful blindness”
We owe nothing to and learn nothing from history, owe nothing to and leave nothing to posterity, turn a blind eye to the inevitable impact of our rapacity on more humble and stable ways of life, neglect the importance of context, impose vast global bureaucratic structures on cultures far different from our own, arrogantly critique our ancestors, and treat people not as unique living beings but as exemplars of a category.
“we owe nothing to and can learn nothing from history or so we believe we owe nothing to and Lead need leave nothing to posterity we turn a blind eye to the inevitable impact of our rapacity on more humble and more stable ways of life that have stood the test of time better than ours we neglect the importance of context we believe we are right and that one size fits all justifying the imposition of vast Global bureaucratic structures not to say Wars so as to impose our thinking on cultures far different from our own equally we arrogantly critique our ancestors for not sharing the idiosyncratic view of the world we've generated in the last 20 years and which we believe must now be forced on all whatever their reasonable misgivings and we treat people people not as unique living beings but as exemplars of a category”
Like civilizations before us which drifted further and further toward the outlook of the left hemisphere, we would appear to be engaged in committing suicide—intellectual, moral, and possibly literal—for the Western world may no longer have the will or skill to defend itself against authoritarian enemies that we cannot just wish away because in our theory they don't figure.
“like civilizations before us which drifted further and further to the Outlook of the left hemisphere we would appear to be engaged in committing suicide intellectual and moral if not indeed literal for I fear that the Western world may longer have the will or the skill to defend itself against authoritarian enemies that we cannot just wish away because in our Theory they don't figure”
The means to our ends are ever more available while we have less sense of what our end should be or whether there is purpose to anything at all—a fundamental inversion of means and ends.
“the means to our ends are ever more available while we have less sense of what our end should be or whether this purpose to anything at all”
For over 2,000 years in the Platonic and later Christian tradition of Western thought, human life was seen as oriented toward three great values: goodness, beauty, and truth, each seen as a manifestation of the sacred; during McGilchrist's lifetime, he has seen each of these values repudiated and reviled.
“for over 2,000 years in the platonic and later the Christian tradition of Western thought human life was seen as orientated towards three great values goodness Beauty and Truth each of them in turn seen as a manifestation of an aspect of the Sacred during my my lifetime I've seen each of these important values along with the sacred repudiated and reviled”
McGilchrist's worry is not that machines will become like people—which is an impossibility—but that people are already becoming more like machines.
“My worry is not that machines will become like people an impossibility but that people are already becoming more like machines”
Almost everything that really matters to us—beauty of nature, poetry, music, art, narrative, drama, myth, ritual, sex, love, and the sense of the sacred—must remain implicit if we are not to destroy its nature, and the attempt to make the implicit explicit radically alters its nature.
“almost everything that really matters to us the beauty of nature poetry music art narrative drama myth ritual sex love the sense of the Sacred must remain implicit if we're not to destroy their nature the attempt to make the implicit explicit radically Alters its nature”
Wisdom, skill, judgment, intuition, and even understanding—all to be gained only from a life well-lived—have been sidelined in favor of machine-like algorithms that stifle true thought.
“wisdom skill judgment intuition and even understanding all to be gained only from a life well- lived have been sidelined in favour of machine-like algorithms that stifle true thought”
We pursue leisure through technology and discover that the average working day is longer than ever and that we have less time than we had before; the technology places enormous burden on our time, alienates us from human intercourse, and exposes us to risk from organized criminals and mind control by disorganized criminals such as governments.
“we pursue leisure through technology and discover that the average working day is longer than ever and that we have less time than we had before we also find that the technology places an enormous burden on our time alienates us from Human intercourse and exposes us to risk from organized criminals and mind control by disorganized criminals such as governments”
The left hemisphere's response to value being power and control naturally puts values of utility and hedonism at the lowest rank in Scheler's pyramid first; there has been a decline in courage, magnanimity, nobility, loyalty, and humility—in all behavior that carried its costs up front rather than concealing its sting in the tail.
“the left hemisphere's res on De being power and control it naturally puts values of utility and heathenism that those of the lowest rank in shaya's pyramid first I may be wrong but it's my distinct impression that there has been a decline in Courage magnanimity nobility loyalty and humility in our society indeed in all behavior that carried its costs up front rather than concealing its sting in the tail”
Speaking the truth takes courage; those in public institutions would rather conform than confront untruth, and with the loss of courage to speak the truth, there has been an undeniable withdrawal from the beautiful and the sacred.
“speaking the truth takes courage and it would seem that those in our public institutions would rather conform than confr front untruth and along with the loss of courage to speak the truth there's been an undeniable withdrawal from the beautiful and the sacred”
We improve education by dictating curricula and focusing on exam results to the point where free thinking, arguably an overarching goal of true education, is discouraged; many students are so frightened that truth might not conform to their theoretical model that they demand protection from discussion, and their teachers collude in this dereliction of duty.
“we improve education by dictating curricular and focusing on exam results to the point where freeth thinking arguably an overarching goal of true education is discouraged in our universities many students are in any case so frightened that the truth might turn out not to conform to their theoretical model that they demand to be protected from disc russan that threaten to examine the model critically and their teachers who should know better in a serious dereliction of Duty collude”
The nature of attention we pay is of critical importance because it creates and molds the only world we can know; attention is a matter of disposing our consciousness towards the world in a particular way, and therefore attention is a moral act because it helps form both us and the world we come to know.
“the nature of the attention we pay is of critical importance it creates and molds the only word we can world we can know indeed it is a matter of a disposing of our Consciousness towards the world in a particular way”
The rightful master is the right hemisphere, but it has been subjugated by its emissary or servant, the left hemisphere, in an entirely predictable parallel to how we have become enslaved by the machine that should be our servant.
“the rightful Master the right hemisphere has been subjugated by his Emissary or servant the left in an entirely predictable parallel we have become enslaved by the machine that should be our servant”
Economists carefully model and monitor financial markets to avoid future crashes; they promptly crash anyway—another example of left-hemisphere overconfidence producing opposite intended results.
“economists carefully model and monitor the financial markets in order to avoid any future crash they promptly crash”
If we could change radically the hearts and minds of only 3% of people, we would be able to bring about the changes we need to see in the world around us.
“it's been said that if we could change radically the hearts and minds of only 3% of people we will be able to change and bring about the changes we need to see in world around us”
There are three reasons why such a suicidal war on life comes about: First, the left hemisphere makes us tool-making animals; it thinks like a machine and has therefore exported machine-like thinking into our environment everywhere; nature and life are therefore ultimately an impediment. Second, the left hemisphere really only understands its own representations, what it itself has made and given to itself; nature and life are therefore ultimately incomprehensible. Third and most important, the resentfulness of a mind that believes it understands and can and should control all it surveys; nature and life are a rebuff to its power that cannot be tolerated.
“why on Earth should such a suicidal War come about there are three reasons that spring to mind one is that the left hemisphere which makes that's what Benjamin Franklin called The Tool making animal thinks like a machine and has therefore exported machine like thinking into our environment everywhere nature and life are therefore ultimately an impediment the second is that the left hemisphere really only understands its own representations what it itself has made and given to itself nature and life are therefore ultimately incomprehensible and the third and most important is the resentfulness of a mind that believes it understands and can and what's more should control all its surveys here nature and life are a rebuff to its power a rebuff which cannot be tolerated”
Scheler called the human being 'homo amans'—the being capable of love; in the world of reductionist materialism, we have instead exalted the individual ego over all else and rendered many virtues, including beauty, goodness, and truth, obsolete.
“Shayla calls the human being ends amand the being that is capable of love in the world we live in reductionist materialism inverts shaya's perception and in a thoroughly cynical assessment of what it means to be human we have exalted the individual ego over all else and it has rendered many virtues including but not confined to Beauty goodness and Truth obsolete”
These recommendations will not themselves heal a matter of psyche or soul; there is no quick fix for such problems; as a psychiatrist McGilchrist learned that knowing what to do is not sufficient; a person must truly see for themselves what they need to do, and the work is to get them to that place of internal understanding.
“these will not themselves heal a matter of psyche or Soul there is no quick fix for such problems alas as a psychiatrist I would often know after listening to a patient for an hour or more on their first visit what it was they needed to do and when I was inexperienced I used to tell them that was a mistake until a person truly sees for him or herself from the inside what it is they need to do they will not do it and once they do see it they will not need to be told the work is to get them to that place”
People say 'what can I do, the world is so huge and I'm so small' and sometimes add 'our planet is so small in an incomprehensibly vast universe'; but this is thinking in left-hemisphere terms of measuring and quantifying; when the lover says 'my love is as deep as the ocean and as wide as the skies,' how large or small is that? All important changes happen from inside, not outside.
“people say what can I do the world is so huge and I'm so small and sometimes they add and our planet is so small in an incomprehensibly vast Universe there's a lot I could say about that but this is to think in the left hemispheres terms measuring and quantifying when the lover says my love is as deep as the ocean and as wide as the skies how large or small is that all the important changes happen from in here not out there”
Milton saw it all—Lucifer, the bright one, cannot bear the imputation of anything higher than he. Just as no properly functioning society is mechanistic, so social cohesion dissipates and living traditions are erased as they are replaced by fragmentation, stoking of resentment, and a rise of aggression.
“Milton saw it all Lucifer the bright cannot bear the imputation of anything higher than he and the Very word Society reminds us that no properly functioning Society is mechanistic so we see social cohesion dissipate and Living Traditions erased in their place fragmentation the stoking of resentment and a rise of aggression”
We can of course also ignore the transcendent values, devalue them, and cause them to wither away; the cost is immense both personally and to the whole living world.
“we can of course also ignore them devalue them and cause them to wither away at what cost to us personally and to the whole of the Living World we can only surmise”
The left hemisphere constructs a simplified world made of isolated, static, already-known things that are fragments devoid of context, disembodied, meaningless, abstract, generic, quantifiable, fungible, mechanical, and bloodless—it is a representation of a world (a map) rather than the world itself, and is literally two-dimensional, schematic, and theoretical.
“in the case of the left hemisphere the world is simplified in the service of manipulation it is made of isolated static things things moreover that are already known familiar predetermined and fixed they're fragments that are importantly devoid of context disembodied and meaningless abstract generic quantifiable fungible mechanical ultimately bloodless and lifeless this is indeed not so much a world as a representation of a world which means a world that's actually no longer present but reconstructed after the fact and it is literally two-dimensional schematic and theoretical not in fact a world at all more like a map”
The hemispheres have a built-in relationship where the right hemisphere grounds experience and knows the left hemisphere has a valuable role; the left hemisphere then works on what the right offers to clarify, unpack, and render implicit explicit; and the right hemisphere finally reintegrates what the left produces with its own understanding, allowing the explicit to recede and produce a new enriched home. However, this process is now often treated as ending at the analysis stage rather than reintegration, which is when problems arise.
“built into the relationship between the hemispheres is that they have a different take on everything including their own relationship essentially the right hemisphere tends to ground experience it knows that the left hemisphere has a valuable role though the left hemisphere then works on what it's offer to clarify unpack and generally render the implicit explicit and the right hemisphere finally re integrates what the left hemisphere's produce with its own understanding the explicit once more receding to produce a new now enriched home the left hemisphere's contribution then is valuable but must come at an intermediate stage problems arise when this is treated as it now often is as the end stage analysis is a valuable tool but breaking things down must be followed by an attempt to understand the whole once more unfortunately the left hemisphere is is unaware of what it is missing he doesn't know why the right hemisphere is important it cannot see the gestal the ultimately indivisible whole therefore it thinks it can go It Alone”
A culture that exemplifies the qualities of the left hemisphere's world attracts to itself in positions of influence and authority those whose natural outlook is similar, especially in the areas of science, technology, and administration, which have undue importance in shaping contemporary life; they then make us more like themselves, creating a feedback loop.
“a culture that exemplifies the qualities of the left hemisphere's World attracts to itself in positions of influence and Authority those whose natural Outlook is similar especially in the areas of science technology and administration which have an undue importance in shaping contemporary life they then make us more like themselves”
As we broaden our view it becomes apparent how much the metacrisis can best be seen as a war on nature and a war on life.
“as we broaden our view it becomes apparent how much The Meta crisis can best be seen as a war on nature and a war on life”
The right hemisphere constructs a world of flowing processes, not isolated things, where nothing is simply fixed, entirely certain, exhaustively known, or fully predictable, but always changing and interconnected with everything else; context is everything; what exists are wholes of which parts are artifacts of our way of attending; quality matters more than quantity; the world is essentially animate; and the future is a product of realism, not denial.
“in the case of the right Hemisphere by contrast is a world of flowing processes not isolated things one where nothing is simply fixed entirely certain exhaustively known or fully predictable but always changing and ultimately interconnected with everything else where context is everything where what exists are holes of which what we call the parts are an artifact of our way of attending where what really matters matters is implicit a world of uniqueness one where quality is more important than quantity a world that is essentially animate here the future is a product of realism not denial”
When we see how devastating the process of left-hemisphere dominance can be, we seem baffled at how we carry on promoting it; but seeing the picture in the round, we start to see why the outcome we wish for eluded us; we feel beset by paradoxes.
“when we see how devastating this process can be do we carry on promoting it the physicist David bone reflected on a phenomenon he called sustained incoherence characteristic of what he called thought the thought process we now know to be typical of the left hemisphere... we seem sometimes beused at how so often a path that looks promising leads us somewhere almost opposite to where we intend it but seeing the picture picture in the round we start to see why the outcome we wish for deluded eluded us we feel we are beset by paradoxes”
Goodness, beauty, and truth, far from being human inventions, are ontological primitives—aspects of the ground of being—and our capacity to respond to them and draw them ever further into being is our privilege and indeed our purpose; that is why there is life at all.
“these values I believe far from being human inventions are ontological Primitives for they are aspects of the ground of being our capacity to respond to them and draw them ever further into being is our privilege and indeed I argue our purpose that is why there is life at all”
There should always be an appeal from theory back to empirical evidence; the left hemisphere has a theoretical model while the right hemisphere looks out of the window to see if the model corresponds with experience; since the Industrial Revolution and particularly in the last 50 years, we have created a world around us which reflects the left hemisphere's properties and vision.
“there is or should be always an appeal from a theory back to the empirical evidence if you like the left hemisphere has a theoretical model the right hemisphere looks out of the window to see if the model corresponds with experience since the Industrial Revolution and particularly in the last 50 years we have created a world around us which in contrast to the Natural World reflects the left hemisphere's properties and its Vision”
No one will believe in us if we cannot believe in ourselves; we need to start believing in ourselves again and deserving to be believed in; once people lose pride in being as good as their word, doing the best job they can, and expecting much of themselves, rules have to be enforced from without and a penal code substitutes for the moral code it helped to destroy.
“no one will believe in us if we cannot believe in ourselves we need to start believing in ourselves again and deserving to be believed in once people lose pride in being as good as their word doing the best job they can and expecting much of themselves rules have to be enforced from without and a penal code substitutes for the moral code it helped to destroy”
Recommendations for healing include: reforming the educational system; revival of the humanities; serious reduction in bureaucracy; cultivation of meditative or spiritual practices; abstinence from social media; keeping machines in the background where they can be helpful but away from human intercourse; and tirelessly seeking to stop and reverse damage to nature.
“I could list the bullet points the left hemisphere would like me to which along the way would inevitably refer to reforming the educational system to a Revival of the humanities a serious reduction in bureaucracy to the cultivation of meditative or spiritual practices to abstinence from social media keeping machines in the background where they can be helpful but away from intercourse with humans and much more that we all know might help and of course it goes without saying that we must tirelessly seek to stop and where possible reverse damage to Nature”
The German-American artist George Grosz produced a shockingly vivid expression of this mindset, entitled 'I shall extinguish everything around me that restricts me from being the master,' expressing the resentfulness of the left-hemisphere mind that cannot tolerate limits.
“The German American Artist George gross produced a shockingly vivid expression of this mindset as he contemplated Europe before the second world war entitled I shall extinguish everything around me that restricts me from being the master”
In his book 'The Matter with Things,' McGilchrist examines about 30 of the best-known historical philosophical paradoxes and explains why each apparent paradox stems from the different dispositions toward the world offered by the right and left hemispheres; this does not mean each take is equally valid.
“in the matter with things I devote a chapter to logical Paradox and explore around 30 of the best known paradoxes that have intrigued and largely baffled Phil philosophers historically in every case I explain why the apparent Paradox can be seen as stemming from the different dispositions towards the world offered by the right and left hemispheres this doesn't mean however that each take is equally valid”
For many people, the two-dimensional representations provided by TV screens and computers have come largely to supplant direct face-to-face experience of three-dimensional life in all its complexity.
“for many the two-dimensional representations provided by TV screens and computers have come largely to supplant direct face-to-face experience of three-dimensional life in all its complexity”
Because the two hemispheric worlds have mutually incompatible properties, when we come to reflect self-consciously and rationalize about what we find, we are forced by the requirement for consistency to choose between the pictures of the world they offer.
“yet because these two worlds have mutually incompatible properties when we come to reflect self-consciously and to rationalize about what we find we're forced by the requirement for consistency to choose between the pictures of the world they offer”
Max Scheler, a valued early 20th-century philosopher, thought there was a hierarchy of values with those of pleasure and utility (the values of utilitarianism) at the lowest level, rising by stages to the level of life values (such as courage, magnanimity, nobility, loyalty, and humility), then to the values of mind or spirit (beauty, goodness, and truth), and finally to the holy or sacred, which he considered the highest value—a value which is incomprehensible to the left hemisphere.
“the early 20th century philosopher Max sha was much concerned with questions of value when he died in 1928 haiger who gave his funeral oration described him as the most potent force in the world of philosophy at the time Shayla thought there was a hierarchy of values which um with with those of pleasure and utility the values of utilitarianism in the left hemisphere at the lowest level and Rising by stages to that of the holy or sacred which he considered the highest a value which I suggest is incomprehensive ible to the left hemisphere in between were first the leens Vera or values of life such as courage magnanimity nobility loyalty and humility and then the gist the values of mind or Spirit such as Beauty goodness and Truth which I suggest are better understood by the right hemisphere”
Attacks have been made on the idea that there are differences between men and women; attempts have been made to brainwash children; there have been attacks on family and kinship with their rightful claims on loyalty; and on the professions with their expertise and codes of ethics, replacing them with blind rule-following and the pretense that professionals are just providing a service to consumers rather than embodying sacred duties.
“we've seen concerted attacks on the idea that there are any differences between men and women attempts to brainwash children attacks on family and K ship with their rightful claims on loyalty on the professions with their expertise which must be replaced by blind rule following and their codes of Ethics which a machine cannot understand and which is therefore replaced by the pretense that teachers doctors and Priests are just providing a service to Consumers rather than embodying what are ultimately sacred duties”