Counterinsurgency
Military and political operations aimed at defeating an insurgency and replacing or stabilizing governance in a contested area.
As defined in Is Israel Winning the War in Gaza? (with Andrew Fox)
Other definitions
Military strategy for defeating armed insurgent movements, usually by winning local population support, which requires decentralized, responsive action.
Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/2011
Where it comes up · 8
- Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/20116 claims
- 441 - The Threat Of Civil War2 claims
- 366 - Urban Warfare 2.02 claims
- Is America Overstretched? A Conversation With General David Petraeus1 claim
- Is Israel Winning the War in Gaza? (with Andrew Fox)1 claim
- 169 - Omens Of A Race War1 claim
- 26 - The Logic Of Violence1 claim
- Paul Collier on the Bottom Billion 01/28/20081 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “Counterinsurgency” →
- Governments in poor, small societies are poor at providing security because they lack resources and skill, and counterinsurgency is a difficult skilled task that took Britain and America a long time to learn; as a result, governments often repress rebellion incompetently, provoking outrages that fuel recruitment to rebels.Paul Collier on the Bottom Billion 01/28/2008
- Colonel H.R. McMaster's account of the Vietnam War, and his later counterinsurgency work in Tal Afar in 2005, showed that the military needed to give more responsibility and attention to frontline soldiers and captains, and his career risk reflected how hostile top leadership was to bottom-up adaptation.Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/2011
- Colonel H.R. McMaster pioneered a responsive, intensive counterinsurgency approach in Tal Afar in 2005 while Donald Rumsfeld and senior officers avoided even using the word insurgent, so official language blocked discussion of what was going wrong and why strategy needed to change.Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/2011
- Framing the Gaza war as win-or-lose is not useful; success should be measured by whether the strategic outcomes articulated at the start—dismantling Hamas, securing the border, returning hostages—are achieved, and ultimately by forcing Hamas to accept terms Israel sets rather than terms Hamas sets.Is Israel Winning the War in Gaza? (with Andrew Fox)
- Hamas's military strategy is neither to defeat the IDF nor to hold terrain (unlike ISIS, which sought to hold its caliphate's capital Mosul) but to bide time inside its tunnels until the world halts the IDF, in pursuit of the political objective of Israel's non-existence—which is why allowing Hamas to survive the war would constitute a massive victory and produce a more violent Middle East.366 - Urban Warfare 2.0
- The paramilitary policing that shocked the public at Ruby Ridge and Waco was not new—counterinsurgency methods had already been developed experimentally on communities of color and in Vietnam before being used this way; what was new was that the violence was televised and focused upon because the people at the receiving end were white.169 - Omens Of A Race War
- The kind of civil war Marche describes is not state-versus-state or blue-coats-versus-gray-coats armies but the rise of expanded political violence, where the attempt to suppress the political violence itself becomes a cause of further political violence—the pattern seen in Algeria, Vietnam, Iraq, Syria, and other major civil wars.441 - The Threat Of Civil War
- Counterinsurgency is a no-win game because suppressing political violence to create political space requires clamping down on society, which crushes sentiment that explodes the moment pressure is released—the Iraq surge zoning Baghdad and the Taliban growing from 40,000 fighters to ruling the country illustrate that domination, however asymmetrical, cannot win.441 - The Threat Of Civil War
- Destroying Hamas does not mean destroying the idea of Hamas or killing every member, but destroying what Hamas was on October 6th—its military capabilities, rocket supply, smuggling tunnels, and manufacturing—and removing it from power, because you fight an insurgency for a people or government, so the ruling power must be removed first before a viable governing partner can be established.366 - Urban Warfare 2.0
- ISIS should be destroyed, ideally by Arab Sunni ground forces or mixed local forces using American air support and training, as occurred in retaking Ramadi; locals fight far better knowing their 'big brother' America will support them, which is the difference between troops fleeing and troops standing to fight.26 - The Logic Of Violence