Constitutional Convention
An assembly called to propose amendments to the Constitution; under Article V it can be requested by the states as an alternative to congressional proposal.
As defined in Terry Moe on the Constitution, the Presidency, and Relic
Other definitions
A special assembly convened to draft or amend a nation's constitution; the US has never held one, and it would require rewriting fundamental rules with no procedural guidance in the existing Constitution
July Liberal Values Lab: America's Political Transition with Peter Zeihan
Where it comes up · 4
- Glenn Reynolds on Politics, the Constitution, and Technology3 claims
- George Friedman — The Storm Before the Calm2 claims
- July Liberal Values Lab: America's Political Transition with Peter Zeihan1 claim
- Terry Moe on the Constitution, the Presidency, and Relic1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “Constitutional Convention” →
- The United States is a unique invented country created by committee at the Constitutional Convention, designed as a deliberately weak presidency constrained by two houses of Congress, a Supreme Court, and distributed federal judges to prevent concentrated government power and enable constant evolution through technological innovation.George Friedman — The Storm Before the Calm
- The Constitution's convention route—triggered when three-quarters of state legislatures demand it—lets states produce and ratify amendments while bypassing Congress, a design choice the framers made because Congress would never approve amendments reducing its own power, and indeed it never has.Glenn Reynolds on Politics, the Constitution, and Technology
- The founders of the United States did something historically extraordinary when they included in the Declaration of Independence the statement 'all men are created equal' but then at the Constitutional Convention, recognizing slavery was the economic foundation of southern states and needed their participation, wrote a clause categorizing enslaved people as 'three-fifths of a person' rather than fully human.George Friedman — The Storm Before the Calm
- To have an institutional third, fourth, or fifth party, you would need a constitutional amendment changing the electoral system; this is so fundamental that it would require a constitutional convention, something this country has never had, and there is no guidance in the Constitution as to how you run it or how many states get what votes; if we went to that stage, we'd be talking about everything being a free-for-all and a Bolivian-style cluster.July Liberal Values Lab: America's Political Transition with Peter Zeihan
- The path of ever-increasing government power and spending is fundamentally unsustainable, and by Stein's Law—'something that can't go on forever won't'—it will end; the only open question is what comes next, ranging from civil war or military coup, to hard economic collapse forcing the government to shrink, to a softer landing or a Constitutional Convention.Glenn Reynolds on Politics, the Constitution, and Technology
- What has historically prevented a constitutional convention is that whenever one looks likely, Congress gives ground and proposes an amendment satisfying the main complaint; the value of the convention threat, like the Sword of Damocles, lies in its hanging rather than in its falling.Glenn Reynolds on Politics, the Constitution, and Technology
- Making fast-track authority permanent and applicable to all legislation requires a constitutional amendment, because a merely statutory grant could be revoked by Congress at any time (as the line-item veto was struck down); since Congress is unlikely to pass such an amendment, the alternative route is a state-requested constitutional convention, though scholars are unclear whether such a convention could be constrained to one amendment.Terry Moe on the Constitution, the Presidency, and Relic