Conquest's Second Law
The aphorism that any organization not explicitly and constitutionally right-wing will eventually become left-wing over time.
As defined in Nadia Asparouhova — Tech elites, democracy, open source, & philanthropy
Where it comes up · 4
- Jimmy Wales1 claim
- William MacAskill1 claim
- Nadia Asparouhova — Tech elites, democracy, open source, & philanthropy1 claim
- Tyler Cowen - Talent, Collapse, & Pessimism of Sex1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Conquest's Second Law” →
- Conquest's Second Law is not universally true; left-wing and right-wing are not universal historical categories but fluid and often ill-defined across eras (medieval times, 17th century England, the French Revolution to 1830), so the law cannot even be evaluated in many contexts and only locally holds for the post-war United States due to educational polarization.Tyler Cowen - Talent, Collapse, & Pessimism of Sex
- Conquest's Second Law (institutions not explicitly right-wing drift left) holds in NGOs because institutions need simplified messages that make people feel good—like pacifying values of democracy, peace, and freedom that are hard to disagree with—whereas nuanced thinkers who reject mindless playbooks lack mainstream appeal and don't end up running institutions, producing a natural drift.Nadia Asparouhova — Tech elites, democracy, open source, & philanthropy
- Conquest's Second Law—that non-explicitly-right-wing organizations drift left over time—is not necessarily correct, because an organization like the Catholic Church has maintained a steady set of values for a very long period that does not map cleanly onto contemporary left-right categories, showing durable non-partisan value maintenance is possible.Jimmy Wales
- Although effective altruism selects only for caring about questions like cost-effective life-saving (not politically hot-button issues), its members systematically tend to be very socially liberal and economically moderate, and inertia would likely keep EA in that category absent a known mechanism (like the one driving other foundations left) to shift it further.William MacAskill