What this covers

Tyler Cowen ranges across how talent is identified, why it clusters where it does, and how accelerating technological progress paradoxically increases the risk of civilizational collapse. The conversation with Dwarkesh Patel moves from concrete questions about who spots talent well to sweeping claims about human survival. Throughout, Cowen treats talent spotting as fundamentally artisanal—intuition and context rather than formula—and traces this insight into economics, education, and athletics. The Asymmetry of Creation and Destruction anchors his longer-term argument: the same innovations that drive near-term progress also lower barriers to catastrophic damage, making existential risk accumulate over centuries until collapse becomes statistically likely, with no guarantee of recovery.

The discussion splits into distinct territories. On talent itself, Cowen argues that Talent Sinks vs Sources are fundamentally different phenomena—established centers like New York and London persist for centuries through path dependence, while the origins of talent remain poorly understood and cyclical. He contrasts this with research productivity decline, attributing it chiefly to exhausting low-hanging fruit rather than bureaucratic drag, and sketches how Context Is That Which Is Scarce in higher education—a vision of how the world works and one's place in it—explains returns that pure signaling cannot. On cognition, he observes that top-level athletics is unexpectedly cerebral, that Multiplicative Model of Talent explains why many geniuses fail to translate raw IQ into achievement, and that novelists are uniquely hard to predict. The conversation grows more contentious on longer horizons: he dismisses Conquest's Second Law as locally contingent rather than universal, questions whether Effective Altruism overclaims on existential risk despite right intuitions, and argues that if AGI poses genuine danger, responsible alignment work cannot forestall it because less scrupulous actors will arrive later.

Sharpest takeaway

Cowen argues that talent identification remains an irreducible art rather than a science, that geographic clustering and context dominate talent's expression, and that while we should be short-term optimists about progress, advancing technology makes civilizational collapse increasingly likely with no guarantee of recovery.

  • Talent spotting depends on intuition and context that cannot be reduced to genomics or checklists
  • Talent clusters geographically in sinks like New York and London far more persistently than its sources
  • The same logic that makes Cowen a short-run optimist (progress accelerates) makes him a long-run pessimist (it gets easier to destroy things)

The claims · ranked47 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.85

The existence of sex is biologically the most pessimistic thing there is, because anything that stands still gets destroyed by parasites, so organisms must constantly randomize and change what they are through sexual reproduction—which is a sign that nothing survives for very long.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 4/4durability 4/4· Tyler Cowen

“Anything that stands still gets destroyed by parasites or destroyed by something. So you've got to randomize and change what you are through sex... That's a sign nothing survives for that long. So the existence of sex is the most pessimistic thing there is”

0.79

A major war with nuclear weapons, while low-probability in any given year, accumulates over a long enough timescale so that humanity is unlikely to survive another 100,000 years; and there is no reason to assume recovery, because human history shows hundreds of thousands of years of negligible progress and only a few of the semi-independent regions circa 1500 made much progress, so collapse could mean permanent medieval-like living standards.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“the chance of there being a major war with nuclear weapons or whatever comes next. While very low in any given year, you just have the clock tick, and that chance adds up. We're not going to be here for another 100,000 years.”

0.78

Cowen's short-term optimism about progress and long-term pessimism about civilizational survival are the same view: the more progress advances, the easier it becomes to destroy things, so while the chance of an accident is small in any year, it is easier to destroy than to create, making catastrophe eventually likely.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Tyler Cowen

“It's the same view. The more "progress" advances, the easier it is to destroy things. The chance of an accident can be small, and I think it is small. But again, bad things happen. It's easier to destroy than create.”

0.73

The best talent scouts are generally not themselves super talented at the thing they evaluate, analogous to how the greatest NBA general managers like Jerry West or Pat Riley were not great players; their skill is an intangible intuition that can be partly taught like art or music appreciation, but it remains an art, not a paint-by-numbers science.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“in basketball, most of the greatest general managers were not great players. Someone like Jerry West, right? I'd say Pat Riley was not.”

0.73

Existential risk matters much more than almost anyone thinks, but EA people overvalue it because the good things we can actually do to limit it are not very different from a familiar list—lowering mortality, growing GDP, supporting science—rather than the super-specific hypotheses they generate; they are not epistemically modest enough about existential risk.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I don't think there are many good things we can do to limit existential risks that are very different from looking for mortality and growing GDP, supporting science, trotting down a pretty familiar list of things that don't all have to be that long-term.”

0.73

Conquest's Second Law is not universally true; left-wing and right-wing are not universal historical categories but fluid and often ill-defined across eras (medieval times, 17th century England, the French Revolution to 1830), so the law cannot even be evaluated in many contexts and only locally holds for the post-war United States due to educational polarization.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I think by choosing the words "left-wing" you're begging the question. There's a lot of historical areas where what is left-wing is not even well defined, so in that sense, Conquests Law can't even hold there.”

0.73

Talent is geographically extremely well clustered, not by birthplace or ethnicity but by where it ends up; established talent sinks like New York and London persist for centuries for obvious reasons (money, big city, common trade or linguistic connection, path dependence), whereas the sources that produce talent are far more cyclical and poorly understood by theory.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“the thing that disappoints me a bit is how geographically clustered talent is. I don't mean where it was born, and I don't mean ethnically. I just mean where it ends up.”

0.73

The most reliable generalization about cultural diversity is that it tends to come out of larger units: small groups, tribes, and linguistic groups get absorbed and there are fewer unique isolated cultures, but this is replaced by much more thickly diverse urban creativity, so different cities become more like each other while the genres they produce can still diverge.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I think the most reliable generalization is that it tends to come out of larger units. Small groups and tribes and linguistic groups get absorbed... there are fewer unique isolated cultures, and much more thickly diverse urban creativity.”

0.73

Top-level athletic performance is super cognitively intense and most top athletes are extraordinarily smart, not just on the court but broadly, because you have to be really smart to figure out how to lead a team, improve yourself, practice effectively, and outsmart opponents; this is heavily G-loaded and is underrated.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I'm a big fan of the view that top-level athletic performance is super cognitively intense and that most top athletes are really extraordinarily smart. I don't just mean smart on the court (though, obviously that), but smart more broadly. This is underrated.”

0.73

Intelligence has convex (increasing) returns but only for a relatively small number of jobs like inventors; this convexity is embedded within a multiplicative model where IQ only cashes out for people who are also good at everything else, which is why many geniuses who can't get out of bed in the morning should be written off.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I think the convexity of returns to intelligence is embedded in a multiplicative model, where the IQ returns only cash out for people good at all these other things. For a lot of geniuses, they just can't get out of bed in the morning, and you're stuck, and you should write them off.”

0.69

Effective Altruism is having a cultural moment partly because political polarization makes the main parties offensive and energies must go somewhere (as they once went to libertarianism, which no longer addresses problems like climate change or pandemics); EA is somewhat like a religion, which is a plus because religions are the only movements that have persistently attracted young people over very long timescales.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Tyler Cowen

“Some of it is political polarization, the main parties are so stupid and offensive, those energies will go somewhere. Some of that in 1970 maybe went to libertarianism. Libertarianism has been out there for too long. It doesn't seem to address a lot of current problems, like climate change or pandemics very well.”

0.68

Declining research productivity is driven primarily by exhausting the literal low-hanging technological fruit rather than by scientific bureaucratization; the bureaucratization is real and worth reforming but is not the number-one reason, and breakthroughs can replenish the fruit only via new general-purpose technologies, which take a long time.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I think exhausting the literal low hanging fruits at the technological level is the main reason. With those, you can replenish them with new breakthrough general purpose technologies. But that takes a long time.”

0.68

In contemporary America, 'average is over' not because of sophisticated talent spotting but because in many service sectors output can be measured reasonably directly (did the computer program work?), which has made it harder for people to get paid things they don't deserve, and pushes lazy workers toward sectors where output can't be measured.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“Sometimes, it's simply the fact that in a lot of service sectors, you can measure output reasonably directly––like did you finish the computer program? Did it work? That has made it harder for people to get paid things they don't deserve.”

0.68

Talent spotting will always remain an art rather than a science, as evidenced by venture capitalists who are super smart and high-stakes yet have unimpressive overall rates of picking winners; claims that genomics or polygenic risk scores will change this are not credible in the near term because of how complexly genomic data interact.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“If you look at the success rates of VCs, it depends on what you count as the pool they're drawing from, but their overall rate of picking winners is not that impressive. And they're super high stakes. They're super smart. So I think it will mostly remain an art and not a science.”

0.68

As a coach or mentor, it is more productive, lower-conflict, and less stressful to work with people's strengths and boost them sincerely than to impose a list of how to reform their weaknesses; people are largely born with their temperament and can only be budged marginally, so focus on improving how they handle the flow coming their way.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I prefer to work with people's strengths and boost their strengths, rather than have a list set out of how to reform them. I think it's a way more productive way to do things. It's lower conflict, and as a coach or mentor or co-worker, it's way less stressful for you.”

0.68

Tenure fails to make academics less risk averse because the selection filters are very strong and pro-conformity: conformists are selected from the beginning, they care intensely about their peers' opinions, and they are literally not trained in how to take risks, so even freed by tenure they cannot easily take risks.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I think the selection filters are very strong. They're very pro-conformity. People care a lot about their peers and think of them. You're selecting conformists to begin with, and so you're just literally not trained in how to take risks.”

0.66

The main thing people learn in higher education is not retained facts (which they forget within years) but context: a vision of how the world works, how they fit into it, higher aspirations, how to deal with different personality types, dating markets, and social navigation; this 'context, which is that which is scarce' is the residual that explains educational returns and is what Bryan Caplan's signaling account overlooks.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“the talent book shows you my old saying: context is that which is scarce. And you're always testing people for their understanding of context. Most people need a fair amount of higher education to acquire that context, even if they don't remember the detailed content of their classes.”

0.64

Stamina is one of the easier things to increase; while you can't become superhuman if not born that way, almost everyone in regular circumstances could increase their stamina by 30% to 50%, and since the brain is just another organ that can be trained like physical stamina, it would be implausible for the trainability rule to hold for muscles but not the brain.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I think almost everyone could increase by 30% to 50%, some notable amount.”

0.62

If AGI is a genuine risk, it cannot be regulated effectively because the danger comes from the sloppiest people—analogous to handling pandemic materials—who are not the ones sitting in your alignment training class; even if careful companies like OpenAI lead now, more screwed-up successors will simply arrive ten years later, so alignment efforts at responsible firms won't matter.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Tyler Cowen

“if it's gonna happen, it's like handling pandemic materials. It's the sloppiest people you've got to worry about, and they are not sitting in on your class on AGI in alignment.”

0.61

Europe's problem for innovation is not wokeness (it is less woke than the US) but that it is culturally non-egalitarian with too few dimensions of status competition; places like Paris classify everyone rigidly by status with no room for the proverbial village idiot, which is a general problem across most of Europe.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“they have too few dimensions of status competition. That's a general problem in most of Europe–– too few dimensions of status competition, not enough room for the proverbial village idiot.”

0.57

The apparent trope that great people had abusive or emotionally neglectful childhoods may be a confound rather than causal, because biographied famous people are on average from earlier times when children were generally treated worse, so the correlation could exist without causation; counterexamples like Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, and the Collisons appear to have had good upbringings.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“Famous people, especially those who have biographies, on average are from earlier times, and in earlier times, children were treated worse. So it could be correlated without being causal.”

0.57

Podcasts primarily function as a very high-class form of entertainment that anaesthetizes people and lets them feel they're imbibing important ideas without doing the costly work of actual research; listening to someone is a substitute that lets you pretend you've done the inquiry, and Cowen does not assume his own podcast is a complement to genuine intellectual inquiry.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“You want to feel you're imbibing the most important ideas, and there are very costly, tough ways to do that... most people can't do that... So one of the next best things is to listen to someone to at least pretend that they've done it. And it's okay, it's a substitute.”

0.57

Novelists are uniquely hard to predict and blossom much later than other talents, often women whose earlier lives are interrupted by children; there is something discrete about a novel where until a person has actually done it, it's hard to tell how good they are, unlike nonfiction writers whose early blog posts reveal their intelligence and potential.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“They can blossom much later, and very often, they do. A very high percentage of them are women whose earlier lives are interrupted–– often by children... There's also something quite discreet about a novel–– until a person has done it, it's hard to tell how good they are.”

0.57

Public intellectuals like the IDW figures peak early and decline rapidly because they made extreme bets on very particular ideas that may be losing ideas; Cowen has sustained and increased his vocality over 20 years precisely by betting on a broad, non-radical pro-capitalist way of thinking rather than a single idea, which lets him stay relevant to new issues.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“they made extreme bets on very particular ideas, and maybe different people will disagree about those ideas. But I think a lot of them are losing ideas... I've done much less to bet on a single idea.”

0.57

When a candidate presents as very humble, it should trigger suspicion, because most people who make something of themselves are arrogant; even feigned arrogance is itself a form of arrogance and thus reveals the genuine trait, so arrogance is hard to overrate as a positive signal in young talent.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“Immediately I'm suspicious. I figure most people who are going to make something of themselves are arrogant. If they're willing to show it, there's a certain bravery or openness in that.”

0.57

In a globalized world you should be more bullish on immigrants from places that are hard to leave, like Africa, because successfully getting out is itself a costly signal of high effort and ability, whereas coming from an easy-exit country like Canada conveys less, all else equal.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I think it means you should be more bullish on immigrants from Africa. It's relatively hard to get out of Africa to the United States in most cases. That's a sign the person put in a lot of effort and ability.”

0.57

On average the most influential public intellectuals are not the most interesting, because being influential requires monomaniacally pursuing a single narrow policy idea over an entire career; John Stuart Mill was very interesting and wrote about many things but had diffuse influence, while Richard Cobden and John Bright were not interesting as thinkers but actually made free trade against the Corn Laws happen.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“John Stuart Mill was super interesting, and he wrote about many, many things and he had some influence. But was there a single thing where he saw it through and made it happen? I don't know. Or Richard Cobden, not too interesting as a deep economic thinker, but free trade against the Corn Laws–– he and John Bright made that happen.”

0.57

A useful forcing question to cut through tribalism is simply asking someone whether they are long or short the market; people who spew tribalist bullshit become incoherent morons when asked this directly, because their stated pessimism is contradicted by the fact that almost no one is actually short the market.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I just asked a simple question: are you long the market or short the market? I'm long the market... People spew so much bullshit, and it's all tribalism, so when you ask them "Are you short the market?", they say something like "Oh, well, I haven't bought anything lately." It's like they become morons when you ask them this question.”

0.56

US state capacity is not flatly in decline but presents a complex picture; the war on terror went better than feared after 9/11, Operation Warp Speed went amazingly well, and the local DMV works better than it used to, and the perception of decline may be like noticing you're in the longest supermarket line—you notice the failures more.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Tyler Cowen

“it's a bit like being in the longest line at the supermarket, you notice it more. The US State has done a bunch of things well... Operation warp speed went amazingly well. Just the local DMV works way better than it used to.”

0.54

Counter-signaling—where weird or unimpressive surface features imply hidden excellence (like a fancy restaurant keeping an odd-sounding dish or a persistently-rostered poor free-throw shooter like Shaquille O'Neal being great at something else)—only applies to established talent that has cleared selection hurdles; for unestablished people there is no comparable selection pressure, so no analogous inference can be drawn.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“this is true for talent only for talents who are established. If you see a persistent NBA player who's a very poor free throw shooter like Shaquille O'Neal was, you can more or less assume they're really good at something else. But for people who are not established, there's not the same selection pressure so there's not an analogous inference you can draw.”

0.54

A unique, intricate worldview matters broadly to high achievers' success not necessarily because the theory itself is the edge, but because it protects you from other people's idiocy and channels your mimetic desires away from distractions that might be good overall but would pull you off course.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“And it protects you from other people's idiocy. Your mimetic desires get channelled away from a lot of other things that might even be good overall, but they would distract you.”

0.52

Career advice for increasing economic growth or progress should not take the form of a static list like 80,000 Hours; instead you should sit with a person, understand their entire context, and find whether you can bend the curve upward, because learning about cultures and history reveals how complex the inputs to significant contributions are, which a list misses.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“You want to sit down with the person, understand the entire context, see what they could do, see if there's a way you could or should bend up the curve. But a list now… that's a little to EA static maximization for me.”

0.52

Asking an applicant point-blank 'Why do you want this grant from me?' is a forcing question that screens candidates: if their answer isn't credible they won't be funded even if they have good talent and ideas, because the inability to answer reveals something disqualifying.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I asked people flat out, "Why do you want this grant from me?" And it is a forcing question in the sense that if their answer isn't good, I won't give it to them. Even though they might have a good level of talent, good ideas, whatever, they have to be able to answer that question in a credible way.”

0.52

Reading history is not substitutable for travel; traveling appropriately in contemporary times should make you more skeptical of history, because you realize how little you can learn about even current places just by reading about them, so when comparing travel versus history, history loses.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“If you've travelled appropriately in contemporary times, it should make you more skeptical about history because you'll realize how little you can learn about the current places just by reading about them. So it's like Travel versus History, and the historians lose.”

0.52

Most foundations give out too many large grants and not enough small grants; small grants are underrated, and for many projects the money per se doesn't matter at all, while only a subset with real capital costs genuinely need the funding.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I think a lot of foundations give out too many large grants and not enough small grants. I hope I'm at an optimum. But again, I don't have data to tell you. I do think about this a lot, and I think small grants are underrated.”

0.52

Unlike novelists, startup founders show many early intermediate benchmarks—how well they raise a first round, the quality of the pitch deck—that let an evaluator see a lot early on, even though these aren't perfectly indicative of product-market fit; this is why founders are easier to spot than novelists despite both being unproven at a new endeavor.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“There are more intermediate benchmarks with startups. Just how good a job do they do trying to raise their first round? There's a lot you can watch... How good is the pitch deck?... I think you see way more early signs.”

0.52

Sam Altman's observation that successful founders believe they're certain to succeed reflects selection for overconfidence specific to startups, which succeed at very low rates; in other sectors like public intellectual work you won't find that same level of overconfidence because people more often stumble into success or know early via repeated tests rather than through Sam-like overconfidence.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“startups succeed at such a low rate that the success is really on selecting for people with quite a bit of overconfidence. In other sectors, you won't in general find that same level of overconfidence.”

0.50

For a 50-year-old with accomplishments, feigning humility is the expected high-status behavior, so failing to do it reveals a competence gap; whereas for a 15-year-old, raw arrogance from a chip on the shoulder is acceptable and even promising because they can't yet hold it in.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“you're much more likely to think the 50 year old should feign humility than the 15-year-old. Because that's the high-status thing to do–– it's to feign humility. If they can't do that, you figure, "Here's one thing they're bad at. What else are they bad at?"”

0.48

The quality distribution of Emergent Ventures applicants is remarkably bimodal, not a smooth curve, so there are few agonizing marginal cases; if Cowen finds himself agonizing over an application, that itself signals it should probably be a rejection, and marginal rejects are simply not good.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Tyler Cowen

“It's a remarkably bimodal distribution as I perceive it, and maybe I'm wrong. But there aren't that many cases where I'm agonizing and if I'm agonizing I figure it probably should be a no.”

0.39

There are definite positive correlations between conditions like depression or anxiety and artistic creativity, though whether the relationship is causal is harder to establish; the correlation alone means one should take such a candidate seriously.

causalestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“there's definitely positive correlations between that stuff and artistic creativity. Whether or not it's causal is harder to say, but it correlates.”

0.38

Women are often better at detecting deceit for biological and evolutionary reasons: because the cost of a pregnancy is much higher for a woman than a man, and because there are many men trying to deceive them, women developed defense mechanisms that men have less of; the explanation that women simply discuss personal matters more is real but subordinate to this.

causalcontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“I would assume for biological and evolutionary reasons that there are all these men trying to deceive them, right? The cost of a pregnancy is higher for a woman than for a man on average, by quite a bit. So women will develop defense mechanisms that men maybe don't have as much.”

0.38

Writing is important to evaluate because it is a form of thinking and correlates strongly with general competence, especially in the areas Cowen funds; the best companies (Amazon, Stripe) have writing cultures, so applicants are asked to write.

factualcontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“writing is a form of thinking. And public intellectuals are one of the things I want to support. Some of the companies I admire are ones with writing cultures like Amazon or Stripe.”

0.34

The blog format will survive the test of time because the basic notion that you write and someone reads is extremely robust, as shown by early diarists like Samuel Pepys and James Boswell surviving from the 17th and 18th centuries; today's technology only makes it easier and more readily preserved, though Substack differs by encouraging longer, whinier, more self-reflective posts.

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“we have early bloggers, Samuel Pepys, James Boswell, they've survived, right? It's good material. That's the 17th and 18th centuries. So why can't it survive today when technology makes it easier and more readily preserved? Just the notion that you write and someone reads seems to be extremely robust.”

0.31

Discouraging the people you turn away from a talent program is acceptable, because those who are really going to do something should take rejection as a challenge and many do (the 'I'll show those bastards' response); if rejection crushes someone's spirit, they should probably be in a role working for someone else anyway.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Tyler Cowen

“if they're really going to do something, they should take that as a challenge. And many do! Like "Oh, I was rejected by Harvard, I had to go to UChicago, but I decided, I'm going to show those bastards."”

0.29

Top achievers in one field can somewhat move across fields and be high achievers in others, but you cannot be top at anything or even most things; many people very successful in other areas might just be near-millionaires running a car dealership rather than reaching the heights of their actual achievement.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tyler Cowen

“Maybe somewhat, but I don't think you can be top at anything–– or even most things. A lot of these are very successful people in other areas might just be near millionaires.”

0.28

Dressing professionally when unnecessary signals conformity that counts against a young candidate for unconventional roles, but there is a point where being so over-the-top conformist becomes totally non-conformist, making the candidate interesting again as a kind of nut.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Tyler Cowen

“there might be situations where it's so weird, so over the top, so conformist, that it's actually totally non-conformist. Like "I don't know anyone who's a conformist like you are!"”

0.28

A high school run to serve its smartest students would assign less homework, hire better-paid teachers and fire bad ones, and bring in many in-person role models like working economists for short talks, because vividness and live local exposure beat Zoom or recorded video for inspiring talented young people.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Tyler Cowen

“Less homework! I would work harder to hire better teachers, pay them more, and fire the bad ones if I'm allowed to do that... mainly less homework and I'd have more people come in who are potential role models.”