Christianity
Religious and philosophical framework that (the panel argues) displaced Greek virtue concepts by introducing theological virtues (faith, hope, charity) and supernatural rewards (heaven), ultimately emptying the ancient virtue vocabulary.
As defined in Roundtable Discussion on Homer's "The Odyssey" featuring Christopher Hitchens
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “Christianity” →
- The Odyssey demonstrates complex and interrelated virtues rather than simplistic virtue; when Aristotle writes the Nicomachean Ethics, he includes luck among the virtues—a conception so foreign to modern thinking that we cannot see luck and virtue as going together, proving that the virtue world has been fundamentally changed.Roundtable Discussion on Homer's "The Odyssey" featuring Christopher Hitchens
- It is not chauvinistic to assume that one needs to be Christian to be virtuous or to aspire to virtue; people in other cultures have notions of virtue and nobility, and one can draw from Christianity, literature, and history without them having to be reconcilable systems.Roundtable Discussion on Homer's "The Odyssey" featuring Christopher Hitchens
- Alastair MacIntyre's book After Virtue argues that virtue words in modern times are empty—we still have the markers but they're like checks on closed accounts; we can say 'we should all be courageous' but nobody knows what we're talking about, and the virtue world has been fundamentally changed and possibly emptied by Christianity.Roundtable Discussion on Homer's "The Odyssey" featuring Christopher Hitchens
- You cannot reconcile Christianity and Homer because they are fundamentally incommensurable systems; attempting to do so creates a mishmash, and the problem is that our ability to ask whether it is just that the 108 suitors die shows we have lived through a Christian era that has changed what justice means.Roundtable Discussion on Homer's "The Odyssey" featuring Christopher Hitchens
- Christianity's contribution to moral thinking is minimal; it added supernatural reinforcements (faith, hope, charity) and drew heavily from early Judaism, but did not fundamentally advance ethical reasoning beyond what Greek philosophy had already achieved, as evidenced by Christian thinkers' constant need to invoke Greek examples.Roundtable Discussion on Homer's "The Odyssey" featuring Christopher Hitchens
- Nichze (sic) was an accomplished classicist who devoted his life to Greek studies and philosophy; his concept of Christianity as 'a religion for slaves' and his elevation of the hero and superman are directly derived from his deep engagement with Homer.Roundtable Discussion on Homer's "The Odyssey" featuring Christopher Hitchens