You cannot reconcile Christianity and Homer because they are fundamentally incommensurable systems; attempting to do so creates a mishmash, and the problem is that our ability to ask whether it is just that the 108 suitors die shows we have lived through a Christian era that has changed what justice means.

factualpending

Speaker

Jay Botkin

Evidence Quote

“you can't take what you want from Christianity and from Homer because they're not reconcilable. that you're gonna make a mishmash if you do that.”

Source

Roundtable Discussion on Homer's "The Odyssey" featuring Christopher Hitchens— C-SPAN's Book TV
Created: 8/12/2026, 5:57:46 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...