China shock
The term from the Autor-Dorn-Hanson research describing the labor-market disruption in specific U.S. regions caused by rising imports from China between 1990 and 2007.
As defined in Why Industrial Policy Is (Almost) Always a Bad Idea (with Scott Sumner)
Where it comes up · 8
- How Martin Wolf Understands This Global Economic Moment3 claims
- Why Trump's tariff chaos actually makes sense (big picture)2 claims
- Gold Revaluation Unveiled: Why It's Needed, How It Works, and Market Impact2 claims
- Italy’s comeback, Germany’s decline, China's massive stimulus & more2 claims
- Doug Irwin1 claim
- Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly1 claim
- Why Industrial Policy Is (Almost) Always a Bad Idea (with Scott Sumner)1 claim
- The Economics of Tariffs and Trade (with Doug Irwin)1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “China shock” →
- Germany's industrial decline is explained by two main factors: first, German industry uniquely benefited from cheap Russian energy and is now suffering more from the loss of that advantage; second, Germany is being hit hard by a China shock where Chinese demand for German cars and machines is plummeting while Chinese competitors challenge German champions in markets like Southeast Asia and Latin America.Italy’s comeback, Germany’s decline, China's massive stimulus & more
- The 'China shock' from China joining the WTO around 2000 only slightly increased the pace of manufacturing job decline, which has been a nearly straight line down for 75 years driven mainly by technology and automation; while it may have had real local effects, at the national level its impact is greatly exaggerated, and the populist belief that the wealthiest nation has been 'exploited' by trading partners is incomprehensible given near-zero unemployment.The Economics of Tariffs and Trade (with Doug Irwin)
- The Autor et al. China shock was a one-off, unique episode of economic history—a huge increase in Chinese market-sector labor supply in the 1990s-2000s—that hit specific one-factory towns hard but had a small aggregate impact (roughly one million US jobs over a decade), and a future negative China shock may occur as the Chinese labor force shrinks.Doug Irwin
- The standard economic argument that cheaper imported food frees displaced farmers to work in expanding sectors only holds if the labor market reallocates workers effectively; in poor countries (and increasingly in the US, per the China-shock work) labor markets often don't adjust dynamically, so the benefits of such interventions are far less clear than many economists assume.Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly
- A strong dollar allowed the US to maintain a massive global military presence despite becoming a smaller economy relative to the rest of the world compared to the 1950s, but it also made US manufacturing expensive and caused stable manufacturing jobs to leave, especially after China joined the WTO in 2001.Why Trump's tariff chaos actually makes sense (big picture)
- The real policy problem in the US is not the China shock itself but the failure of the American government to develop place-based adjustment policies that allowed communities and workers in key industries to adjust to these shocks, representing a broader policy error beyond just trade policy.How Martin Wolf Understands This Global Economic Moment
- There are two distinct critiques of globalization in the US policy debate—the 'China shock' argument (that outsourcing to China caused manufacturing job losses) and the 'China entanglement' argument (that dependence on China as an increasingly hostile adversary creates vulnerability)—which are often conflated but lead to very different policy prescriptions.How Martin Wolf Understands This Global Economic Moment
- As a consequence of energy and China shocks, German exports are now far more reliant on the United States, which largely shut its market to Chinese competitors, making US economic performance and demand critical to Germany's industrial future.Italy’s comeback, Germany’s decline, China's massive stimulus & more
- The China shock (manufacturing job losses from outsourcing to China) is ancient history—it basically happened in roughly the first decade of this century, and since then the share of manufacturing employment in total US employment has been remarkably stable with no repeat of the extraordinary shift, making efforts to bring back those lost industries likely to be very costly and mostly unproductive.How Martin Wolf Understands This Global Economic Moment
- A strong dollar under neoliberalism meant the US could maintain a massive global military presence despite being a smaller economy relative to the rest of the world, but it also made US manufacturing more expensive and caused manufacturing jobs to leave the country, particularly after China joined the WTO in 2001.Why Trump's tariff chaos actually makes sense (big picture)