Certificate of Need
State regulatory requirements (described here as allowing incumbents to veto new entrants) that restrict the establishment of new hospitals or facilities, limiting competition.
As defined in Ed Dolan on Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance
Other definitions
A regulatory requirement that providers prove a need before building or expanding health facilities, which restricts the supply of hospitals.
Arnold Kling on Specialization and Trade
Where it comes up · 13
- John Cochrane2 claims
- Christy Ford Chapin on the Evolution of the American Health Care System2 claims
- Ed Dolan on Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance2 claims
- Keith Smith on Free Market Health Care2 claims
- Patrick Collison: Philosophies for Running Stripe, Hiring, Decision Making, and Reading1 claim
- Chemed: Empire of Care1 claim
- John Cochrane on Health Care1 claim
- Arnold Kling on Specialization and Trade1 claim
and 5 more
Most important claims · 10 of 17Search all claims for “Certificate of Need” →
- State regulations on who can enter hospice vary widely, with Los Angeles County having about 1,900 hospice operators while Florida has about 50, so VITAS favors stringent states to limit competition.Chemed: Empire of Care
- In many states a hospital that wants to open must obtain a Certificate of Need, literally requiring existing hospitals to confirm there is a need they cannot already provide—forcing an entrant to get permission from the very competitors who would be harmed.Michael Munger on Permissionless Innovation
- The ideal reform combines a universal/single-payer-style subsidy system (like Switzerland's voucher-style subsidies) that covers the neediest, with substantial rollback of cost-containment regulation (certificate of need, scope-of-practice and licensing limits on nurse practitioners and PAs, restrictions on physician organization) so physicians can organize themselves as in concierge medicine and co-ops, leaving insurers only for catastrophic coverage—correctly incentivizing both physicians and patients.Christy Ford Chapin on the Evolution of the American Health Care System
- Government intervention in healthcare, education and housing follows the same two-part pattern—restriction of supply (via regulatory capture, monopolies, cartels like K-12 government monopoly, the accreditation-controlled university cartel, hospital certificate-of-need laws, and professional associations) plus subsidization of demand (trillions in mortgage subsidies, student loans, and Medicare)—and by Micro/Econ 101 this predictably sends prices to the moon, yet policymakers act surprised every time.Marc Andreessen on Software, Immortality, and Bitcoin
- Health care and education exhibit the same subsidize-demand/restrict-supply pattern: demand is heavily subsidized (third-party payment, education subsidies) while supply is actively restricted through hospital Certificates of Need, state medical licensing that doesn't transfer across states, and accreditation controlled by industry incumbents so that hardly any new accredited college has appeared in decades—making doctors comfortable and hospitals profitable while raising prices.Arnold Kling on Specialization and Trade
- In many states, opening a new hospital requires a Certificate of Need granting permission from existing hospitals that the new facility is needed—and incumbents predictably decide it is not—thereby limiting competition.Keith Smith on Free Market Health Care
- Many states grant existing hospitals the ability to restrain or veto the entry of competing hospitals, making the hospital system uncompetitive and increasingly expensive, with much of the cost paid not by patients but by taxpayers or spread across employee premium pools.Ed Dolan on Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance
- Certificate of Need laws, present in many states, require state-board approval to build a new hospital or buy major equipment, and because the explicit charter purpose is to keep up the profits of existing hospitals, incumbents can block lower-cost specialty entrants like dialysis or colonoscopy clinics, exactly like a regulator letting United review and veto Southwest's expansions.John Cochrane on Health Care
- Current policy lets pharmaceutical and hospital systems reach into taxpayer and premium-payer pockets, so prices like $100,000+ per year drugs are not true market prices; if no one could pay, the thing wouldn't exist at that price, and these prices persist only because someone else (taxpayers, insurance pools) is paying via Medicare, Medicaid, and premiums.Ed Dolan on Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance
- The deepest problem in the US healthcare system is cross-subsidies: the government mandates hospitals treat everyone but, unwilling to raise taxes, lets them overcharge private insurance and cash payers; this requires suppressing competition because a competitor offering lower prices would undermine the overcharging, which is why hospitals can hide prices—a sign of an uncompetitive business that competitive industries like airlines could never sustain.John Cochrane