Keith Smith on Free Market Health Care
What this covers
Entrepreneur and anesthesiologist Keith Smith sits with EconTalk host Russ Roberts to examine how the Surgery Center of Oklahoma, a cash-only facility with posted prices, functions as a counterexample to the U.S. health-care system. Smith contends that American health care's dysfunction and soaring costs flow from government incentives and insurance intermediation that break normal market signals. The conversation traces how this particular surgery center achieves lower prices and higher accountability than conventional hospitals, using its model to argue that a genuine market—rather than regulatory relief or payer reform—could restructure the entire industry.
The discussion ranges across several interconnected distortions. Smith explains how insurance companies profit from inflated hospital charges through commission-based discounting, how hospitals exploit federal Disproportionate Share Hospital kickbacks by claiming fictional losses while posting inflated list prices, and how Relative Value Units reward hospital physicians for over-utilization rather than judicious care. He sets the surgery center's two-decade-old, frozen price list against hospital billing and contrasts the incentive alignments: a facility paid for what it does (not what it uses) avoids waste; lack of insurance contracts forces Market Discipline via Reputation; and folding most profits into surgeon fees aligns the center's survival with patient outcomes. Roberts raises Certificate of Need laws as regulatory barriers, while Smith argues that Market Competition Lowers Prices so effectively that even these restrictions lose power when patients can fly elsewhere. The conversation also touches on Canadian wait times, paper versus electronic records, and whether self-funded health plan employers—far larger than commonly understood—might become the engine of systemic change.
Smith argues that the dysfunction and high cost of American health care stem from government-created incentives and insurance intermediation, and that a genuine market—exemplified by his cash-only, price-transparent surgery center—delivers lower prices, higher quality, and accountability that the existing system suppresses.
- Posting all-inclusive cash prices forces price competition and exposes the inflated 'list prices' of conventional hospitals
- Hospital billing is structured around claimed losses that trigger federal kickbacks and insurer commissions, inflating prices
- Disintermediating the system lets a facility pay surgeons more, charge patients less, and stay accountable to reputation
Certificate of Need laws allow incumbent hospitals to block new competitors from entering the market.
- In many states, opening a new hospital requires a Certificate of Need granting permission from existing hospitals that the new facility is needed—and incumbents predictably decide it is not—thereby limiting competition.
“if I want to open a hospital in Oklahoma City, in some states... I have to get permission from the existing hospitals that I would be needed. And strangely enough, existing hospitals often think you're not.”
Price distortions are so extreme that flying employees to foreign facilities remains cheaper than local hospital care.
- The price distortion is so large that self-funded employers will fly employees to distant or even foreign facilities (e.g., an American facility in Cancun with a Mayo-trained surgeon) and pay them cash bonuses with no deductible or out-of-pocket cost, because doing so is still cheaper than the local hospital.
“if you'll do this for us and fly to Mexico to have your surgery there instead of under the American system... we will pay you a check. We will give you money... $5,000.”
True market competition in health care delivery is possible and worth exploring.
- Roberts introduces Keith Smith and welcomes him to the show, stating the topic is the Surgery Center of Oklahoma and the potential for a true market in health care.
“Keith, welcome to EconTalk.”