Causal power
In Koch's argument, the capacity of a physical system to actually affect the world, claimed to be necessary for consciousness and lacking in mere simulations.
As defined in AMA | April 2025
Other definitions
The capacity of a system or element to influence states — extrinsically (affecting other things) or intrinsically (its own current state determining its next state); IIT identifies consciousness with intrinsic causal power.
309 | Christof Koch on Consciousness and Integrated Information
Where it comes up · 3
- 309 | Christof Koch on Consciousness and Integrated Information4 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas3 claims
- AMA | April 20251 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “Causal power” →
- The historical problem of universals plays a crucial role in 18th century philosophical debates: Locke is a conceptualist affirming abstract ideas, Berkeley is a nominalist denying abstract ideas, and Hume is also a nominalist—because of nominalism, Hume rejects conceptions of matter and mind as substances, of causal power, and of infinite space or infinite time.A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas
- There is a crucial distinction between correlation (two events occurring together in conjunction) and causal connection (one event actually causing another), and Locke acknowledges that the idea of causal connection arises only as a voluntary assumption, not as something we perceive—we see only the correlation, not the connection itself.A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas
- A forthcoming bioRxiv paper shows formally (assuming IIT) that two systems can be Turing-equivalent — identical inputs producing identical outputs, indistinguishable functionally — yet radically different phenomenally: a small set of nonlinear gates can have high system-level causal power while a 116-gate von Neumann machine computing the same function has near-zero whole-system causal power, because brain neurons each connect to ~50,000 others with heavy overlap whereas a transistor talks to only two or three, so an LLM can be functionally rich yet not conscious at all.309 | Christof Koch on Consciousness and Integrated Information
- Christof Koch argues simulated minds cannot be conscious because simulations lack causal power—a simulated black hole won't suck you in—but the listener challenges this by noting that a simulated brain hooked to sensors and actuators (as LLMs and self-driving cars already are) does affect the world, questioning whether causal power coupled to the environment is really the criterion that distinguishes conscious from non-conscious simulations.AMA | April 2025
- Consciousness cannot be simulated: just as a simulation of a black hole has no power to bend real spacetime and a rain simulation never gets wet, a computer simulation of even a complete human brain would talk and behave as if conscious but would feel nothing because computation by itself lacks the intrinsic causal power consciousness requires — so true machine consciousness must be physically built via neuromorphic hardware or possibly quantum computers, making consciousness substrate-dependent and ruling out mind uploading.309 | Christof Koch on Consciousness and Integrated Information
- Integrated Information Theory holds that consciousness is not a computation or function but a structure in high-dimensional causal space — a system having intrinsic causal power upon itself, where its current state co-determines its next state — and the more a system can determine its own past and future, the more conscious it is.309 | Christof Koch on Consciousness and Integrated Information
- David Hume will argue that the idea of causal power is reducible to the idea of constant conjunction—we have no empirical basis whatsoever for affirming any actual causal connection beyond the observed conjunction of events—making Hume a skeptic about causal power.A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas
- Causal power can be extrinsic — a charge influencing another charge, or gravity bending spacetime — or intrinsic, where a small network of elements (neurons, transistors) is such that its current internal state determines its next internal state; IIT identifies consciousness with intrinsic causal power, which is fully computable from a complete description of how a system's states evolve, so the theory is operational rather than dualist or mysterious.309 | Christof Koch on Consciousness and Integrated Information