factual
Functional equivalence is not phenomenal equivalence
A forthcoming bioRxiv paper shows formally (assuming IIT) that two systems can be Turing-equivalent — identical inputs producing identical outputs, indistinguishable functionally — yet radically different phenomenally: a small set of nonlinear gates can have high system-level causal power while a 116-gate von Neumann machine computing the same function has near-zero whole-system causal power, because brain neurons each connect to ~50,000 others with heavy overlap whereas a transistor talks to only two or three, so an LLM can be functionally rich yet not conscious at all.
factualpending
Speaker
Christof KochEvidence Quote
“functional equivalent does not equate to phenomenal equivalence... this one is highly conscious, this one isn't conscious at all, which I think is the case for LLMs.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:33 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...