Articles of Confederation
The first U.S. governing document (pre-Constitution) that lacked a president, a taxing Congress, and a federal judiciary; the Constitution was drafted to cure its defects.
As defined in Richard Epstein on the Constitution
Where it comes up · 5
- Michael Munger on Constitutions2 claims
- Doug Irwin1 claim
- Louis Michael Seidman on the Constitution1 claim
- Richard Epstein on the Constitution1 claim
- Joseph Ellis on American Creation and the Founding 09/08/20081 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “Articles of Confederation” →
- The U.S. Constitution was literally unconstitutional: the Articles of Confederation required 13 of 13 states (Wicksellian unanimous consent) to amend, yet the Philadelphia delegates simply decided to ratify by a nine-of-13 rule, ignoring the existing status quo rules—and a new convention would do the same, inventing its own rules rather than respecting the current ones.Michael Munger on Constitutions
- The American Revolution can be understood as an early Brexit: the Founding Fathers wanted political independence but expected to retain market access to the British Empire; Britain instead stripped all economic privileges, the 1780s saw severe trade disruption (arguably worse than the Great Depression for economic activity), and the Constitution itself was largely an outgrowth of the need for unified trade negotiating authority and revenue.Doug Irwin
- The U.S. Constitution succeeded partly by luck: the Articles of Confederation were so bad that they created an enormous 'win-set'—many possible arrangements were better—so the framers could pick one of many superior contingent points, meaning the Constitution's content was contingent rather than the product of unique godlike genius.Michael Munger on Constitutions
- The Constitutional Convention was in effect an enlightened 'coup'—a small group convened ostensibly to revise the Articles of Confederation but who replaced them altogether, without being empowered to do so, and had a modern poll been possible most citizens would have rejected the Constitution.Joseph Ellis on American Creation and the Founding 09/08/2008
- The Constitution itself was created in violation of existing law: the Framers were directed only to propose amendments to the Articles of Confederation, which required ratification by all 13 state legislatures, but they instead wrote a new document, provided for ratification by popularly elected conventions, and declared 9 states sufficient—so the founding document was itself unconstitutional.Louis Michael Seidman on the Constitution
- The Constitution was drafted to cure the defects of the Articles of Confederation—adding a single President, a taxing Congress, and a federal judiciary the Articles lacked—seeking enough centralization for the nation to operate coherently but not so much as to squash individual state variations; it was never designed to create the modern welfare or New Deal state.Richard Epstein on the Constitution