Arrow's impossibility theorem
Kenneth Arrow's result showing that no voting system can perfectly aggregate individual preferences into a coherent social ranking while satisfying a set of reasonable conditions.
As defined in Martha Nussbaum on Creating Capabilities and GDP
Where it comes up · 4
- Garett Jones1 claim
- Martha Nussbaum on Creating Capabilities and GDP1 claim
- 354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality1 claim
- AMA | February 20231 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Arrow's impossibility theorem” →
- Drawing on Gary Miller's Managerial Dilemmas, Arrow's impossibility theorem and Condorcet preference cycling apply inside firms just as in voting, so corporations face the same difficulties making rational decisions; the only solution is to recognize firm culture as an equilibrium to a repeated prisoner's dilemma—a long-run cooperation game—where failed firms are those that failed to coordinate on a good cooperative equilibrium, an insight that explains not just firms but societies as a whole.Garett Jones
- Approval voting is unattractive despite advantages over plurality voting, because the binary approve/disapprove choice discards information about intensity of belief—someone you would go to the mat for and someone you can barely tolerate both receive the same approval—and intensity, not Arrow's theorem, is the more practically important concern in voting design.AMA | February 2023
- Drawing on Nozick's slave parable and Arrow's impossibility work, a single democratic voter has essentially zero sway, so government is not accountable to the individual; it is a lousy system for aggregating preferences that serves powerful people rather than 'us' — there is no 'us.'Martha Nussbaum on Creating Capabilities and GDP
- Social choice theory provides an axiomatic toolkit for evaluating aggregation methods: one formulates desiderata that a good aggregation rule should satisfy and uses mathematical analysis to determine whether rules satisfying them simultaneously exist, yielding either impossibility results like Arrow's theorem or possibility results where compelling criteria uniquely pick out a particular rule, thereby giving strong reasons to adopt it.354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality